5 ms·
Elop running out of time to turn Nokia around
- Toshio 14y agoIf Nokia survives as an independent company, it is going to shrink considerably. They don't need a lot of people to be a little patent troll still making a product just to avoid the NPE pigeon hole.
- shin_lao 14y agoThey really have good products with the Lumia phones. I think they will make it, however I agree it will probably not as an independant company.
- danieldk 14y agoThe Lumia hardware is really nice and robust. Lumia with Android would probably sell like hotcakes right now. Now they are at the mercy of Microsoft, who seem to have trouble wrapping up WP8, can abandon the platform any moment (as they have done with Windows Mobile, WP7), or stop delivering updates for slightly older phones.
- shin_lao 14y agoYou might have a bias against WP. I own a Lumia and the experience is good, WP7 is a very decent OS.
- danieldk 14y agoI don't. I also have a Lumia with WP7, and I do like the operating system quite much. What I do not like is the lack of updates and that the Lumia that I bought relatively recently is now already obsolete. Coming from the iPhone, where I had years of updates, that's a few steps back.
- EnderMB 14y agoNokia were the kings of mobile back when phones were simple, so why the hell haven't they ditched Windows Phone and made phones simple once again?! I bet there's a huge market out there for older users that want a simple and usable phone with stripped functionality, and it's a tactic that worked very well for Nintendo when they realised that they couldn't compete with Sony and Microsoft in the console market. A lot of older users just want a mobile phone so they can get in touch with family, send a few texts to people and occasionally browse the web. If linked with a company like Yahoo (providing mail and other basic cloud stuff) I'd be shocked if a phone that focused on being a phone and not a smartphone didn't sell millions amongst the tech-illiterate and older audience.
- monsterix 14y agoPainful metamorphosis is probably the right term to be used here. They could acquire the smaller and profit-making players in dumb-phone markets and let them function independently - kill their own overheads in "small-margins" game. Nokia should reinvent their focus to something else - not continue on mobile platform now. Just like they did in past by moving away from cables to rubber tyres and so on... They're late for the tablet game too, but an enterprise centric tactile surface (which is portable too) sounds like a good idea [Sheesh! Given away the idea, but the world would be a better place with it ;) ]. There is a gap in there which they could surely fill. I don't know about Elop's strengths or weaknesses, but for me Nokia is still a severely defocused bloat. Strip down to basics is the only advise here. Just a few thoughts.
- r00fus 14y ago> They're late for the tablet game too, but an enterprise centric tactile surface (which is portable too) sounds like a good idea [Sheesh! Given away the idea, but the world would be a better place with it ;) ]. This is what killed RIM - they bet on an enterprise tablet over their phone market, and failed. The whole "enterprise tablet" market is either ripe for the picking or no-man's land - and I don't think Nokia could have done better than RIM. When failing, you need to cut back on unprofitable side-ventures, double-down on your core profitable offerings, execute, then re-invest that into new markets.
- wkz 14y agoIMHO Nokia had a promising platform in Meego. Would be interesting to see what would happen if it was given half a chance.
- mtgx 14y agoI don't think they have any time left to risk it on going all-in with another platform with non-existent market share. If they fail to get significant momentum with WP8 this year, the kind of momentum they need to actually recover and also replace the Symbian sales, then they need to immediately switch to Android. If they want they can still do Meego on the side. But going Meego-only would be an even worse decision.
- gnaffle 14y agoAgreed. It's too late now, and it's very sad to see. If they had gone all-in on Meego a few years earlier, or chosen it instead of WP7 and made it run Android apps out of the box, maybe they would have had a fighting chance.
- bergie 14y agoFrom Twitter today: @JollaMobile working with the old Meego communities still. https://twitter.com/totoroki/status/248416652260151296 https://twitter.com/totoroki/status/248416652260151296 If you want to develop for @jollamobile, do qml-applications and expect a screen between 4-5 inches, says @jussihurmola https://twitter.com/mvonwillebrand/status/248416914534170624 https://twitter.com/mvonwillebrand/status/248416914534170624 Jolla is the mobile phone start-up founded by a group of ex-Nokians.
- nvrmor 14y agoI'd buy if they went back to meego/harmattan
- tobiasu 14y agoAnd for added fun port Dalvik to it, so it can run most Android apps in addition to the native Qt5 stuff. Not going to happen, but one can dream.
- quonn 14y agoThey could sell this to a few geeks. But that's it. Meego never came even close to Android in terms of quality. And ern Android would probably not work for Nokia. Nokia is doing exactly the right thing - just years too late.
- zmmmmm 14y agoThe main reason they are "too late" is that MS has screwed them - first by limiting the capabilities of WP7 phones, then by betraying them right at the time they launched their flagship and saying there'd be no upgrades to WP8 for ANY phones, and then finally for forcing them to wait forever to get Windows 8 devices out. In my view the Microsoft partnership has been a disaster for Nokia.
- guard-of-terra 14y agoQuality is not something you "have" or "not have". Quality is polish. Android 1.0 didn't have any, but then it became better and better with each new version. You're not alone in not understanding this. HP trashed WebOS because their first shaky release didn't show "quality". Ditto Nokia and Maemo/MeeGo. The only way to make a "quality" OS is rub and rub and rub and rub.
- blinkingled 14y agoOnce Microsoft buys them at a suitable price, they've got nothing to fear. Just like they did with Bing, Windows Phone, Xbox etc. Microsoft has deep enough pockets to continue pumping money into Nokia for making WP handsets until they gain meaningful market share. I am not trying to critique Microsoft here - just that I see that as a likely scenario given the past and current circumstances. It only helps that both Microsoft (with Windows Phone 8) and Nokia (with hardware) are doing things mostly right.
