3 ms·
New California law restricts HOA fines to $100 per violation
- leakycap 1y agoThe quotes from the pro-HOA side in this article make me think even $100 is too much power to give these people.
- kstrauser 1y agoNo kidding! > “You don’t have the leverage anymore to get people to change bad behavior,” Zepponi said. A neighbor who leaves their RV parked on the driveway in violation of association rules might just eat the $100 rather than pay for RV storage that is more expensive, he said. Yes, god forbid someone have the legal right to park their vehicle at their own house. I'd prefer my neighbors not do that, but I'd also like to have that right for myself if I ever needed to. And a friend had a ration of hassle when he replaced the back door on his house with one that wasn't an approved design. I'm certain he'd have been delighted to say "whatever, Karen, here's your $100 and STFU."
- ToucanLoucan 1y agoI've lived next to two different households who leave campers in their driveways all summer, between uses. I have never given a shit nor can I comprehend the mind of someone who does. I'm convinced HOAs are a product of privileged brains so used to things going their way that they have to make some shit up to act annoyed about.
- smelendez 1y agoYeah, I think letting HOAs regulate too much is actually bad public policy because it encourages petty conflict that does more harm than any good that could from houses having RVs in their driveways or whatever.
- ip26 1y agoHave you ever lived in a townhome or condo? I feel the need to note that those HOA are responsible for the maintenance, repair, and upkeep of everything outside the drywall. Owner overfills dumpster? HOA is fined by sanitation. Owner dumps water on sidewalk, water freezes, neighbor slips and falls? HOA may be liable. You might celebrate, because “down with the HOA!” but when the roof needs to be replaced, it’s paid for by the HOA bank account. If that’s empty, either the roof is left to leak or you are paying a special assessment. I’m a bit biased, I’ll admit, as I once served on such an HOA that was near the brink of insolvency and wrestling with owners who would dodge their share of funding basic maintenance for years at a time. Most of the ire, perhaps, is really directed at single-family HOAs, however.
- KumaBear 1y agoSounds like a poorly managed HOA fund. If they can’t make repairs without fees
- ip26 1y agoCorrect. Owners protested any time raising dues was proposed, and so the old board did not raise dues by any meaningful amount for a few decades while costs rose and the exteriors aged. Unfortunately, while this was clearly a mistake in retrospect, the milk was already spilt.
- dilyevsky 1y agoIn California the board can raise fees 20% a year without requiring a vote.
- kstrauser 1y agoA community fund to pay for basic shared necessities is one thing. I know people who chip in to support a shared local swimming pool. I think that sort of thing for HOAs is beautiful. It's basically a hyper-local government where you're voting to pay extra taxes to have nice quality of life things. And then their are HOAs who have strong opinions about which species of grass your lawn can have. That's that craziest, power-trippingest thing I can imagine. I'm glad the state is telling them to get out of the law enforcement business.
- bluedino 1y agoWe have a neighbor with two campers, and a boat. They move them around every 10 days so they don't get a ticket. They also have 7-8 vehicles, and to top it off the person who lives there is a mechanic that works out of his home garage so there's always all kinds of random cars parked there as well.
- kstrauser 1y agoThat may be a zoning issue if they're illegally operating a business in a residential neighborhood. Forget the HOA. The local city government is probably the right jurisdiction to address that.
- ToucanLoucan 1y agoWhat bearing does this have on your life? Genuine question.
- technion 1y agoI do not at all understand how these things exist. I read that the argument is it drives up property values. But how many people just avoid buying under such ridiculous rules? Doesn't that just lower value?
- tiahura 1y agoIt looks trashy. Just like Christmas lights left up after the holidays and pink flamingos in the yard. Communities should be empowered to self-regulate.
- dev1ycan 1y agoYet in other parts of the world you don't have this problem... maybe you need to teach people etiquette and "style" rather than use HOAs to try to correct people by force
- anticorporate 1y agoOne man's trash...
- dilyevsky 1y agoThat but also it's a fire hazard and it causes spillover of parking into the streets.
- kstrauser 1y agoThat's all a matter of opinion. Some people like lawn flamingos. I don't, but why should I have the power to tell my neighbor they can't put a flamingo in the yard they own? At the moment, I have a sign supporting a sports team my wife and I like. My neighbor can have a lawn flamingo I don't like, and I can have a team sign they don't like. Any other way seems like absolute madness to me.
