4 ms·
I don't understand how Bluesky is going to continue to exist past 2026, based on the sharply declining usage, their headcount, and the amount of funding they've
by tptacek 1y ago
I don't understand how Bluesky is going to continue to exist past 2026, based on the sharply declining usage, their headcount, and the amount of funding they've taken.
It has apparent value propositions past the social network, but none of those use cases are visibly taking off and none of them appear to be monetizable. The social network itself is what will be evaluated when they go out for more funding. And I don't see how you can raise at all for a social network in 2026 with flat numbers, let alone the declining numbers Bluesky actually has.
I've been dual-wielding Twitter and Bluesky for about a year (after a year off Twitter where I was mostly Mastodon), and, anecdatally, we've hit a point where the engagement and volume of stuff I see in Bluesky is lower than what I was getting even on Mastodon. Earlier on, there was some truth to the idea that Twitter had a much larger audience, but you'd get better engagement on Bluesky. I now get better engagement on Twitter. I can see people I had followed into Bluesky moving back to Twitter.
I have no idea what's going to happen, but I'm curious to hear a coherent story about how Bluesky isn't cooked.
- jghn 1y agoWhat I've found is that most of the people I really want to follow are exclusively on bsky. BUT most of the people I'd prefer to casually follow either exclusively or mostly only posts on Twitter. And the 2nd group is a much larger pool than the first group. I really dislike Mastodon so gave that up a while back. I know there are a few people I'd like to follow who only post there, but such is life.
- packetlost 1y agoI've found Bluesky does a really bad job at not showing me stuff I don't want to see. Furry p*rn on the "cute internet cats" feed? Yup. Heaps and heaps of political rage bait on the main discover feed? Yup. I wanted to like BlueSky, but it's such a bizarre echo chamber of people who left Twitter for ideological reasons that it basically filters for people that I actively don't want to engage with. Those types of people are still there on Twitter (mostly on the other side these days), but I don't see them because the algorithm filters them out.
- jghn 1y agoI never see that but on both sites I only ever look at the feed that only includes people I follow. I don’t understand why anyone would use a feed that includes other co the t
- JimDabell 1y agoNew users follow zero people on Bluesky.
- jghn 1y agoYes. And I seeded my feed with people I already knew. Just like I did with Twitter back in 2008. And just like Twitter all those years ago, from seeing what they repost, I expanded my network. People who are incapable of finding content without a "discovery" or "for you" feed get what they deserve.
- JimDabell 1y ago> People who are incapable of finding content without a "discovery" or "for you" feed get what they deserve. If this is a typical attitude to the new user experience, no wonder Bluesky isn’t succeeding.
- jghn 1y agoWhy would anyone want a "discovery" type of feed on any site? On sites that insist on showing me content from things I don't follow I just block it.
- mrbombastic 1y agoThey do really need to do something about this, I am not on regularly anymore but there was a period where i kept getting weird sexual posts of dudes in diapers, no matter how much i blocked or asked not to see that.
- 1y ago
- pfraze 1y agoWe have multiple years of runway
- therealmccoyboy 1y agoThis thread is a good example of why you should probably announce things.
- akerl_ 1y agoSure, but if you’re on a downward trend for growth and don’t have viable paths to change that, runway is just stopping distance.
- antoniojtorres 1y agoI’ve noticed this anxiety on steam reviews too, people seem to stress out if there isn’t a continuous growth of a game’s player base, like there’s a totality that we all need to be striving for, even in a federated space, even in a game’s player base, otherwise any shrinking indicates a spiral. Not that they aren’t real (the spirals) but there’s an aspect of putting the cart before the horse here.
- akerl_ 1y agoA video game and a social network are pretty massively different things.
- antoniojtorres 1y agoAre they? Isn’t roblox and fortnite marketing themselves as them being more similar than people think?
- shrinks99 1y agoSharply declining usage? I don't see the stats to back that up on https://bsky.jazco.dev/stats https://bsky.jazco.dev/stats Usage has absolutely declined from peak switching periods where inevitibly some users won't stick around, but that's to be expected. Most stats seem to be leveling off (which isn't exactly stable growth either so the rest of your points stand).
- tptacek 1y agoYeah, I think what you needed to do here is zoom out. That's a sharply declining chart. I understand that as a Bluesky user the peak and dropoff doesn't hurt the experience. But investors are going to put money in with the expectation of a return and what they're going to look at are the derivatives of the adoption curve: how quickly is it gaining users, and is adoption accelerating?
- Larrikin 1y agoWhy does anyone need to invest at all? Why can't Jack Dorsey just run it instead of needing it be a hockey stick start up?
- tptacek 1y agoSee, that's a good question, but it has an answer: first, they took a priced round, and those investors will need to see a return, and second, when the funding runs out, someone is going to have to put more money in --- substantially more money --- to keep the lights on. What's probably true is that if they found a stable source of revenue they wouldn't have to answer these kinds of questions. But this is just back to my original point, of "I don't see how this is going to work", because I don't see how they're going to do that. I'd be happy if someone jumped in and set me straight with a clear and plausible plan. To me, though, from the information I've seen, it looks like the premise here is that they're going to raise again, and to do that they're going to need to demonstrate accelerating growth, which they starkly do not have right now.
