2 ms·
The problem with the idea of "base power" is that in the past, the cheapest electricity was from the big thermal generators that take a day to warm up, and oper
by epistasis 1y ago
The problem with the idea of "base power" is that in the past, the cheapest electricity was from the big thermal generators that take a day to warm up, and operate most cheaply by pumping out at maximum efficiency 24 hours a day. You could then layer on the more expensive electricity sources that could spin up in 15 minutes or a few hours, and match the demand curve, as long as you matched baseload generators to the minimum of the demand curve, and have a cost-optimal electricity mix.
Now that we have cheaper sources of energy for parts of the day, "base" power is a much less desirable concept. It's gone from a simple and straightforward optimization problem that a middle-schooler could solve to a cost optimization problem that markets and linear solvers can solve.
Now that we have cheap storage, and solar-plus-storage is cheaper than coal in the UK, the cost optimization is getting simpler: get rid of all the base load coal!
- rgblambda 1y agoDidn't the last coal power plant in the UK close last year?
- DamonHD 1y agoYes, but no GB nukes load-follow either, so the same issue. Economy 7 off-peak rate was invented to soak up some nuke power unused by industry in the night, IIRC. "Cannot turn off" power can be as tricky to manage as "cannot turn on", and caused some difficulty for the GB grid operator during covid...
- energy123 1y agoAs you say, base power is just a concept. It is not a thing that exists in the real world. It's also a bad concept. Electricity demand and supply can be modelled statistically for a significantly better understanding than can be compressed into a single term like "base load". But that doesn't admit for very good rhetoric on internet forums.