16 ms·
3M May Escape Toxic Chemical, PFAS Manufacturing Legacy
- nakamoto_damacy 1y agoJustice-as-a-Service... The Enterprise subscription tier has a get-out-of-jail feature.
- more_corn 1y ago3M knowingly poisoned every single person in the world for decades. Let them burn, and salt the earth where they fall. These fuckers don’t deserve a second chance. How could they have done it better? Acknowledge the science when the problem was discovered in the 70s, publish the findings, let the scientific community study the problem and let people make informed decisions about the dangers. Had they done that PFAs might still be in use in very controlled circumstances. They certainly wouldn’t be used as waterproofing on our paper plates.
- coryrc 1y ago> Let them burn Who is "them"? The scientists at the time? The managers at the time? The managers now? The stockholders who have already sold and made their profits?
- hobs 1y agoIf we can have a murder investigation and assign partial blame for people that are just there while the crime is being committed, why cant we do it for something that harms the entire human race? Just because we don't have a great framework for something today doesn't mean we should not have it, just that incentives have been against it up to this point.
- bilbo0s 1y ago>If we can have a murder investigation and assign partial blame for people that are just there while the crime is being committed, why cant we do it for something that harms the entire human race? Check the bank balance of the people being convicted for being present when a crime is committed. Compare it to the bank balance of the people who harm the entire human race.
- hobs 1y agoYeah, see my second sentence - throwing up your hands and claiming inaction isn't the way to solve anything. Saying "but the billionaires don't want it!!" sure, let me pre-give up so its super easy for them to keep winning.
- titzer 1y ago> Compare it to the bank balance of the people who harm the entire human race. Yet another reason why we don't need billionaires. No one should have enough money that they can just pay their way through crime after crime.
- coryrc 1y agoWe won't get there by just saying "they" should be punished; most people can agree on that. Be specific on who and how.
- Zigurd 1y agoIsn't one of the answers found in the dubious concept of corporate personhood?
- lm28469 1y ago[flagged]
- naldb 1y ago[flagged]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 1y agoA recent article in The Atlantic said that one scientist would know it's harmful to humans and another would know it's in all human blood and 3M made sure they'd never meet. So the scientist who knew it was harmful didn't know it was everywhere and the scientist who knew it was everywhere didn't know it was harmful. Point is that it's possible to silo scientists in this way so they can't see the big picture.
- doug_durham 1y ago[flagged]
- SirMaster 1y agoSo when the chemicals get into our biological bodies, they hurt us mechanically, not chemically?
- cluckindan 1y agoYes. They repel water, fats and oils. Having waterproof kidneys or a fatproof liver isn’t great for normal functioning of said organs.
- filoeleven 1y agoThey are endocrine disruptors. The levels are not subclinical. > Hormones work at very small doses (part per billion ranges). Endocrine disruption can thereby also occur from low-dose exposure to exogenous hormones or hormonally active chemicals such as bisphenol A. [...] Furthermore, since endogenous hormones are already present in the body in biologically active concentrations, additional exposure to relatively small amounts of exogenous hormonally active substances can disrupt the proper functioning of the body's endocrine system. Thus, an endocrine disruptor can elicit adverse effects at much lower doses than a toxicity, acting through a different mechanism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endocrine_disruptor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endocrine_disruptor > Between 2016 and 2022, the agency worked off an advisory health limit of 70 parts per trillion (ppt) for PFOS and PFOA, two compounds commonly produced and used for decades. Last year, after science showed virtually no level of exposure to drinking water is safe, the EPA set non-enforceable “advisory health limits” of 0.02 ppt and 0.004 ppt for PFOA and PFOS, respectively. > The new legal limits for PFOS and PFOA is 4 ppt each, levels that science shows are still dangerous to drink. Public health advocates say the discrepancy is likely the result of industry pressure on the EPA and an inability of PFAS tests that regulators use to check water for the chemicals at levels as low as 0.02 ppt. https://www.earthisland.org/journal/index.php/articles/entry/epa-sets-limits-on-6-toxic-pfas-or-forever-chemicals-in-drinking-water https://www.earthisland.org/journal/index.php/articles/entry...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- TheRealNGenius 1y ago[dead]
- yapyap 1y agoI’m sure they’ll get off legally (just donate to the sitting president) but for the people affected by their practices they will be hard pressed to turn their legacy around.
