9 ms·
Google has an iOS 6 Maps app awaiting approval
- uptown 14y agoOr this story: Source: Google Hopes To Have iOS Maps App In The App Store “Before Christmas” http://techcrunch.com/2012/09/20/crap-maps http://techcrunch.com/2012/09/20/crap-maps
- soupysoupysoup 14y agoHow does "competes with existing functionality" not wake up the antitrust regulators? Wasn't the entire IE shipping with Windows situation based on a competitive functionality?
- nostromo 14y agoFirst Apple would need to be considered a monopoly. They're clearly not a monopoly since there are so many smart phone alternatives available.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoThat's not true, you don't have to be a monopoly to get in trouble for anti-competitive behavior, you just have to be... participating in anti-competitive behavior.
- bluedanieru 14y agoYes, but what's anti-competitive depends on what your market position is.
- fpgeek 14y agoTrue, but a company that is already the target of one antitrust lawsuit probably has less leeway than it used to.
- uptown 14y agoMicrosoft held a monopoly.
- cooldeal 14y agoYes, but Microsoft did not completely ban Netscape from running on Windows like Apple did with podcast apps, Google Voice etc. so the situation is not exactly analogous. Everyone could and many did install Netscape, IE 3+ was just better after Netscape stagnated at version 4 for years because of a rewrite. http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html Microsoft shipped their browser default since an OS without a browser did not make sense. The user was completely free to install any other competing browsers without needing to jailbreak the device. If Microsoft actually stopped Netscape from running, could you imagine the backlash?
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoThat's weird, because I have Google Voice and three other browsers on my iPhone...
- cooldeal 14y agoGoogle Voice was in limbo for over an year, was neither approved nor rejected. And if you the three browsers are equivalent to having a choice of three browsers on the desktop, think again. All of them are forced to use the builtin webkit.
- masklinn 14y ago> Yes, but Microsoft did not completely ban Netscape from running on Windows like Apple did with podcast apps, Google Voice etc. so the situation is not exactly analogous. Which is not relevant, I fear. Action was taken against microsoft because they were a monopoly and used their monopoly position both to hinder potential competition and muscle their way into new markets.
- masklinn 14y ago> antitrust regulators? > antitrust |ˌantēˈtrəst; ˌantī-| > adjective [ attrib. ] > of or relating to legislation preventing or controlling trusts or other monopolies, with the intention of promoting competition in business. In pretty much every thread about Apple on this site, you will be reminded that Android enjoys amazing sales. > Wasn't the entire IE shipping with Windows situation based on a competitive functionality? Microsoft was found to be a de-facto monopoly on the desktop.
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>In pretty much every thread about Apple on this site, you will be reminded that Android enjoys amazing sales. And in the same threads and on Apple blogs like Gruber's and Siegler, you're constantly reminded how it doesn't matter because Apple takes ~75% of the profits, and statistics on how apps are more profitable on iOS because Apple users are the premium users willing to pay and how many Android users are too cheap to buy apps. So if you're an app maker looking to make money, iOS is pretty much close to a monopoly if you're trying to make money.
- tsunamifury 14y agoIts only a monopoly if you are very narrow minded about the market. Brew and J2ME have multi-billion dollar app markets that compete with Apple and Android in terms of volume.
- fpgeek 14y agoCitation please? So far as I know, Nokia was a leader in non/pre-iOS/Android app markets. For some reason I think their results weren't competitive with iOS or even Android...
- soupysoupysoup 14y agoNice phonetics. You're right. No less frustrating though. Anytime I'm denied a choice, especially in the face of enforced inferiority it raises my hackles. Here's hoping all the protesting and ridicule will get the job done.
- michaelkscott 14y agoSeriously, why wouldn't Apple approve it? Which of their terms will this app violate?
- masklinn 14y ago"Duplicates a native service" would be my guess". "We'll refuse what the fuck we want" is an other possibility.
- Tichy 14y agoOr they find some landmarks that are shaped like sexual organs and reject it because of pornographic content.
- talmand 14y agoJust once I'd like to see them issue such a press release.
