3 ms·
> It's war initiated by Hamas Takes two to tango. Hamas started the war. Israel has continued it way past where it made sense. (No later than after Sinwar was
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> It's war initiated by Hamas
Takes two to tango. Hamas started the war. Israel has continued it way past where it made sense. (No later than after Sinwar was killed.)
- istjohn 1y agoGaza has been under blockade since 2007, and the roots of the conflict date back to the founding of the Zionist Organization by Theodor Herzl in 1897 with the purpose to facilitate the escape of Jews from persecution in Eastern Europe by establishing a colony in Palestine. Israel has persecuted the indigenous people of Palestine ever since.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> the roots of the conflict date back to the founding of the Zionist Organization by Theodor Herzl in 1897 with the purpose to facilitate the escape of Jews from persecution in Eastern Europe by establishing a colony in Palestine Please, the roots of this conflict go back millenia. Nothing done in the last hundred years have helped it. And the Palestinian people keep getting fucked by outside powers using them for their own ends, whether it be the Arab countries invading Israel or Iran having their sock puppets invite bombs. But it's a bit silly to imagine that if we poofed Israel and turned Israel & Palestine into a democracy that we wouldn't, within like two minutes, start seeing missiles flying.
- Cyph0n 1y ago> within like two minutes, start seeing missiles flying. And that’s worse than the current situation how exactly? In fact, it would be objectively better because there would be justice: no apartheid, no occupation, no tiered citizenship, and no blockade.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> that’s worse than the current situation how exactly? Uh, look at the civil wars in Sudan, Ethiopia and Burma. > it would be objectively better because there would be justice: no apartheid, no occupation, no tiered citizenship, and no blockade What? Why do you think changing borders on paper has any effect on how the people actually on the ground feel about and treat each other? We're not half a decade out from our withdrawal from Afghanistan and we're back to the notion that remote powers drawing lines on a map somehow dictatates reality in the Middle East?
- Cyph0n 1y agoFirst, ending an occupation and apartheid is not “changing borders”. You are maliciously oversimplifying the situation in Palestine. Second, are you seriously saying that people’s feelings have nothing to do with injustices waged upon them by force? And just to add one thing - the theoretical worsening of a situation in response to ending injustice never justifies the maintaining of said injustice. You can argue this point all you want, but it will never be true.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> ending an occupation and apartheid is not “changing borders” "Poof[ing] Israel and turned Israel & Palestine into a democracy" literally is. > are you seriously saying that people’s feelings have nothing to do with injustices waged upon them by force? Nope. > the theoretical worsening of a situation in response to ending injustice never justifies the maintaining of said injustice I'm not talking about justification. Famine is unjustified. The war is unjustified. I'm saying Y would be worse than X. That is true. It doesn't justify X. But it does make Y stupid.
- stale2002 1y ago> way past where it made sense. If they don't destroy Hamas now, then a war will happen again in another 10 years. At which point 10s of thousands of palestinians will needlessly die, again. The only resolution to all of this, will happen when Hamas is completely disarmed and out of power. You can criticize how Israel goes about achieving that goal. But that goal is the only one that gets to a real, permanent peace.
- ath3nd 1y agoYou are basically saying that regardless of criticisms and international condemnation, Israel has no choice but commit war crimes and genocide? This is like "look what you made me do" defence in court, not sure it will save genocider Netanyahu from rotting in the Hague jail. Nor would it stop us from boycotting Israel and calling out their genocide.
- stale2002 1y ago> Israel has no choice Yeah thats basically how thing will end up. Because if they dont get rid of Hamas now, they will end up in another war and end up killing 10s of thousands of more Palestinians later. Thats just what would happen. I mean, people are saying Israel is doing a genocide now right? If thats the case, why wouldn't they just do a genicide again if another October 7th happened? Obviously thats what they would do. > Nor would it stop us You don't have to stop doing anything. Just realize that they have a modern military that they are going to continue to use to kill their enemy until that enemy has surrendered or been destroyed. Thats the only way this ends. The only question is how many people have to die and how much of gaza has to be flattened in order to achieve that outcome. Boycotts aren't going to stop anything. Nor will condemnation. The only thing that would come close is serious military action, but well would you look at that, every major of enemy of Israel is now destroyed, from Syria to Hezbollah to Iran. Military action seems rather unlikely now, given how successful Israel was in obliterating every enemy it has in the area. So, the people of palestine are left with choice. Accept peace, or watch as Israel keeps killing people until Hamas is gone for good. > rotting in the Hague jail. Even if this fantasy land future did come to past, trials don't bring back the dead. If Israel has to kill another 50 thousand people to get rid of Hamas (because a peace deal with rejected), well those 50k genocide victims are still dead. The world's not turning on a dime here. Nobody is coming to save palestine. Boycotts don't stop bombs.
- dotancohen 1y ago> Hamas started the war. Israel has continued it way past where it made sense. The war will continue to make sense until the hostages are returned. When Hamas believes that the war no longer makes sense, then they are invited to return the hostages and the war will end.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> war will continue to make sense until the hostages are returned Not really. Hamas should unilaterally return the hostages. They're not getting any negotiating points by keeping them. But Israel prosecuting the war as it has is permanently debilitating its long-term security and economic prospects. (Its zenith was probably after its Iranian bombing campaign. Tel Aviv should have withdrawn then and fallen back to targeted bombings of Hamas leadership.)
- SilverElfin 1y ago> But Israel prosecuting the war as it has is permanently debilitating its long-term security and economic prospects. If the economic prospects are being debilitated, it is only because people are actually believing in the narrative that Hamas has hoped they’d be manipulated into believing, through a sustained campaign of disruptive rioting and propaganda - all while trying to not talk about the decades-long rocket attacks, the murder/rape of October 7, etc. But it’s silly for the world to fall for this narrative when it is clear who the aggressors are. Only one of these parties fundamentally believes in genocide of the other party - and that’s Hamas, per their own statements about their goals. As for the long-term security - this I am not clear on. Why do you think Israel’s security has been reduced? I think it will be very hard for Hamas to regroup quickly to the extent that it has been built up previously (especially thanks to Qatar’s help). But if left alone rather than stamped out, I think eventually they will build up strength and in 20 years we’ll have the next October 7. I think Israel’s only choice is to put a definitive end to Islamic terrorism.
- bigyabai 1y agoWhich hostages? Israel still detains several thousand Palestinians in violation of international law. There are no plans to release them or give them a fair trial, that I'm aware of.