- tiahura 1y agoBecause part of the agreement to buy the house includes agreeing to the HOA. Your neighbors have a reasonable expectation that their neighbors will abide by the community rules. If one wants to do their own thing, they should live somewhere that doesn’t come with built-in rules.
- dilyevsky 1y agoI'm on the board of smallish HOA (townhouses and condos), a few points: 1. 90% of enforcement is a result of someone's complaint. HOAs can be sued by belligerent owners for not enforcing rules and it will cost everyone in the association a shitload of money. 2. Of those complaints probably at least 80% are totally legitimate grievances because the owner is doing something that's negatively affecting all of their neighbors like say park their RVs in the driveway and then 5 more cars in the shared parking spaces around the neighborhood so nobody else can park when having guests. 3. Every time we decided not to fine someone to force compliance we ended up regretting it - that just resulted in more complaints, sometimes escalations and serious damages, threats of lawsuits, and in the end we had to fine anyway. 4. These days when someone complains i just tell them there's nothing we can do because we really can't and just bug their state legislators, who seems to be living on a different fucking planet. tl;dr - most people complaining about HOAs just have no fucking clue what they are talking about and they never served on the board. Well guess that also applies to every other issue discussed on the internet.
- esseph 1y agoYep, once again why I will never, ever, EVER, live some place with an HOA.
- dilyevsky 1y agoYou don't have much of a choice if you want to buy a condo. Also have fun dealing with your neighbors craziness on your own, i'm sure most folks here are well equipped for that judging by comments...
- firesteelrain 1y agoI am on a HOA Board and our fines are so low that it would take a long time before we can foreclose on the property. Most correct the issue but then re offend. The way the rules are written we can’t make it more stringent like some homeowners would like unless there is a majority vote. We can’t even get people to attend monthly meetings or utilize the website.
- firesteelrain 1y agoThere is leverage. I am not sure why HOAs in California are not using the foreclosure option for failing to pay fines. It’s not a fast process.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mc32 1y agoYes and no. HOAs can be a PITA and petty and I err on the side of less governance but some people are recalcitrant, stubborn and just set in their ways. It's a damned if you do and damned if you don't. HOAs are usually clear in their rules, so if you want to live in a predictable neighborhood you can choose to live in one. IF you want more laisses faire neighborhoods you can pick one that does not have an HOA.
- mcny 1y agoExcept when most of the city lives in an HOA, it is very difficult to convince the city to spend money in public works. Less public spending => lower taxes => less money for public spending
- firesteelrain 1y agoLogic doesn’t make sense - it’s less for cities or counties to worry about because code enforcement and upkeep is outsourced to a certain extent
- jjav 1y ago> HOAs can be a PITA and petty and I err on the side of less governance but some people are recalcitrant, stubborn and just set in their ways. Recalcitrant about what? About using their own private property in a way they want (that doesn't violate city/state law)? Well yes, they sure should be. It needs to be illegal for any HOA to have any say about that.
- hn_throwaway_99 1y agoI previously lived in a condo building. I was unfortunately unlucky to have a really shitty neighbor (and I liked and got along well with everyone else on my floor). This neighbor, who was in her 40s, was apparently a trust-funder that came from a wealthy family and she didn't work, and thus would have parties at 4 AM on Monday morning (among others). She ruined my quality of life. Originally the condo association gave her some minimal fines, but she was wealthy enough that it was just part of the cost of the party - I'm sure she had bottles of booze that cost more that $100 at her parties. It was only when the condo association changed the rules to implement an escalation series (i.e first violation was $X, second was $2X, third was $4X, etc.) that her behavior started to change. I get that a lot of people hate HOAs and I understand the reasons, but $100 is essentially nothing to a lot of people in California, which means HOAs will essentially have no enforcement mechanisms. This is especially a problem in multifamily buildings like condos where people are literally living on top of one another. IMO seems like just another well-intended CA regulation that will cause a lot of negative, poorly thought-out consequences. At the very least I think it would make a lot more sense to have the fine limit be based on the value of the house or something similar, and not a single rate for all of CA.