- jmelloy 14y agoI don't believe they've used that in a while. They let Chrome & Sparrow on without any complaints.
- dvhh 14y agobut they are both severly crippled on iOS, chrome is just a safari skin, and sparrow cannot be used as a default app for mail on iOS cannot use notification for new mail unless using 3rd party services (if you are trusting them with you email credentials).
- CraigRood 14y agoDoesn't that come down to API limitations rather than actual functionality?
- capo 14y agoDuplicates a native service Surly it can't be legal for Apple to potentially reject an app on such grounds?! and on that subject where is the talkative Google search update? http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/building-search-engine-of-future-one.html http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/building-search-engin...
- digitalsushi 14y agoI'm not a lawyer, or even that educated, but I would be highly surprised if Apple couldn't do whatever they wanted with their own app store.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 14y ago> Surly it's not legal for Apple to potentially reject an app on such grounds? Of course it is. The only ways for it to be illegal would be 1. if it infringed on freedom of speech (no way that's going to hold) or 2. an antitrust action (which would require Apple to be a monopoly)
- omgsean 14y agoI don't believe Apple has any responsibility to provide freedom of speech within their closed ecosystem.
- talmand 14y agoYep, typically freedom of speech applies to government censorship. A private party can shut you out of their system as they have no responsibility to provide you with a platform. "Freedom of speech" is so often a misused/misunderstood concept.
- masklinn 14y agoHence "no way that's going to hold"
- nthitz 14y agoEven if it is approved and released shortly it still doesn't solve the problem of it not being the default Map app. Contact links & location links will still open in Apple's Maps. Still waiting on something comparable to Android's Intents in iOS
- sitharus 14y agoThere's already a similar mechanism in the URL handlers, but Apple don't let you choose which application to use if multiple ones are registered. This still bugs me. I'd also like widgets one day.
- masklinn 14y ago> There's already a similar mechanism in the URL handlers, but Apple don't let you choose which application to use if multiple ones are registered. It also doesn't let you override core applications (in that it picks the first one either way), and last time I checked it if two applications registered the same handler and you removed the first one, the association didn't switch to the second one it just broke. May have been fixed since. > I'd also like widgets one day. I just want toggles in the notification bar (DND, airplane, 3G, roaming and location would be sufficient as far as I'm concerned). Instead of the waste of space that Stocks is (yes I know I can remove it from the notification center, and did)
- sitharus 14y ago> > There's already a similar mechanism in the URL handlers, but Apple don't let you choose which application to use if multiple ones are registered. > It also doesn't let you override core applications Hence "Apple don't let you choose which application to use" - it all happens at Apple's whim, and currently that excludes replacing system apps.
- abraham 14y agoThere is a way for iOS apps to prefer Chrome over the default browser so I assume Maps will have the same feature. https://developers.google.com/chrome/mobile/docs/ios-links https://developers.google.com/chrome/mobile/docs/ios-links
- cooldeal 14y agoWonder how this jives with Gruber's comments on the maps situation: >Using Maps to Improve Maps >> Scott Rafer: >>What’s missing from this conversation is that map usage is critical. […] Google’s maps are going to start degrading. Apple’s will get better. They’ll meet in the middle within 18 months. >The idea is that you need to collect usage data to improve your data. The only way for Apple to get from here to there is to release what they have now and improve the data as millions of people start using it. http://daringfireball.net/linked/2012/09/19/rafer-maps http://daringfireball.net/linked/2012/09/19/rafer-maps If Google Maps is approved, far less people would be using Apple Maps.
- capo 14y agoWhy would GMaps degrade in quality? Apple's might improve but Google's are on Android devices, and they have another key data source in StreetView.
- baddox 14y agoAs map data changes over time (road construction, POI movement, etc.), Google Maps could fall out of date. Of course, I doubt that's a major threat, since Google will presumably still be the primary maps platform on Android and the desktop web.
- ktsmith 14y agoHow is Google's data going to fall out of date? There are millions of activated android devices providing them data.
