4 ms·
There is no such thing as "statistical murder". No crime was committed here. I don't like health chain consolidation either, but words mean things.
by tptacek 1y ago
There is no such thing as "statistical murder". No crime was committed here. I don't like health chain consolidation either, but words mean things.
- AdieuToLogic 1y ago> There is no such thing as "statistical murder". Sure there is. Denying categories of potentially life-saving treatments due to provincial laws causing hospitals to value legal considerations over medical decisions is one example. Perhaps the phrase "statistical manslaughter" is a better description however.
- zmgsabst 1y agoI don’t think you need the statistical: If you engage in behavior with known and predictable risks, which then kills somebody, it is manslaughter. Like recklessly operating a vehicle or blindly throwing knives. That sometimes your behavior doesn’t kill people is immaterial — manslaughter is being intentionally risky in your actions which leads to a death. Or in the case of UnitedHealthcare, felony murder: their felony fraud in issuing false denials for their clients resulted in deaths — and deaths that result from a felony have a special charge.
- AdieuToLogic 1y ago> If you engage in behavior with known and predictable risks, which then kills somebody, it is manslaughter. > That sometimes your behavior doesn’t kill people is immaterial — manslaughter is being intentionally risky in your actions which leads to a death. I was thinking more about laws enacted in the last couple of years in various US states which have guaranteed a rise in pregnancy-related deaths[0]. 0 - https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/04/u-s-pregnancy-related-deaths-continuing-to-rise/ https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/04/u-s-pregnancy...
- FireBeyond 1y ago> Or in the case of UnitedHealthcare, felony murder: their felony fraud in issuing false denials for their clients resulted in deaths — and deaths that result from a felony have a special charge. Sadly, the insurers have a defense to this, and it has largely held up in court: "We did not deny that person the healthcare that could save their life. We just declined to be the party to pay for it."
- 1oooqooq 1y agono self respecting judge would accept that claim if there was no good faith behind it, such as returning premiums paid so they can pay for it themselves.
- axus 1y agoVarying degrees of negligence? Drink a lot and drive, your chance of homicide goes up.
- tptacek 1y agoEvery health system in the world makes decisions that result in deaths that could have been avoided had other decisions been made. I don't like many of the decisions our shambolic health system makes. But none of it is "murder".
- jack_h 1y agoI want to highlight your point because you're correct and this is something that a lot of people don't understand about economic systems. We exist in a resource constrained system. There are finite medical workers, finite time, finite medicine, finite medical facilities, finite medical equipment, and just finite resources in general. There will always be shortages and surpluses in such a system as resource allocation is never perfect. If you have a shortage you must ration supply through some mechanism. It can be by prices, by queue, by need, by lot, by status, or countless other mechanisms or combinations of mechanisms but you must ration regardless. This will lead to people dying under certain conditions who may not have died if some other rationing mechanism was used, but if a different rationing mechanism was used then a different set of people would have died. The only thing that can be done is to select the system that allocates resources more efficiently than other systems to minimize this failure mode. This whole idea of "statistical murder" would just lead to the banning of medical care entirely as no system has perfect allocation at all times, although some are certainly worse than others. Plus I have no idea what the word "statistical" even means in this context...
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoOur system isn't this resource constrained though. Our system has evolved unintentionally to allocate things this way, but our system does in fact have the resources. In fact, we have so much resources/efficiency/excess we have all kinds of labs/practices doing all kind of optional procedures across the entire country. So many that wait times are really really low for those elective procedures. Example. I live in a mountain town. Our ER takes hours. I can go to one of the multiple nearby doc in a boxes and get seen in 15 minutes. My town HAS the resources to see those people waiting in the ER. We just don't allocated the resources that way. My town is a ski town. We have WAY more orthopedic surgeons than we need, but it's extra profitable for them here and living rich in a remote ski town is nice. My tiny town has multiple beauty skincare facilities with licensed doctors on staff. It's not a 'we don't have resources' it's a 'we don't prioritize these lives'. Which is fine. But don't lie to us and say there aren't medical resources.
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoFord Pintos exploded way to easily. Ford chose not to fix it because it would cost them $11 per car. It was later revealed that Ford presented flawed data and bad math to hide even cheaper options to fix the Pinto. In the modern world people can choose obvious evil choices because it makes them money, but because the damage is spread across the entire world and only slightly makes peoples lives worse it is ignored. Our laws are setup for a world like this. But there needs to be then same sort of legal incentives to keep people in line at this scale. Where if your choice results in one million human years wasted/made worse, society sure a shit is going to punish you hard because it benefits society to not waste one million human years.