6 ms·
Why America still needs public schools
- lapcat 1y ago[flagged]
- IAmBroom 1y agoAlso, duh. "We find that firefighting services have been essential for eliminating fires, saving people from fires, and getting cats out of trees. And charity calendar sales."
- lotsofpulp 1y agoIronically, I find that schools (due to voters and politicians) focusing on “equality” or “fairness” is what lead to the decline in public education in the first place. Voters wanted better results from poorer performing students, but politicians had no cheap way to deliver them, since the poor performance is caused due to the environment at home. The politically acceptable and cheap solution was capping the ceiling instead of raising the floor, which means parents who wanted their kids to excel sought school districts with similar parents, or sought private schools. Obviously the current admin and their previous term did not help the situation, but the incentives had been set wrong long before they came to power.
- alphawhisky 1y agoOr, hear me out, it's because they've been underfunded from the start. PTA, Volunteer Coaching, Parent involvement in fundraisers, etc. all helped make the underfunded schools of the 1990's and 2000's run smoothly despite lack of funding. The reality is that there were never enough resources in the first place, and parents used to shoulder a lot more of the burden. Parents no longer have time for these things, which when combined with an even smaller budget results in very lackluster schools. Maybe, just MAYBE, if we took the 60k signing bonus and absurd salary away from ICE and started giving it to teachers, we'd see change in a meaningful way.
- lotsofpulp 1y agoI would bet the statistics suggest no matter how much a teacher is paid, no matter how small the class size, or how fancy the school, no one can make a kid care about learning if that isn’t reinforced from the beginning at home and amongst the kids’ peers. https://www.thecentersquare.com/washington/article_a5b43015-5566-4884-8229-9b6b40717004.html https://www.thecentersquare.com/washington/article_a5b43015-... Obviously, education should be properly funded, and many places do not pay competitively, especially considering many teachers these days have to baby sit mentally ill kids. But the bigger problem is that the kids who can and want to excel have been deprioritized in favor of the those who can’t or don’t want to learn.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 1y ago>Or, hear me out, it's because they've been underfunded from the start. Compare the funding per student to any other country in Europe... they've been hilariously overfunded for longer than either of us have been alive. >The reality is that there were never enough resources in the first place, a That's not reality. That's "spin". There were always enough resources for high achievement from those capable of high achievement... but then equal amounts of money wouldn't be wasted on low achievers. >Maybe, just MAYBE, if we took the 60k signing bonus This is just bad math. You need how many teachers nationwide? 1 million-ish? Go ahead and split those $60k bonuses over that many teachers (and over the next 20 years), and the few tens or hundreds of dollars that it ends up being, per teacher, is supposed to make a difference?
- HankStallone 1y agoYeah, "underfunded schools" is a talking point that bears no relation to reality but was great for pulling at people's heartstrings, because "think of the children!" But taxpayers have learned better, because they can look at their property tax bills and see how the bulk of it goes to schools. They can look up the per-pupil cost and see that it just keeps climbing faster than pretty much anything else but health care. They can see that the corollary talking point (schools in disadvantaged areas get less funding) is a lie too. From an MIT study: "The distribution of spending experienced by children living in poverty (figure 1a) is nearly indistinguishable from that of children not living in poverty (figure 1b)."[1] People who make that claim usually only count state and local funding, ignoring federal Title I which makes up for it. The "underfunded schools" dog just won't hunt anymore. People who are worried about their next paycheck don't want to hear it, especially when it often comes from school administrators who make more than they do. [1] https://direct.mit.edu/edfp/article/19/1/169/116642/Funding-High-poverty-School-Districts-Federal https://direct.mit.edu/edfp/article/19/1/169/116642/Funding-...
- lapcat 1y ago> the decline in public education What decline do you mean exactly? > The politically acceptable and cheap solution was capping the ceiling What cap do you mean exactly?
- lotsofpulp 1y agoThe decline in standards, and hence expectations of the quality of education from many public schools (those sequestered in wealthy enclaves notwithstanding). As I understand, for myriad reasons, there is no failing kids anymore. There isn’t even much punishment, as far as I can tell, such as detention, suspension, and expulsion. Everyone passes, and grades have little correlation with performance. https://archive.is/2025.05.30-210113/https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/03/10/new-numbers-show-falling-standards-in-american-high-schools https://archive.is/2025.05.30-210113/https://www.economist.c... >An analysis by The Economist suggests that schools are lowering academic standards in order to enable more pupils to graduate. And the trend is hurting low-performing pupils the most. See the last paragraph of PaulHoule’s comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45449204 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45449204 Also, the federal politicians screwed public schools by mandating various very expensive services, but providing no funding. For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IDEA_2004 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IDEA_2004 Every kid is legally mandated to have access to a potentially expensive Individual Education Plan, but no extra money is given to the schools to provide this, so where do the funds come from?