- lftl 14y agoI think Gruber was postulating that Apple would continue updating the app to take advantage of iOS in deeper ways while Google wouldn't put the same level of effort into the iOS version of the app, making it stagnate. So more of degrading of the iOS experience than anything related to map data.
- 14y ago
- ChuckMcM 14y agoOk, this is an interesting twist to the story. See my comments elsewhere on why I don't think an App version of Google Maps would see the light of day (if it did that would definitely count as 'plan C' in my book). Fun times.
- guimarin 14y agoApple lost this particular battle ( mobile search ) the day Google bought Android. OSM is cool as we know, but it was not deployed until now, and the reaction is epic. Apple will fight the good fight like bing is doing in web search, but ultimately will be found wanting, just like bing. The only f-u play Apple has left is to spend billions of dollars making OSM on par with GoogleMaps, contributing that knowledge 'upstream,'watching specialized maps services eat google maps' ad lunch. I seriously doubt that would happen, but it's the only play left. "If I can't play then no one can..."
- Tichy 14y agoI had this idea recently of splitting the internet into two internets: one for Apple fans and one for Apple haters. Apart from getting rid of a lot of flamewars, Apple could rule supreme in the Apple internet, be the best search engine there and so on. If you never know that there are better options, you can be happy.
- toyg 14y agoIt's not just OSM, Apple also gets data from TomTom (since June this year).
- nostromo 14y agoThis map uproar seems a tad hyperbolic. I used it this morning and I was actually pleasantly surprised. My map experience wasn't worse as I expected, but actually much better with turn by turn. The people most upset seem to generally be edge cases. I'm sure Apple will work those out as complaints roll in. Google has had 7 years to perfect maps. Apple feels maybe a year behind in some respects and a year ahead in others, but definitely not 7 years behind.
- sitharus 14y agoIn my city the maps are perfect - in some areas better than Google. They've improved a huge amount since the first iOS 6 betas when whole roads were missing. The business locations are not so great though. It's a big mish-mash of really old data and incorrect locations.
- mikeash 14y agoThere's not much "edge case" about obsolete maps, misplaced businesses and addresses, etc. It's great that it's working for you, but it's a bit annoying for you to just dismiss the trouble that many of us are having like that.
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>The people most upset seem to generally be edge cases I love it how you dismiss 99% of people and the globe as an edge case by your anecdote of it working well for you. Let me take a guess, you live on the West Coast where Apple engineers live?
- kmfrk 14y agoWe're only talking about a demographic of ~5B people and 63 countries, don't be so hyperbolic: http://theunderstatement.com/post/31855177665/quantifying-the-impending-ios-6-maps-backlash http://theunderstatement.com/post/31855177665/quantifying-th....
- nostromo 14y agoThis is exactly my point about the hyperbole. As if 5 billion people are wandering alone in the wilderness today because of a new map app. To quote Steve Jobs, "Relax... it is just a phone."
- mrintegrity 14y agoIs it just me or has Apple "slavishly" copied the google maps app functionality, icons (that arrow looks like a copy paste) and rounded corners? The hypocrisy here is just mind blowing.. And it clearly demonstrates the utter bullshitness that is there fight against Samsung
- ryannielsen 14y agoIf you're accusing Apple of copying iOS 5's Maps app for iOS 6's Maps app, you're accusing Apple of copying itself. Google provided the backend data and map tiles for Maps prior to iOS 6, but Apple wrote the app itself.
- tycorc 14y agoAre you insinuating that apple designed the look for google maps on the iphone? google maps existed long before it was on the iphone, through google.com. The iPhone map looks just like the home browser version. The style looks the same on an android, blackberry and iPhone. Apple ripped off google maps plain an simple, but I agree with the original poster, there is nothing wrong with that, and it just shows how full of BS apple really is.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- shinratdr 14y ago> And it clearly demonstrates the utter bullshitness that is there fight against Samsung The only thing it demonstrates is that you have no idea what you're taking about. The app "functionality" is "being a map" something Google has never patented. The UI elements are Apples, as they designed and built the iOS Maps app. The only thing here that's a slavish copy is your comment. Reminds me strongly of the comments of a million other uninformed idiots that barely understand the concept they are trying to deride, yet insist it is hypocritical. Yeah, it's the worst hypocrisy to use assets you designed and a concept that can't be patented in a new app. I heard Apple has a calendar app too? Is that also a slavish copy of Google Calendar? Apple didn't sue everyone who made a phone FFS. They sued Samsung, a company that genuinely did rip them off and try as hard as they can to present Android and their devices as much closer to the iPhone than anything else. Apple isn't doing a single thing that's similar with Maps. They're just making a Maps app. Google doesn't own the concept of mobile mapping.
