3 ms·
> Economists work from assumptions All models start with givens…
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Economists work from assumptions
All models start with givens…
- idiotsecant 1y agoWhich is fine, as long as your assumptions are good models of reality. When your assumptions are essentially articles of faith your models tend to be about as good as the guys who interpret patterns in chicken bones.
- aorist 1y agoYou need assumptions exactly for the things which cannot be tested against reality. Otherwise why assume rather than measure?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Otherwise why assume rather than measure? You need a model to design an experiment. This is how all science is done. You hypothesize. Then experiment.
- quantumgarbage 1y agoSure, that does not mean all models are equal. Economics both describe and prescribe, so those models should be evaluated on their predictive power and on whether they have actually done any good.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> that does not mean all models are equal Sure. Nobody claimed that. I’m just pointing out that being upset that a model makes assumptions is nonsense.
- quantumgarbage 1y agoWe are questioning the assumptions themselves, not the act of making them. (I don't feel like anyone is upset?)