4 ms·
> "But why are you only assuming a usage time of 3 years?" Your entire analysis rests on this point, which you fail to demonstrate. (You also cite zero sources
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> "But why are you only assuming a usage time of 3 years?"
Your entire analysis rests on this point, which you fail to demonstrate. (You also cite zero sources, which isn't encouraging.)
(EDIT: This assumption is conservative, but reasonable.)
Was this AI generated?
> The cable itself costs virtually nothing
Did you attempt to look up the cost of laying new fibre trunk?
> due to their Satellites now being massively overbooked, speeds went down months to months
Then this isn't a remote location. Starlink's economics have been pretty obvious for anyone who has been on a plane, boat or train in the last decade. They're also terrifically useful for remote mining, observation and military operations.
> people noticed that it is actually cheaper to run 10 KILOMETERS / 6 Miles of Fiber cable through the jungle
Well sure, if you ignore negative exernalities a lot of stuff is cheap.
- stronglikedan 1y ago> Was this AI generated? It's crazy to me that people use AI to generate comments for social sites of all things, but here we are.
- Fischgericht 1y agoI find it even more crazy that you no longer can comment on HN without someone trying to invalidate valid points by claiming you not being human. :) To be honest, while I took it lightly, others might feel pretty insulted by such claims. De-humanizing someone stinks.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> you no longer can comment on HN without someone trying to invalidate valid points by claiming you not being human I made this mistake, but I'll defend it by pointing out that I've gone a few comments deep on HN, thinking through and citing and engaging in good faith, only to realise I wasn't talking to a human but to a bot. (Then the commenter gets defensive about using a bot, hallucinations and all.) Instead of taking it as a personal insult, maybe interpret it as your comment having inspired someone to engage effortfully with what you said.
- Fischgericht 1y agoWow. Well, I believe that YOU are a bot, not me. Are you Grok? Anyway, yes, I am a human. And it is not that hard to find the sources for this point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Starlink_and_Starshield_launches https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Starlink_and_Starshiel... v1 constellation was completed in 2021, and decommissioned from 2024. v2 deployed from 2023, but the sat-to-sat communication is not working, so all of them, will need to be replaced by v3, too.
- hughes 1y agoWhy do you believe the inter-satellite links are not working?
- Fischgericht 1y ago[Due to the part of the spectrum I am on, I do not have believes or opinions.] The laser based inter-links still not working has been subject on various conferences like AngaCOM etc. But in my case: I have simply tried it *). And every Starlink user can do it, too: Use traceroute. And if you think "they might be hiding the hop-to-hops between Sats!", you can dig deeper using MTR behind the modem or simply rooting the modem itself. Last time I have connected to a v3 Sat however was ~6 months ago. Maybe an active user reading this can try today?
- niwtsol 1y agoDo you have a link to a blog or writeup regarding the inter-links not working? Hard to find it without getting lost in "Troubleshoot your starlink device" SEO hell.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Do you have a link to a blog or writeup regarding the inter-links not working? The simpler answer is intra-constellation communication is a bleeding-edge technology. It's an extraordinary challenge for which extraordinary proof is needed to show success, not the other way around. SpaceX has solved most of the gating technical problems. But getting it to work reliably enough that it becomes more economic than ground-based backhaul will take time.