- nachteilig 14y agoThank god. I'm holding off on upgrading to iOS 6 until this is released, so it will be very welcome. I live in a city, so accurate location data is important to me (and I prefer not to use the web based google maps because I don't want to give safari permission to use location data)!
- xuki 14y agoNote that you don't have to give location data to all websites. You can allow maps.google.com and deny others.
- qq66 14y agoIf this is true, then Google is making a catastrophically bad tactical error, or Apple Maps are not as horrendously awful as the blogosphere is making them out to be (haven't had a chance to try them myself).
- Tichy 14y agoThis was Apple's decision, not Google's.
- qq66 14y agoSorry - I meant the decision to put an App in the App Store. If the Apple Maps are bad as people seem to be proclaiming, Google should let iOS 6 brew up ill will with Apple's customer base, especially since Apple users tend to upgrade their OS's immediately, and use it to promote Android.
- Tichy 14y agoHm, maybe - but withholding maps from iOS could be considered evil and backfire into Google antipathy. Also I the impact might not be so great after all - fans will be fans...
- runn1ng 14y agoWith their own map app, they can push location-based advertisments and have greater control over it. Google is made on advertisments. Google wants as many people to use its maps as possible.
- randomdata 14y ago> Google wants as many people to use its maps as possible. If that were true, they would offer the service for free. As it stands, for normal contracts, only the first 25,000 requests per day are free[1]. If we assume Google wasn't willing to give Apple a special pricing deal, with 300M+ iOS devices in the wild, Apple could easily be left shelling out a fortune each day to user their data. [1] https://developers.google.com/maps/faq#usage_pricing https://developers.google.com/maps/faq#usage_pricing
- CCs 14y agoHow about TomTom for iPhone? http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/tomtom-u.s.-mexico/id355682375 http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/tomtom-u.s.-mexico/id35568237... Yes, it costs $60 + in-app purchase for more frequent updates, but still, at least it is accurate.
- fpgeek 14y agoUm, doesn't Apple source much of their underlying data from TomTom? Absent incredible stupidity on one side and/or the other could TomTom really be holding out on them?
- cincinnatus 14y agoMapQuest. Free.
- ars 14y agoThis is blogspam. Original: http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/blog/2012/sep/20/apple-google-maps-headache http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/blog/2012/sep/20/apple-...
- kyleslattery 14y agoJim Dalrymple says no: http://www.loopinsight.com/2012/09/20/on-the-rumor-that-google-has-submitted-an-ios-6-maps-app-and-apple-is-sitting-on-it/ http://www.loopinsight.com/2012/09/20/on-the-rumor-that-goog...
- fpgeek 14y agoDueling anonymous sources. Wonderful. That being said, 9to5Mac seems to emphasize that an app was submitted and Jim Dalrymple seems to emphasize that it isn't sitting in review. There's one simple way those could be consistent: an app could have been submitted and rejected. Google's and Apple's different points-of-view might even be giving us the contrasting spins on the situation.
