5 ms·
Clean fusion power may only be fifty years away. (Seriously, it's great that there are fundamental research programs still going on. Even the spin-offs are gen
by dsr_ 14y ago
Clean fusion power may only be fifty years away.
(Seriously, it's great that there are fundamental research programs still going on. Even the spin-offs are generally worthwhile by themselves.)
- gus_massa 14y agoIt's really very difficult to predict which technologies will work in 50 years. Try to imagine yourself in 1962 and try to predict what would happen in 2012. I googled http://www.google.com/#q=1960+technology+predictions http://www.google.com/#q=1960+technology+predictions , there are a lot of results, some of them are very interesting. But it is difficult to choose the sites with good reliable information. Or in other words: http://xkcd.com/678/ http://xkcd.com/678/
- InclinedPlane 14y agoWell, 1952 to 2002 would be even more challenging (42 even more so). The transistor was new, lasers hadn't been invented, no orbital satellites had been launched, computers were very primitive, etc. So much of our modern communications infrastructure is based on lasers, satellites, and micro-chips. What invention will render our predictions utterly useless? Consider the potential of memristor technology, for example, which could put vastly increase the power and space efficiency of computers and lead to micro-chip sized supercomputers. Or maybe we invent some form of nanofabrication, or room temperature superconductors, or some invention that wouldn't even make sense to us today.
- jostmey 14y agoI would not rush to call fusion "clean". But it would be an amazing power source.
- DennisP 14y agoIt's pretty close. Has a high neutron flux that makes your equipment radioactive, but there's no waste from the fuel itself. If one of the boron fusion projects works out, we won't even have the neutron flux.
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoIIRC, the neutron branching fraction for the proton-boron reaction is around 1%. So it is not clean, but the flux is low enough not to do much damage to the walls of the fusion chamber.
- DennisP 14y agoTrue. It would need a bit of shielding. Some of the picosecond laser papers say the total radioactivity per megawatt would be less than what's released by burning coal, which contains a little thorium and uranium. Here's an abstract that mentions that: http://www.davidpublishing.com/journals_show_abstract.html?7377-0 http://www.davidpublishing.com/journals_show_abstract.html?7... (Google will turn up plenty of full papers though.)
- adaml_623 14y agoLess radioactivity release than coal I think. Due to the levels of radioactive material naturally occurring in coal deposits.
- DennisP 14y agoIf Sandia's idea works, they'll exceed breakeven next year. After that they just need to build a machine two or three times bigger and they'll have a high enough energy gain to easily be practical. And they only need a new fuel element every ten seconds, which gives them a practical advantage over NIF's approach. Meanwhile there's focus fusion (could get to net power next year with boron fusion), NIF (a couple years away, already working on a practical power plant design called LIFE), General Fusion (five years to commercialization if it works), Tri-Alpha (slightly more), picosecond laser fusion (simple high-gain boron fusion design, needs a laser six times bigger than our best now but lasers are advancing fast), polywell (Navy's doing it, could be five years if it works, they're not talking much), and a couple more that look promising but need funding (Helion, levitated dipole). And tokamak of course, which is still decades away from practical use so of course that gets the most money and press. What people don't realize is that fusion has been advancing exponentially since 1970. But still every fusion article gets the inevitable "fifty years away" joke. I'm on the verge of making a record of every one I see, just so I can send them all a "nyah nyah" when one of these projects comes to fruition.
- kposehn 14y agoInteresting. What are the benefits to any of these approaches in your opinion? What seems key to me is having a large enough energy output to harness without waste in the flare window while being able to manufacture fuel in sufficient volumes to power the sucker.
- DennisP 14y agoBiggest benefit, but theoretically hardest to achieve, is boron fusion, which is nonradioactive. Since the energy is carried away in charged particles instead of neutrons, you don't need a steam cycle. Focus fusion would be a small boron fusion device, producing 5MW per reactor at a tenth the price of coal. Potential drawbacks: the energy gain is a bit marginal so you have to also capture x-rays, and erosion of the electrodes could be a problem. But a 5MW plant should only cost half a million or so. Picosecond laser would also do boron fusion (which in that design is only ten times harder than D-T), but with a 10,000x energy gain, divided by the one percent efficiency of the laser. It's projected to produce power as cheaply as focus fusion. Tri-Alpha supposedly could achieve boron fusion but they've been very tight-lipped about the whole thing. They've gotten close to $100 million in venture capital though, including from Paul Allen. Polywell, if it works, could do D-T fusion in a 2-meter sphere, or boron fusion in a 3-meter. I've seen relatively high projected costs, though that may be for D-T. If you're a scifi fan, this was invented by the guy who came up with Bussard ramjets. He was also a big tokamak guy, before he gave up on them. Levitated dipole sorta turns tokamaks inside-out, with the plasma contained around the outside of a solid levitating torus. This seems to solve some plasma instabilities that tokamaks struggle with. They say it would be ideal for D-D fusion. Deuterium (for D-D) and boron are readily available in large quantities relative to what we'd need. D-T needs tritium, which would have to be made by bombarding lithium with the neutrons from the fusion reaction. This would limit how fast we could roll out the reactors. D-D and D-T would both require steam turbines. Most people focus on D-T since it has the least stringent requirements, and the rest of these are D-T. General Fusion uses a vat of molten lead and lithium, spinning to open a channel down the middle. A plasma ball is shot in from each end, then 200 steam-driven pistons slam into the container, making an acoustic shock wave that compresses the D-T plasma. The neutrons hit the lithium for tritium, heat the lead, and it all drives the steam turbine, with some steam diverted to drive the pistons. Jeff Bezos is a big investor in this one. Right now they've got the pistons working with the tight timing they need, and a prototype with a dozen pistons or so. NIF says they're farthest along the development path, they're leveraging big advances in lasers, and with their LIFE development they're already working with thirty or so commercial suppliers to put together a practical reactor design with as much off-the-shelf equipment as possible. They don't need as much tritium inventory to start up as tokamaks, and think they can be competitive with fossil fuels. They've been talking 2020 or so for a demo reactor, but they also thought they'd manage ignition this year, and a recent DOE report said it'll be another couple years. Helion targets a middle ground between tokamaks and NIF, in terms of temperature and density, which they think will be easier. They need $20 million for a full-size reactor, already built a 1/3-scale test unit. They're also working with NASA on a fusion rocket design. Tokamak (like ITER) seems to be on a solid path to net power, but it's such a huge, complicated, expensive device that it's hard to imagine it being economical, and they're talking about a thirty year timeframe at best.