- lapcat 1y ago> those not sequestered in wealthy enclaves notwithstanding This seems to speak against the existence of a cap. > As I understand, for myriad reasons, there is no failing kids anymore. It's not clear to me whether this is true or whether it relates to high school graduation rates. Unfortunately, The Economist article has no analysis of why students don't graduate, whether they are forced out or simply drop out voluntarily, for whatever reason. The article says, "might not have made the grade," which is weasel wording. I would put any data from 2020-2022 in its own special category due to the pandemic. The most severe drop in SAT scores was indeed during that period. There's some irony here, though, because The Economist says, "The trend towards weakening standards can be blamed in part on No Child Left Behind, an education-reform law passed in 2002," but that was the policy of Republican George W. Bush (who actually introduced the phrase "the soft bigotry of low expecations"). > grades have little correlation with performance Citation needed. This claim is different from the claim of grade inflation. > Every kid is legally mandated to have access to a potentially expensive Individual Education Plan Every disabled kid > no extra money is given to the schools to provide this That's obviously a problem, but it would seem the obvious solution to unfunded mandates is to, you know, fund the mandates.
- potato3732842 1y agoDepends on whether you see schools actually "inculcating the United States’ fundamental values of liberty, equality, fairness and the common good" or working to create a bunch of worker bees who can't think critically and blindly worship every institution (public and private) regardless of how hard they're getting fleeced.
- alphawhisky 1y agoIronically, private schools are more likely to pitch anti-union and anti-worker ideas to kids. These places are all conservative think tanks and anyone who doesn't see that is an idiot. The liberation of the common man will never include a private school.
- potato3732842 1y ago>Ironically, private schools are more likely to pitch anti-union and anti-worker ideas to kids. These places are all conservative think tanks and anyone who doesn't see that is an idiot. The liberation of the common man will never include a private school. I was thinking more on the lines of the sort of how they never really teach critical thinking, gloss over any and every historical mistake and perhaps how to spot and avoid them and generally do their hardest to create what shortsighted small scope government silos see as model citizens at the expense of not creating people capable of sort of long term thinking and ability to connect disparate concepts that result in a more performant society. But anyway, I think your response speaks volumes.
- lapcat 1y agoThis seems like a strange take to me. What's the alternative? Which schools inculcate critical thinking and distrust of institutions? (Surely not private religious schools with mandatory uniforms and other strict rules.) Or do you believe that ignorant children with no schooling will naturally develop critical thinking skills?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 1y ago>for inculcating the United States’ fundamental values of If I am honest, I do not have the same values as those who favor public education. Not only do our values have very little overlap, the values that are extolled by them are quite offensive and disgusting to me. Given that these values are now those of the public education system, I should be desperately worried about my own children and the children of people I care about. However, since the late 1990s a curious thing has happened, and none of those children are in danger. My children do not attend public school and yet aren't being hunted down for truancy as I would have been as a child. We've already eliminated the danger of public education. This might be confusing to you, because some children still attend. Others are aware, you'll see it expressed in every reddit thread... someone will call for the end of homeschooling on the grounds that they're unable to indoctrinate every child, though they describe if much more charitably than that. None of those children will grow up caring about public education, none of them will ever vote in ways favorable to public education their entire lives. The shift has already begun, and in the coming years it will become ever more obvious.
- jklowden 1y agoThere was never any danger of public education, so eliminating that danger was quite easy. What we are undermining, though, is the benefit of public education. Witness the last election, where tens of millions were indifferent to democratic governance if it meant cheap gasoline and eggs. And, yes, the assault on democracy is real. On January 20, Trump signed an order in support of free speech. Within a week he barred the AP over the Gulf of America. Within a month he illegally disbanded USAID. Within 3 months he began suing law firms and defunding university research. Today colleges are receiving letters demanding curriculum in exchange for funding. And we have four years more, at least, to endure.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 1y ago>There was never any danger of public education, For those who have changed the world to what it is today, and want that but more, I'm sure public schools have always been something to celebrate. I am not one of those people, however. >though, is the benefit of public education. That benefit, even when I treat it with the most generous interpretation, is gone and has been for awhile. People whose children attend public school do not benefit from this, their children are being shut out of the economy in favor of bringing in workers from other countries. The political apparatus benefits, if those children are indoctrinated to vote correctly even as they grow up to only be fit to get a 20-hour part time job at Starbucks. Even now, you're worried about the politics in this very comment, you don't really care that those children won't grow up to earn a viable livelihood. >Within a month he illegally disbanded USAID. Oh noes! I too wish that the United States would spend millions and billions on foreigners in foreign countries. Won't anyone think of the CIA soft power we're losing?
