3 ms·
> I get it, but the alternative is what? Get model release forms from anyone in a public space every time you turn your video camera on? I find it interesting
by Aurornis 1y ago
> I get it, but the alternative is what? Get model release forms from anyone in a public space every time you turn your video camera on?
I find it interesting how the winds have changed on this topic. 5-10 years ago it was a hot topic in online tech spaces (HN, Reddit, Slashdot and adjacent sites) about preserving your rights to take photos and videos in public spaces.
I can understand some people preferring not to be filmed in public or shared commercial spaces, but ultimately if you are truly in public then being photographed or recorded is just part of the deal.
I don’t think some people have thought about the second-order effects of things like requiring model release forms for everyone who enters the frame. Imagine getting a ticket or being sued by your busybody neighbor because you took a video of your kids in the backyard and they walked past. Laws like this are frequently abused by people who want to wield power over others, not simply people who simply want to protect themselves.
When you extend the thinking to topics like news reporting and journalism it becomes obvious why you don't want laws requiring everyone to give consent to have video shared of themselves in public: No politician would ever allow footage of themselves to be shared unless it's picture perfect and in line with what they want you to see.
- gameman144 1y agoI don't think the author was arguing at all that these things should be illegal, more just that there should be more consideration of other people's preferences where possible. It's also legal to play an annoying song on repeat all day on a quiet hiking trail, but people (rightfully) recognize that as improper socially.
- jMyles 1y ago> I find it interesting how the winds have changed on this topic. My very very strong gut feeling is that this is an influx of bots muddying the waters of discussion in concert with the unleashing of the secret police force that is ICE. It seems to me that every real person sees the crucial importance of public photography in peacefully maintaining accountability.
- Ekaros 1y agoMaybe our society has failed if publishing such photos is needed to maintain accountability... I really do not see that step for actually functioning society.
- jMyles 1y ago...we have evolved eyes, brains capable of retaining visual memory of what they capture, and communications media capable of describing and depicting those captured photons. If you believe in the basic right of general purpose computing - not just a political right, but the idea that general purpose computing is the lifeblood of the internet age - then it seems to follow logically that the capture of photons and depiction thereof are part of the functioning the commons.
- detaro 1y agoAnd of course nobody in this discussion has said anything against photographing officials and news-worthy events. "You should not publish photos/videos of private individuals without consent or a very good reason" and "you should be able to freely document police activity" do not contradict each other.
- jMyles 1y ago...and how does that work when we complete the abolitionist struggle and no longer have a separate segment of society assigned to "police activity"?
- detaro 1y agoThen we don't need to worry about documenting ICE activities anymore and still don't need to publish photos of random people without a good reason.
- jMyles 1y agoIs that true? There are many level of exercise of political, social, and economic power that happen in the commons. The camera is a primary tool of defense against injustice in this area. Restrictions (especially with the force of law, but also social pressures) of the basic and deeply human capacity to capture photons and vibrations, and to make depictions of the results of that capture, are invariably used by the more powerful against the less powerful. eg: cops playing "copyrighted" material to prevent posting to youtube. Much safer and fairer is to just give ourselves the same rights we might imagine are afforded to an alien, 4 light years away, looking through an extremely powerful telescope. Do you suggest that earth laws extend to this alien? Is she prohibited from posting the activities she can see of ours through her telescope?
- Vrondi 1y agoBut, OP was not in a public space.
- o11c 1y agoThere are at least 3 completely distinct actions at stake here, and we should not pretend they are the same: 1. Taking pictures/videos for personal use. 2. Taking pictures/videos for internet fame/money. 3. Taking pictures/videos as a check on abuse of power. Most opposition now is due to #2, sometimes under the guise of #3; #3 also has divisions between "is it {illegal,unethical,immoral,weird}?"
- MatthiasPortzel 1y agoHere’s an article from 20 years ago on the subject, to support your memory: => https://web.archive.org/web/20040611150802/http://villagevoice.com/issues/0423/haber.php https://web.archive.org/web/20040611150802/http://villagevoi...
- johnnyanmac 1y ago>I find it interesting how the winds have changed on this topic. 5-10 years ago it was a hot topic in online tech spaces (HN, Reddit, Slashdot and adjacent sites) about preserving your rights to take photos and videos in public spaces. I don't know about that. Aroudn this time was the peak of "Glassholes" for those who remember that phenomenon. People really didn't want someone to be potentially, passively recording their conversation. Would that not be a thing should Google re-launch Google Glass today? That might be a real factor given how Meta is trying to push AR glasses.