- myrmidon 1y agoI think it is incorrect to blame this on a currently corrupt president. Counter-hypothesis: This is a systemic issue. Decisionmakers and shareholders that cause harm face very little consequences if their behavior does not violate the letter of the law. Compare the leaded gas debacle: US lead industry suppressed knowledge about harmful effects, and even directly targeted researchers with smear-campaigns and lawfare for decades, but faced no real legal consequences once everything came to light.
- im3w1l 1y agoI think it's even more systemic. The public knows about the harm and they are ok with it. They think the benefits outweigh the risks.
- myrmidon 1y agoThis sounds bleak, but I'm pretty sure that any improvement (more justice/corporate responsibility) would at least not be free: It would also have chilling effects on research/innovation from perceived legal risk and higher costs (because the customer always pays in the end, which also applies to indirectly legally prescribed risk mitigation). It is plausible to me that the public is "close to correct" in its current stance, and I would at least not dismiss that notion out of hand!
- pengaru 1y agoThe public is driven by convenience, and it's extremely convenient to prefer believing purported long-term harms are fake news, when that belief enables enjoying practically every other short-term convenience available to them
- the-chitmonger 1y agohttps://archive.ph/6dfLp https://archive.ph/6dfLp
- jmyeet 1y agoLet's compare to Purdue and the Sacklers, shall we? Purdue owns a huge piece of the responsibility for the opioid epidemic. They created OxyContin and lied about it's addictiveness. They are probably responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people at this point. The Sacklers were heavily involved in all aspects of this and became billionaires because of it. Nobody has been criminally charged. The government tried to give them a Jeffrey Epstein level pass by essentially allowing them to pay a few billion dollars over 20 years, which essentially amounted to interest off their ill-gotten gains. Last I heard an appeals court said no, you can't do that and release liability. This really was a slap on the wrist. Now compare this to what China does [1][2][3]. Remember how all those people went to jail for mortgage fraud after 2008? Oh wait... And now? We just sell pardons [4]. This sort of thing used to cause a scandal (eg [5]). [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/nov/24/china-executes-milk-scandal-pair https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/nov/24/china-executes... [2]: https://www.npr.org/2025/03/01/nx-s1-5308604/alibaba-founder-jack-ma-returns-5-years-after-largely-disappearing-from-public-view https://www.npr.org/2025/03/01/nx-s1-5308604/alibaba-founder... [3]: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-45728459 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-45728459 [4]: https://abcnews.go.com/US/trumps-flurry-pardons-include-campaign-contributors/story?id=122313284 https://abcnews.go.com/US/trumps-flurry-pardons-include-camp... [5]: https://www.propublica.org/article/the-shadow-of-marc-rich https://www.propublica.org/article/the-shadow-of-marc-rich
- Isamu 1y agoI agree there can be better accountability but China is not a shining example of anti-corruption, there it is used to destroy your political enemies and to increase your political power. Here the issue is probably that the political parties shield their rich donors.
- gruez 1y ago>Nobody has been criminally charged. The government tried to give them a Jeffrey Epstein level pass by essentially allowing them to pay a few billion dollars over 20 years Doesn't that settlement only cover civil claims? It doesn't grant them immunity over any criminal claims. It's more correct to say that they didn't bother prosecuting them criminally (possibly because it's hard to do so), and got a civil settlement instead because the evidentiary standards are lower. > which essentially amounted to interest off their ill-gotten gains. They offered to pay $6B of $11B gains. Maybe you think they should have been fined $100 trillion or whatever for all the harm they caused, but that money doesn't exist, and moreover it's unclear whether a long drawn out legal battle would result in more money than the settlement they offered. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-06-27/purdue-s-bankruptcy-went-too-far https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-06-27/purdue...