- somenameforme 1y agoThe article frames the issue as 'public' vs 'private' education, yet is railing against things like charter schools which are public. And their main argument is formulated by comparing education against no education, which is nonsensical. The main reason "private" (in their sense of the word) schools are gaining in popularity is precisely because they are seen as delivering a better education by an ever wider chunk of society. More specifically the US currently spends more than the vast majority of the world per pupil [1], yet our outcomes in e.g. math leave us somewhere between Malta and and Slovakia. [2] Clearly it does not seem that 'more money' is the solution. [1] - https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd/education-expenditures-by-country https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd/education-exp... [2] - https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/pisa-scores-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/pisa-scor...
- alphawhisky 1y agoYeah, the rich part of society. Building towards private schools is like building the titanic without enough lifeboats. Make an education system that works for everyone or awful things will keep happening to private schools because everyone understands how fundamentally unfair they are.
- somenameforme 1y agoCharter schools are free and open to all students. Excess applications are generally resolved through a lottery type system.
- Simulacra 1y agoThe charter schools in Washington DC are most certainly not part of rich society. There are many charter schools in very non-rich places.
- throwaway2016a 1y agoI didn't get a sense the article singled out charter schools specifically rather it just lists it as a alternative place that funds get funneled instead of to neighborhood public schools. Which brings me to: > The main reason "private" (in their sense of the word) schools are gaining in popularity is precisely because they are seen as delivering a better education by an ever wider chunk of society. If you accept that the article is talking about charter schools, then yes, perhaps the narrow focus of the charter could allow for a stronger education in a specialized area could allow for better education in that area. But, if you accept it as private schools as a whole, then I don't buy that argument fully. The administration has been very clear that the motivation is "anti-woke" and "traditional family values" and nothing to do with education quality. In fact, as someone who went to a religious school in a small town (granted 30+ years ago) I can vouch that my education (especially in science and math) was FAR worse than the public schools at the time and homeschooling quality varies wildly. Edit: As far as > More specifically the US currently spends more than the vast majority of the world per pupil I also find this focus on spending per pupil very odd because it doesn't account for cost of living. And if you dive into the fine print it says: > Includes both government and private expenditures. So what if (and this is a completely untested hypothesis) the reason we spend so much per pupil in that chart is being exasperated by the private school system. Edit 2: after diving into it, that source provided is greatly inflated by private school spending including private colleges (which are insanely expensive). So that same data can also be used to argue the US is really spending too much on private schools not public ones.
- daft_pink 1y agoTo be fair, I don’t think anyone’s trying to eliminate public education. That’s a very unfair characterization. They are just trying to cut down large education bureaucracies that don’t appear to be benefiting the students. Generally very large or very small public school systems in America really underperform for the students. It’s not clear that the Federal resources in the Dept of Education are directly benefiting the students. They are trying to give more control over education to parents and local communities especially those in underperforming areas.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- giraffe_lady 1y ago> To be fair, I don’t think anyone’s trying to eliminate public education. That’s a very unfair characterization. It's not unfair at all, that is what they're trying to do. It would be a political career ender to say that so they say things like "trying to cut down large education bureaucracies that don’t appear to be benefiting the students." But there is an influential contingent of republicans that wants to effectively end american universal public education and they're not meaningfully opposed within the party. > It’s not clear that the Federal resources in the Dept of Education are directly benefiting the students. What's your area of experience with education where this is how you've come to see it? Because for what I do, it's extremely obvious that these resources do benefit the students.
- 4MOAisgoodenuf 1y agoThere are absolutely actors who wish to privatize education. And, depending on the district, those federal resources provide a significant chunk of the funding for schools. In my local district in Kansas, it’s about 13% of public school funding, in the district next door it’s about 44%. Without that funding many public schools in the area would close with no alternative. By cutting off those resources, there is no “choice” or “control” being given to local communities unless you mean a certain family in Wichita…
- daft_pink 1y ago