2 ms·
> Well, I guess there wouldn't be anything wrong with sending back wine, if wine tasters were at all consistent rather than just trying to show off their refine
by dllthomas 14y ago
> Well, I guess there wouldn't be anything wrong with sending back wine, if wine tasters were at all consistent rather than just trying to show off their refinement.
Sending it back in order to signal refinement is jerk behavior, agreed.
As to the other half of it, though, why should I have to be consistent? I am paying for a bottle of wine I like. I am paying more for it because society gives us the option of sending it back. If I don't like the wine, or don't think others at the table will, there's nothing wrong with exercising that option - it just needs to be done in good faith.
- SilasX 14y agoI thought that was the point of the rest of the 2nd paragraph: everything we see indicates that he wasn't sending stuff back in good faith, and if it were a blind test between that bottle and the one he deemed acceptable, we can safely say he wouldn't know which one was the good one.
- dllthomas 14y agoOh, yes, I agree that this guys behavior was probably inappropriate. My post was simply addressing the use of consistency as a metric.