3 ms·
> Is it still ad-hominem if you actually agree with Carl? If you conclude X is right because Carl said so, it’s argument from authority. > Doesn't it make Car
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Is it still ad-hominem if you actually agree with Carl?
If you conclude X is right because Carl said so, it’s argument from authority.
> Doesn't it make Carl's argument even stronger when you say "I'm always against Carl but this time he's right" which is the opposite of dismissing his idea, ad hominem or not?
No. It makes his rhetoric (essentially an argument about an argument) stronger. But not argument per se.