- ghshephard 14y agoThat should be, "Jim Dalrymple, AKA Apple unofficial backchannel hints"
- steevdave 14y agoI really do hope they do. I've been using the beta and all through it, there were no routing apps available for my area (San Antonio, so not exactly a tiny city, according to Wikipedia we are the 7th largest population wise) Now that iOS 6 is out, I decided to give the Maps app a shot again. So I pulled it up, thought for a second since I am used to the old interface, clicked the wrong thing a couple times, finally got to where I needed to go. Scrolled through the saved list of directions that I've used in the past (very helpful). Clicked the bus button. Got routed to the App Store. There were 8 or so apps to pick from. Which ones sucked and which ones didn't, no idea. It's too new to tell. Picked one at random, it's 99 cents, which is fine, I don't mind buying apps. It installs. And then sits there. Wait for a bit, maybe it's thinking or something (I'm on an iPhone 4, not 4S or 5). Okay, it's not. Go back into the maps app. It hasn't saved where I am, I'm back to the default screen. This time I remember so I go back to the directions. Click the bus button. Get routed back to the App Store again. This time the app I have says ROUTE. So I click it. It shows some introduction screen. I click the start button. Directions are blank. Go back into maps, back to the directions, click the bus button, back to the App Store, click the route button, and the in the routing app, are two very different addresses than the ones I entered in to the Maps app. Scratch my head wondering how that happened. Close Maps, close the routing app, delete the routing app, launch maps.google.com, get the bus schedule almost immediately. I have no idea what anyone else's experiences are, but I have never been so disappointed. Now as mentioned, I'm still on the iPhone 4, and I'm at the tail end of the contract, I believe next month is when I qualify for the upgrade without paying full price. I'm seriously looking at the S3, although the new report of the exploit via NFC is a bit troubling. I'm not particularly worried about the apps I've purchased on the iPhone. I've spent maybe 150 on apps on the almost 2 years I've had the phone, and as I was talking about it to a friend, he pointed out that as a smoker, I spend more than that per month on cigarettes, which really put things into perspective for me. Never has Apple tastes so sour.
- bane 14y agohttp://blog.seattlepi.com/microsoft/2008/06/24/full-text-an-epic-bill-gates-e-mail-rant/ http://blog.seattlepi.com/microsoft/2008/06/24/full-text-an-...
- 14y ago
- runjake 14y agoJim Dalrymple (who is an unofficial mouthpiece for Apple) says nope: http://www.loopinsight.com/2012/09/20/on-the-rumor-that-google-has-submitted-an-ios-6-maps-app-and-apple-is-sitting-on-it/ http://www.loopinsight.com/2012/09/20/on-the-rumor-that-goog... If I were Google, I'd hold off on releasing a Maps for iOS just a little while. It's firmly in the "killer app" category at the moment and might help spur Android adoption just a little.
- Steko 14y ago"If I were Google, I'd hold off on releasing a Maps for iOS just a little while. It's firmly in the "killer app" category at the moment and might help spur Android adoption just a little." Based on this logic google should withhold search (after contract runs out) and only serve youtube in VP8. Releasing Maps soon but not immediately for Google (which is what it looks like they are doing) wins in several ways: (1) reap the benefits of Apple's Maps launch negative publicity for a couple weeks. (2) once your app hits, more people are using your services. Google loves people doing this. (3) and less people using Apple Maps and helping improve it. Keeps the gap wide. (4) finally, if not approved, you can use the disapproval as another competitive advantage.
- boundlessdreamz 14y agoNope. Maps is a huge differentiator. Search & Youtube is not. Windows and Android phones have good maps, iOS doesn't. No one will care much if the search is switched to bing or if youtube was not available as an app. Also youtube makes it money via ads which it shows in the latest app. I don't think google is monetizing maps much.
- chrischen 14y agoI agree YouTube may not be, but search is pretty big. However, Google would have a hard time blocking google.com from iPhone users without being anticompetitive. They can not expend the effort to create a google maps app for iphone, but that's not the same as being actively anticompetitive as they would have to be if they wanted to block search from iPhone users.
- gleiva 14y agoAfter checking out the bunch of complaints, I wonder what's going on with Apple's quality process. They must had seen some of this 'roller coaster street' bugs before... They either sacrificed quality for getting the product out soon... Or maybe they are assuming most of fans won't care about the bugs just because they'll get the new phone anyway... Or their quality process just needs some improvements.
- yalogin 14y agoThe problem is there is no other company that does maps and so Apple cannot even buy some one to fill the gap. They are now forced to grow/improve the maps organically, which will take some time. But this is Apple they will get there.