- mtgx 14y agoThe thing is if Microsoft buys them, I'm not sure how the other manufacturers would react. At least Google promised them to help fight against both Apple and Microsoft with Motorola's patents, and also manufacturers can't just quit Android. But they could easily quit WP8. They must not be very happy about how Microsoft is heavily promoting Nokia's devices already, while making it so everyone else ignores their own.
- blinkingled 14y agoMicrosoft has already started to give Nokia exclusivity and buying them out doesn't change much - OEMs are not not dependent on Windows Phone anyways - they can keep their WP handsets a small affair but they still gotta pay Microsoft on their Android sales in patent royalties, even if Microsoft favors/buys Nokia. Even if non-Nokia OEMs totally ditched Windows Phone - Microsoft could just take the royalty money and continue to invest it in Nokia and use all tricks in the book to gain some meaningful market share. No matter how you look at it - it looks good for Microsoft.
- Toshio 14y ago> has deep enough pockets to continue pumping money into Nokia for making WP handsets until they gain meaningful market share. I'll believe it when I see it. Them achieving meaningful market share with windowsphone would shock a lot of us in the industry since microsoft's track record so far has been that they suck pretty badly at hardware rollouts.
- 14y ago
- jeswin 14y agoWhen he took over, Elop stated that it is 'a battle of ecosystems'. Having spent significant time with Nokia devices (including Maemo/Meego), I completely agree with him. A few years back Android itself was second choice for most mobile developers, and it was almost impossible for Nokia to get them to write apps. Also, Android picked up because of Google; if Samsung made Android it would have gone the Bada way. WP8 is the first OS that gives Nokia a fighting chance against iOS/Android devices. - I have only seen positive reviews of this OS. - It is do or die for MS as well, expect massive ad spend this season. - Shared kernel with Windows. Attractive to millions of Windows developers. (Windows isn't cool anymore; but there are way, way more developers on Windows than any other platform.) - If resource constrained WP7 is anything to go by, WP8 will be smoother than any android phone in the market. This is Elop's first, last and only chance. I'd rather give the man a fair chance. Edit: formatting.
- Toshio 14y ago> Windows isn't cool anymore; windows has never been cool; ubiquitous is the word you're probably thinking of.
- bornhuetter 14y agoIn the 90's, having a Windows gaming machine was cool.
- angstrom 14y agoEspecially considering consoles didn't have multiplayer beyond the living room. Having access to B.NET, Kali, MPlayer, and other gaming networks of the day was very cool.
- bornhuetter 14y agoI still think my dual boot Windows/Linux machine is cool, but I seem to be in a minority around here. Haters gonna hate.
- 14y ago
- brudgers 14y ago"Nokia still sells almost a million phones a day" "Greenwich's Rehle said Nokia should focus on rolling out smartphones running on Google's Android software for millions of consumers in emerging markets who often still prefer Nokia's brand. Android models cost under $100 while the cheapest Windows Phone costs around $200" OK, so they're selling a million phones a day and not making a significant profit. The reason is that too few of the phones are high margin smartphones. And from this the conclusion is that they should switch to Android and sell commodity smartphones? This doesn't sound like analysis. It sounds like Microsoft bashing.
- bergie 14y agoA lot of the million phones a day that they sell are featurephones with Nokia's own OSs. With Android they might be able to push margins slightly up there, and with the volumes they have that could be a big thing.
- rbanffy 14y ago> the conclusion is that they should switch to Android and sell commodity smartphones? They already sell commodity phones. In these markets people don't pick Nokia because of brand or features - they pick it because they need voice and text calls and Nokia's phones seem to be a slightly better value proposition (rugged, long battery life) than other low-end units. Once other manufacturers manage to bring Android 2.x into the S40 price range (something Nokia certainly won't be able to accomplish with WP8), you'll see quick erosion of Nokia's share because other sets will have a much better value proposition.
- lawdawg 14y agoI think Nokia seriously underestimated the "Instagram/Zynga" factor when they decided to go with Windows Phone. The average consumer does a minimal amount of research before buying a phone, and typically buy whatever the sales representative recommends (unless they are looking for a specific model, like the iPhone or SGS3). But on top of that, consumers will still ask questions like: 1. Oh my friend uses this app called "Instagram", does Windows Phone have "Instagram"? 2. I want to play "Words with Friends" with my friends, can I do that on Windows Phone? If the sales representative is honest (I mean he has to be or will get an instant return), the consumer is just going to pick up an equally cheap or cheaper Android phone. The 920 does not solve this problem despite having pretty sweet hardware. Not only that, its a huge phone like the SGS3, but quite heavy, which will turn off a lot of consumers who want big screens, but light devices (you don't see Apple making bigger phones that are heavier). Even if the camera is the best on the market (and to be honest, I don't think it will be noticeably better than the iPhone5 and upcoming Android phones), without useful apps for sharing those photos, people won't be drawn to the platform. Finally, things like wireless charging and using the phone with gloves on are not major selling points, just like NFC has never been a major selling point.
- bergie 14y agoRumors say they're paying the makers of various "must have" apps to get them on their platforms. This probably explains why my old Symbian phone has Twitter, Foursquare, and Facebook. Since the companies making those applications are not really interested in these platforms the apps usually are halfhearted at best.
- gnaffle 14y agoThe sales representative isn't always honest, but he _will_ try to push whatever model the carrier is interested in pushing. Right now, carriers are interested in pushing Android since that ecosystem is aligned with the carriers interests (easily customizable). Carriers are generally not interested in Windows Mobile and Nokia, and very few carriers are interested in pushing the iPhone even though they have to carry it due to customer demand.
- 14y ago