12 ms·
Megafauna was the meat of choice for South American hunters
- chermi 1y ago"They chose sites that dated back more than 11,600 years, before the last of the now-extinct Ice Age megafauna vanished from the continent. The team only counted bones with clear signs that people had butchered the animal for food, like cut and percussion marks." I understand what they're trying to do here, but is this the best selection criteria? You can basically tear down/debone small animal carcasses with your hands, so there's less likely to be cut and percussion marks.
- DiscourseFan 1y agoYes but then you wouldn’t know it was a human, since only humans kill animals with sharp edges and big sticks
- somenameforme 1y agoBut that's also not proof of anything either, because any human that saw a dead e.g. giant sloth would have absolutely scavenged it.
- DiscourseFan 1y agoWell sure, but then they weren't hunting it. Also, they probably found evidence of human made hunting implements near the sites.
- card_zero 1y agoNo, they just looked at cut marks. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adx2615 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adx2615 Hunting rather than scavenging seems to be just an assumption, not investigated. But that's reasonable, they'd surely hunt a delicious giant sloth, why not.
- somenameforme 1y agoI'd wager we would do both, but a limiting factor is need. A single giant ancient beast could provide literally thousands of pounds of meat. That's feeding a village for a very long time. And taking down one of these beasts, even with reasonably advanced technology would always entail major risk. Even now a days with advanced rifles/ammo, elephant poachers are sometimes killed by elephants. And finally it's not just killing it, but then processing/preserving the meat, and bringing it all home. That would have been a tremendous amount of work. And nobody really knows how many humans were alive e.g. 10,000 years ago, other than - probably not many. There were almost certainly less than a million humans in the entirety of South America. The max population density there would have been 1 human per 18 square km. But of course in practice we would have huddled around water sources and in small settlements, greatly reducing our overall spread. So you could probably have traveled hundreds of kms in all directions before seeing a single human. That's just not a lot of people to completely eliminate a bunch of massive species throughout an entire continent. By contrast these species all started disappearing just about the time when we were leaving an ice age. And these animals may have been overadapted not only to the cold, but the associated vegetation/prey and feeding patterns.
- Qem 1y agoI wonder if the extinction of most megafauna happening just before the advent of agriculture and the first civilizations is not just coincidence but direct causation. We spent ~200kyr with a lot of "easy" calories roaming around. So no need for complex societies. Once we caused our first "end of the world" overhunting with stone age technology, and they were gone, the only remaining alternative for the survivors was meager small game that had to be complemented with backbreaking work in the fields trying to raise more plant food. Thus agriculture got popular. With it the need for record keeping and sedentary lifestyle. Only then civilization could be kickstarted.
- Theodores 1y agoI imagine that a massive mammoth would require the whole village to bring to the ground and back to the village. Conversely, the whole village isn't needed if it is just chicken on the menu tonight. Hence, I would argue that you need a relatively complex society if dinner is mega fauna. I also don't entirely follow your point that goes from 'backbreaking work' to 'sedentary lifestyle'. The latter only happened in the post war years when we worked out how to have all of the energy we need on tap. Before then, life was hard, albeit not for everyone since we have hierarchies.
- AlotOfReading 1y agoThat point is one of many reasons good archaeologists avoid conflating the idea of social complexity with sedentary societies. Modern megafaunal hunters like the Hadza are socially complex. What they don't have are sedentary lifestyles and permanent, entrenched social stratification, even though they're aware that these things are possible.
- Qem 1y agoMeat spoils fast. So your society would need no record keeping(writing) because without refrigeration or salt mining you can't store meat like grain. Animals move around, so taking tons of meat kilometers back to the village takes time that's already counting for spoilage. So you are less likely to have a village in first place. That would be more pratical to go full nomadic and set temporary camp near the carcass of the more recently slaughtered multi-ton beast. No need to transport anthing besides yourself. > I also don't entirely follow your point that goes from 'backbreaking work' to 'sedentary lifestyle'. The latter only happened in the post war years when we worked out how to have all of the energy we need on tap By sedentary lifestyle I don't mean individual sedentarism, like being a couch potato. I mean society-wide, in the sense of not living in permanent settlements were people spend their lives mostly in the same plot of land, but are constantly on the move.
- AndrewKemendo 1y agoThe late quaternary megafauna crash is well documented with human hunting pointed to as one of a few causes: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11895740/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11895740/ I wrote about its impacts on society here: https://kemendo.com/Myth-of-Scarcity.html https://kemendo.com/Myth-of-Scarcity.html Previously discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39569747 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39569747 My argument (which I need to update) is that it was the primary catalyst for society to create the system of private property at scale. However the roots of ritual society are more likely to be centered around the first sex strike around 70,000 BC, first proposed by Chris Knight in his 1991 book “Blood Relations” http://www.chrisknight.co.uk/category/menstruation/ http://www.chrisknight.co.uk/category/menstruation/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_strike The megafauna crash around 50,000BC then catalyzed the expansion of what was then a novel concept, of ritualized transaction, around more sedentary practices eventually leading to agriculture around 13000BC
- excalibur 1y ago> technically, “megafauna” describes any animal over 44 kilograms TIL we're all megafauna. We should make this a rite of passage, when a kid hits 97 lb they get a megafauna party.
- vmilner 1y agoIt makes the biggest dinosaurs (50-70 tons) gigafauna...
- rr808 1y agoSame in most places. Indigenous populations in Australia killed off all the large mammals except a few, in NZ there were a a number of large bird species which were all killed off soon after Maori arrived.