- calvinmorrison 1y agolimited liability corporations are the root of all evil.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- khaki54 1y agowithout Limited Liability Companies, a civil matter as simple as a copyright lawsuit could permenently bankrupt a small business and take the owners house and all their assets. I don't agree with companies wantonly externalizing their costs onto the environment or the populace such as Dow or 3M poisoning the entire planet. Criminal liability never goes away for serious crimes, whether sole-proprietership, LLC, or Corp. We need to actually start jailing people though
- lm28469 1y ago> copyright Another thing we should flush down the drain to begin with
- jMyles 1y agoNo flushing is necessary; it is conceptually fading on the internet whether the state acknowledges it or not. It'll be great if some solemn elder-statesmen step up and read the writing on the wall instead of throwing more tantrums, but I think it's beyond obvious now that the internet will not abide copyright.
- calvinmorrison 1y ago> could permenently bankrupt a small business and take the owners house and all their assets. A small business, which practically is comprised of - in the US in most cases 1 employee, or maybe 1-3 employees, most likely related. That person, who you say did a copyright issues, but maybe I say, accidentally used a chopsaw on someones hand... they're liable. some fake paper does not reduce liability.
- 1y ago
- IlikeKitties 1y agoSo, what is anyone gonna do about? Do YOU want to sacrifice your life to play supermario bros against the Managers and CEOs responsible for that? Are they even alive anymore?
- throwhuppla 1y ago[flagged]
- starwatch 1y agoIf you want more context on PFAS, I recommend this Veritasium video [0]. It expanded on my usual thought of "PFAS = bad," explaining why non-stick cookware is probably fine while other forms of PFAS are problematic. The video also covers the environmental damage caused by PFAS manufacturing. [0]: https://youtu.be/SC2eSujzrUY https://youtu.be/SC2eSujzrUY
- ck2 1y agoskiers have been putting teflon wax on their skis for decades now it's in the snow, ground, and water-supply forever
- lm28469 1y agoYou forgot rain. Maybe one day people will remember we're just sharing one small planet, the air, the water, the food supplies, ... all the shit you dump/burn ends up in your food or water eventually
- pengaru 1y ago> all the shit you dump/burn ends up in your food or water eventually but most that shit doesn't survive the journey intact, being out in the elements and bombarded by the sun isn't kind to most things hence the focus on "forever chemicals"
- ZeroCool2u 1y agoReally well written, so here's a gift link: https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2025-3m-pfas-toxic-legacy-turnaround/?accessToken=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJzb3VyY2UiOiJTdWJzY3JpYmVyR2lmdGVkQXJ0aWNsZSIsImlhdCI6MTc1OTg1MTM5NCwiZXhwIjoxNzYwNDU2MTk0LCJhcnRpY2xlSWQiOiJUM0VFS0JHUEZIUU8wMCIsImJjb25uZWN0SWQiOiJBMTc4NDk2MTA2M0M0RDBBQjdCRENDN0NCMEVERDIxRSJ9.mM8h26C6T4AInAF5Cgxgmtb8IN7MfTTFLRfzyFptmL0 https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2025-3m-pfas-toxic-legacy...
- siliconc0w 1y agoI don't think most people understand that the damage from PFAS is generational and cumulative. You can isolate zebrafish, expose the first generation, and you'll see abnormalities generations later even those those fish were never exposed. That is their legacy - it's civilization-level harm.
- ninininino 1y agoI've been struggling to understand why people care more about Gaza, Ukraine, BLM, or trans bathrooms than issues like PFAS proliferation and ultimately came to the conclusion that people really just don't care about hypothetical future generations as much as the present. You can point and say "look, this action doesn't affect you much and just makes a 0.01% difference, but it will effect 100,000 future generations of life on this planet and can never be reversed" and people will still say "wow that's sad, but there are people starving in Country A" and be much more concerned. I guess it's us that are the weird ones.
- Liquix 1y agoA person’s toothache means more to that person than a famine in China which kills a million people. A boil on one’s neck interests one more than forty earthquakes in Africa. Think of that the next time you start a conversation. - Dale Carnegie
- graemep 1y agoPeople do care about climate change and lots of other long term things. People care about things that there are campaigns about, that get media coverage. They also avoid thinking about things that they think cannot be changed. These are correlated: if there is a campaign to change something people think it cannot be changed.
