5 ms·
Using Cesium-137 testing to find counterfeit wine
- frankfrank13 1y agoi want a Catch Me if you Can about this guy -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudy_Kurniawan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudy_Kurniawan
- dddgghhbbfblk 1y agoIt's a pretty wild story. Rudy was also very prolific so there are a lot of his bottles out there in collections and potentially still on the auction market. He had a huge impact on the expensive wine collection trade.
- roolgo 1y agoThere is a pretty good documentary about this guy and the wine auction: Sour Grapes.
- ahazred8ta 1y agoclips from the Sour Grapes documentary https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Sour+Grapes+kurniawan&ia=videos&iax=videos https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Sour+Grapes+kurniawan&ia=videos&ia...
- vzaliva 1y agoIt should be noted that cesium dating works for counterits produced in last ~60 years (or less) as Cesium-137 half-life of about 30 years.
- avidiax 1y agoWouldn't that just mean that the detector needs to be increasingly sensitive to detect a late-1940's forgery?
- rtkwe 1y agoYou should also be able to use the presence of the decay daughters as another way to detect forgeries.
- philipkglass 1y agoCesium 137 decays to barium 137 which is stable and naturally occurring, so the cesium daughter wouldn't be useful for this case (non-destructive testing of sealed wine bottles).
- rtkwe 1y agoAh, inconvenient that it doesn't have a longer chain of gamma emitting daughters.
- numpad0 1y agoHalf life is just time until only half of the original amount remains. Double that and it represents the time it takes to halve again. The actual detection threshold would be separate from half life.
- perihelions 1y agoThe idea with cesium-137 is that it didn't exist naturally in significant quantities prior to 1945. An airtight container, sealed from the atmosphere prior to 1945, should not contain any. It's not like some other radioisotopes using in dating, such as carbon-14, which are continuously produced naturally (i.e. by cosmic rays initiating nuclear reactions in the high atmosphere). In that case, an airtight container had a known concentration at the time of its sequestration, and radioisotope dating (to oversimplify) counts the number of half-lives that elapsed since that point. (Or with the example of organic matter—the number of half-lives since a tree was felled into lumber—since it ceased metabolizing atmospheric gases).
- extraduder_ire 1y agoNuclear explosions in the atmosphere also changed the isotopic concentration of the atmosphere so much that it's a clear delineation of the "modern era" in almost all radioisotope dating.
- hadlock 1y agoApparently there are companies out there who engineer otherwise inert particles, or mixes of particles, that fluoresce under specific wavelengths, for example Mobil might add the particles to their premium Mobile 1 synthetic motor oil product to find counterfeit products in certain markets. By opening a bottle of oil purchased off the shelf they can hit it with ~620nm && ~580nm and if it does not respond correctly, it is relatively easy to demonstrate that it is counterfeit and quickly get it removed from shelves. This can also be applied to crude oil and quietly tested at the refinery to verify it hasn't been diluted with similar product.
- mrexroad 1y ago> Mobil might add the particles to their premium Mobile 1 synthetic motor oil product to find counterfeit products in certain markets. By opening a bottle of oil purchased off the shelf they can hit it with ~620nm && ~580nm and if it does not respond correctly Interesting. I haven’t heard they had additives in the oil to detect counterfeits. I assume the fluorescing behaves differently at 620nm and 580nm? I recall they had issues with counterfeits in some countries and have made attempts to combat it with packaging (e.g. specific letters on label fluorescing under UV, and currently their Scantrust app [0] validation tool). I’d be interested to know how it behaves, as having the oil itself fluoresce when not labeled as such might be annoying when using UV dyes for monitoring leaks. For example, I like to run LiquiMoly’s molygen every few changes to monitor changes in seeping on one of my older cars, but it is only helpful when i run the oil w/ dye after non-dyed oil. [0] https://www.mobil.com/en/sap/our-products/mobil-anti-counterfeit https://www.mobil.com/en/sap/our-products/mobil-anti-counter...
- analog31 1y agoFrom what I've read, there are also fluorescent compounds in the other fluids used in cars. A mechanic can shine a UV light under your hood and spot the leaks.
- rolph 1y agonot only oil, chemical reagents on watch list , explosives, probably reloading powder. fertilizer components. not for counterfiet detection but for attribution in case of abuse.
- kayo_20211030 1y agoIf I buy a bottle of plonk for $20 and it tastes as I except, I don't stress about what gamma rays it's emitting. I just reckon I got what I paid for. Of course, if I payed $1 million, and I dare not open it, I might stress quite a lot. But really, that's for other people not me. I sadly don't have a million bucks to spend on wine.
- Cthulhu_ 1y agoAt these numbers you don't buy a product, you buy an investment with the intent to sell it later on; if it turns out to be a fake though, it's worthless. On the other hand, if you get it verified, it goes up in value by a lot.
- burnt-resistor 1y agoCollectable wine is essentially orthogonal to quality and taste when blind tasted. Never pay over say ~$30-40 USD for a bottle of wine if all you care about is taste. That's the gist I got from VEN 3 at UC Davis. And, always buy budget wine while suggesting to people it was "expensive". ;) People who want to collect expensive wine, more power to them, but it seems to me somewhere between a tulip bulb, Beanie Babies, and art market. https://localwiki.org/davis/VEN_3 https://localwiki.org/davis/VEN_3 https://www.caltech.edu/about/news/wine-study-shows-price-influences-perception-1374 https://www.caltech.edu/about/news/wine-study-shows-price-in... https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-08080-0 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-08080-0
- kulahan 1y agoTwo Buck Chuck was a famously inexpensive and delicious wine from... Trader Joe's, I think? Though last I heard it got moved to Three Buck Chuck. It's my dad's favorite. Incidentally, he once went to a wine auction with a rich friend. The friend bid on a $1000 bottle of wine (ostensibly inexpensive among this crowd) and gave it to my dad as a gift, who ended up not drinking it until years later when his first grandchild was born. If I remember correctly, he preferred the Two Buck Chuck.
- 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- gdbsjjdn 1y agoInsane to see the government resources used to prosecute this - it's basically play money for rich guys who want to show off.
- ChuckMcM 1y agoPretty wild story. Reminded me of the story of salvaging a Roman trade vessel off the coast of Greece. Everyone carefully cataloged and managed the various amphorae of trade goods, and one of the divers made off with a quarter million dollars worth of lead keel weights. :-)
- M95D 1y agoDo you have a link?
- ChuckMcM 1y agoI've been looking for it but have yet to find it. My memory has it being in Smithsonian magazine but I've gone through the last 6 years that I have digitized and nothing.
- ChuckMcM 1y agoNow we have a modern version: https://www.militarytimes.com/off-duty/military-culture/2023/06/01/chinese-ship-accused-of-looting-iconic-wwii-wrecks/ https://www.militarytimes.com/off-duty/military-culture/2023...
- BurningFrog 1y agoWith lead costing about $2/kilo, that would be about 125 tons of lead.
- ChuckMcM 1y ago"Roman" lead has no Cesium in it, which is important for some radiological instruments.
- lacoolj 1y agoOh cool this was what they did in White Collar! Good ol' Neal Caffery vs. Matt Kessler (I think was his name) Time to re-watch