- 1y ago
- CyberMacGyver 1y ago> I don't understand how Bluesky is going going to continue to exist past 2026, based on the sharply declining usage, their headcount, and the amount of funding they've taken. Do you have any data to back this up? Also famously twitter is losing value and advertisers and users still it’s not stopped twitter from existing Regarding engagement doesn’t twitter have lot more low quality engagement vs Bkuesky
- raincole 1y ago> I don't understand how Bluesky is going going to continue to exist past 2026, based on the sharply declining usage, their headcount, and the amount of funding they've taken. Are you an insider? Where are the numbers? how_long_can_bluesky_exists = f(usage, headcount, funding) Three parameters and you supplied zero of them. It does sound like you just randomly picked a number 2026 and proceeded to rant on how little engagement you received on Bluesky.
- tptacek 1y agoYou can just Google these things. Nate Silver posted (grim looking) usage numbers --- followers and posters --- just a couple weeks ago. They very publicly raised a $15MM (priced) A round a year ago, after raising what I understood to be a comparable amount of seed funding. There was talk early this year of them raising again at a $700MM valuation, but I don't see a subsequent announcement that that happened. You can generally take a headcount number and assign a fully loaded cost to it (say, $200k, conservatively) and just math it out. And of course that analysis assumes their infra expenditures round to zero. So no, I'm not just making stuff up. I could be wrong! I feel like I was open about that.
- epistasis 1y agoSaying "you can google it" when the range of online information is massive is not a helpful thing to say. What numbers are you believing and why? Nate Silver has basically zero juice on Bluesky, people go there to get away from that sort of "expert" that's got a huge profile already but is hard to escape if you are uninterested in his takes. I mean he'll, take his own word on it, it's not the social network for him! https://www.natesilver.net/p/what-is-blueskyism https://www.natesilver.net/p/what-is-blueskyism
- tptacek 1y agoWhat does it matter how much "juice" he has on Bluesky? The numbers are the numbers.
- 1y ago
- Onavo 1y agoTry lobbying the government or the opposition party to make Bluesky the official platform for all their communications.
- tbrownaw 1y agoNo. Government should be using a self-hosted instance of something standard and federated (ie, an ActivityPub implementation such as Mastodon). That can be federated out to the walled gardens (Twitter), vulture-capital places (Bluesky), etc as needed.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Molitor5901 1y agoI think platforms like that will survive on essentially rage and bitterness. People will always flock to platforms like X, Bluesky, iFunny, and others to vent and rage. There's so much anger in nearly every post that I don't see any of it as particularly useful, or a good use of one's time.
- x0x0 1y agoI googled: $23m raised (8 seed, 15 A in Oct 24). Also, linkedin says 53 people, though crazies like to say they're employed places. It does say 29 in the US so that's more likely real. Assuming that skews eng a bit, that's probably (225 fully loaded eng, 150 fully loaded the rest) $6m in payroll alone. Not to mention server expenses. That's tough. The case for more funding: 1 - yolo; 2 - non-economic investments; 3 - Musk gonna Musk, so expect Twitter to further shed users. There may be a business to be built there if you can run significantly more efficiently than Twitter which was a shockingly poorly-operated business (Zuck was dead on re: the clown car. Except maybe more like a silver mine, not a gold mine.). Oh, and 4 - the EU is pretty hostile to Twitter and Threads, so maybe there's some there there. Dunno.
- tptacek 1y agoYeah, this is basically where I'm coming from. There are ideologues and stans arguing both ways whether Bluesky is a moribund platform. I don't think it's intrinsically moribund. But I think that's the wrong question. The more important question is: is it succeeding to the point where it will attract another round of investment? That case is I think pretty hard to make based on the available public evidence --- but the Bsky people obviously know a lot more about this than I do!
- intended 1y agoI think the case can be made that twitter itself is unsustainable, and that the goal to create a new business model or social media system is part of the idea behind Bsky. Admittedly- this does not sound like the investment thesis that raises 700mn usd. But! the larger goal of Bsky is to not be twitter, and to be a different type of social media. In general, its not going to be as good. Whether there is a business model at the intersection of not-twitter and new social media, is to be discovered. Taking a stab at it - I suppose the question is whether this can be converted into any sort of cheap subscription based model, which is efficient to run on long time horizons and so breaks even, long enough to keep attracting users, and offloading moderation tasks to user groups.
- archagon 1y agoI have the opposite problem. My Bluesky (and Mastodon) feeds have gotten so active that I have a hard time catching up these days. And Twitter seems to be mostly full of bloviating narcissists who are addicted to feeling like “influencers” of the unwashed masses, not co-equal participants of public discussion. More broadly, Twitter’s problem is that it carpet bombed the bridge with a substantial portion of its intelligent population. I’m pretty sure half the tech, game dev, and research people I follow on Bluesky/Mastodon will not return under any circumstance, myself included.
- croon 1y ago> I've been dual-wielding Twitter and Bluesky for about a year (after a year off Twitter where I was mostly Mastodon), and, anecdatally, we've hit a point where the engagement and volume of stuff I see in Bluesky is lower than what I was getting even on Mastodon. What do you count as "engagement"? Views/likes? Those can be produced. Interesting conversations that aren't obviously LLM can't. That's the metric I use for anecdotally seeing Bluesky (and Mastodon) as immensely more engaging in a signal/noise ratio.