- cyanydeez 1y agoWell, people do care about PFAS, global warming, environmental degradation...it's just htey've decided the solution is _depopulation_. They're fighting over the very carrying capacity of an earth that no ones going to fix. So, like, you realy think israel, russia, america, china, india are all flirting heavily with fascism because of their religion, nationalism, isolationism? Or is it more likely they're trying to isolate themselves from humanity to reduce the overall social costs. Biollionaires out there building their bunkers, and here we are...
- tristor 1y agoThe only way to escape PFAS is to go to a different planet. 3M and Dow have poisoned the entire world. It's shocking how much effort and money I have had to invest to try to mitigate this problem as much as possible in my own home, not because the alternatives are expensive, but because of how pervasive PFAS use is and how it contaminates everything. Every single decision-maker involved should have been jailed.
- leobg 1y agoWhat have you done in your own home? I’d be curious to know.
- tristor 1y ago> What have you done in your own home? I’d be curious to know. I've gotten rid of anything in my kitchen that I can that contains PFAS or is produced with PFAS or PFOAs. I use cast iron or stainless steel cookware, glass and silicone only for things that cannot be made of stainless steel. I've more or less eliminated plastics as much as possible from the kitchen. Unfortunately, I can't necessarily do that with food packaging, but even there when I have an option I will change brands or stores to buy things without plastic packaging, or paper packaging coated in PFAS/Teflon. Similarly to avoid PFAS and other chemicals in the production of plastics, as well as microplastics, I almost exclusively buy clothing made entirely from natural fibers. Beyond that, I have a whole home water filtration system, and after that whole home filtration system I additionally run an undersink 5-stage RO system, both of which are NSF/ANSI certified (53 for the filter system and 58 for the RO system) to remove PFAS and PFOAs. I also go out of my way to find and buy products that don't contain added PFAS, because unfortunately PFAS are in many basic everyday household products like dishwasher detergent, rinse aid, laundry detergent, fabric softener, and the like. If you dig into this you will be disturbed at how many things have PFAS intentionally added to them, and then you will be even more disturbed to find out how many things contain PFAS incidentally, mostly due to contaminated water supplies. Even with all of this effort, and more I'm not detailing in this comment, I am exposed to PFAS in the food supply and water supply daily, and in a myriad of other ways. It's impossible to avoid, even with a major budget and being extremely conscious of this issue. There is no way to get away from it. The entire world is contaminated. I don't even know how much my mitigations have any helpful effect towards my health, because it's so difficult to mitigate.
- mNovak 1y agohttp://archive.today/6dfLp http://archive.today/6dfLp
- thelastgallon 1y agoMercury, Lead, PFAS, thousands of additives in plastics. What else?
- rasz 1y agoDont forget rubber additives (6PPD)!
- benabbott 1y agoI wonder if the manufacture and subsequent planet-wide spread of novel chemicals before their impact on life is fully understood is a great filter... We've had plastics for, essentially, 100 years. PFAs for a bit less than that. We still don't understand their full impact on the body/life.
- bokohut 1y agoI would encourage every single person reading this to have your water tested for PFAs. Several years ago now an executive friend at WLGore, yes the very place that created it, gave me some information in passing. It was the kind of information in hearing from one someone you know that makes one pause for a moment in hearing it but then when one considers time against the statement it became less alarming in that moment. Now years of time have passed since that conversation occurred and the statements have manifested into reality. I live literally down stream from WLGore and they have been dumping the toxins in the waterway for decades. Our local jurisdictions have been talking on PFAs for a few years now and in January of this year my time was up on my friends statement made years prior. I spent months doing research and in April I had our water tested. The EPA recommends 4 part per trillion is "safe" but in reality my conversation with medical professionals state NO amount of consumption is safe. My water test came back at 70 parts per trillion and I immediately purchased the special filtering needed to remove PFAs and installed it on our existing water filtering within days. I have also bought a whole house PFA filter that I intend to install in the coming weeks yet our water we drink, cook, and make ice with has been clean for months now as the post drinking system PFA filter test reflected <1 part per trillion. No matter your wealth no one can purchase time, the only way to obtain more time is with your health. Test your water because what you cannot see matters most!