- behringer 1y agoI'd say too bad. You should ask your local politician for a noise ordinance and then call the police and have them apply the law. HOAs should be illegal. There should only be one government body, if there has to be one at all.
- hn_throwaway_99 1y agoWe did have a noise ordinance, and I did call the police on them. I can only wish that you get a neighbor like I had one day.
- kstrauser 1y ago"Hi, police! My neighbor's having a raging party that's winding down, and a bunch of drunk people are about to hit the streets. Want to arrest a bunch of drunk drivers tonight?" No one wants to party where the cops routinely show up. Honestly, some of these things are so easy nip in the bud.
- rdoherty 1y agoI'm a HOA president and while HOAs can be very extreme, the flip side is if homeowners are breaking rules designed to protect property or common areas (pool, lawns, playground, etc) a $100 is not enough to stop people. Thankfully our HOA focuses on our common areas and is responsible for all exteriors and lawns (it's all townhomes), so the lines are a bit clearer. We've had all sorts of wild issues such as building scaffolding on top of balconies (not attached), ripping up common area plants, parking issues (we all have garages, street parking is guest only), drying food on the pool deck (really), dumping garbage bags outside in the common area and more. If we can only levy a $100 fine there's little incentive for some people to stop doing things that impact the community. I do cringe when I hear about these crazy HOAs of what are usually a collection of single family homes. I think a better approach would be some kind of limitations of the what HOAs can have rules about vs the penalties. Interiors of homes should be generally off limits (aside from townhomes that are all technically 1 building, so you should not be doing anything structural without approval). For single family homes with private property surrounding them I'd rather there be limits that are purely for safety, legal reasons or impacting common areas.
- tdb7893 1y agoIt wouldn't surprise me if it's still a net positive, even with the downsides. Also the article says there are carveouts for health and safety, I wonder if excessive noise at night counts as a health issue (there's more than enough research on how important sleep is where it wouldn't be absurd to have it as part of the health carveout).
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> homeowners are breaking rules designed to protect property or common areas Fines are administrative. If someone is causing property damage, that’s liability—indemnification (where the homeowner pays the HOA’s legal fees) should be sufficient.
- threatofrain 1y agoProtect property [value] may have been what they meant. For example, every single home looking like they're from a quaint village.
- cr125rider 1y agoPeople review HOA docs by law, with fines detailed in them before purchasing a property. This is California trying to save stupid people from themselves, yet again. Remember when they basically allowed crime?
- kstrauser 1y agoGovernments places all kinds of restrictions on what you can and can't enforce with a contract. Why are you opposed to representative democracy?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- sytse 1y ago[flagged]
- dfajgljsldkjag 1y agoThanks chatgpt
- sytse 1y agoThanks for the comment. This was part of my 2 comment experiment to see if ChatGPT summaries would be appreciated. The only other comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45477313 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45477313 got a downvote. So they are not appreciated and I won't post any more.
- sytse 1y agoThe other post went from 0 to 5, people do appreciate it. I'll continue the experiment but under another account.
- SilverElfin 1y agoI think the issue isn’t that HOA fines are a problem. It’s more that some of them have corrupt governance with little transparency and limited ways to break up a group of people that all vote and act in alignment to each other rather than the interests of the community. Another problem is that in some areas, virtually all construction comes with HOAs so there isn’t an element of choice for buyers to opt out. That’s maybe a problem with competition, especially where big builders buy up large tracts of land and build hundreds of homes, all subject to the HOA. If people have choice and reasonable guarantees of good governance, then I don’t have an issue with HOAs. In practice, it’s a mixed bag. But we should remember that even though we hear outrageous HOA stories, by and large, most of them function without such frustrations. So restricting all HOAs in response to those few stories, feels like it will backfire.
- kstrauser 1y agoI think there's little chance it'll back fire. Most of America for its history, and most of the rest of the world, got by just fine without them.
- gullywhumper 1y agoShould the government of California lead by example and also limit the maximum level of fines levied by any entity within the state (state, county, city, or other org)? Why is a fine levied by an HOA any different than an org at one of those other levels of governance from the perspective of democracy? Seems to me, many of the same people cheering this law, also bemoan 'attacks on democracy' from the federal gov't. So what is the right level of democracy?