2 ms·
I don't mind checking karma results of my individual postings to see which ones fit best into the site culture. I've been considering karma systems, and I gues
by tokenadult 18y ago
I don't mind checking karma results of my individual postings to see which ones fit best into the site culture.
I've been considering karma systems, and I guess I think a two-dimensional system might be a useful improvement. One dimension would be
1) agree or disagree (factually) with this post,
with no impact on the user's cumulative score but display by each post
and the other would be
2) this post is a significant contribution to the community or not,
with the same cumulative scoring by user that now occurs on HN.
Sometimes people want to register disagreement with posts that are good posts for getting other people to think and bringing new ideas into the discussion.
- atestu 18y agoIf the disagreement is justified, the user can simply reply to the post to make his point, no? I think a two dimensional system would just bring clutter to a good minimalist site.
- tokenadult 18y agoReplying to make clear my disagreement [smile], I'll clarify that what I was writing about is the case when user 1 posts a new comment, and then various anonymous users downvote to indicate factual disagreement, rather than downvoting to indicate that it was a lousy comment. User 1 has nothing further to reply to, because all user 1 or any onlooker sees is a bunch of downvotes. (And since the comment's net vote total is shown, sometimes both downvotes and upvotes are invisible if they cancel each other out.) I agree with your desire for simplicity. I have the opinion that a voting system that votes both on agreement with the statement of the post, up or down, and on the contribution of the post to the community, up or down, is simple enough to be worth the additional information. Reasonable minds can differ, of course, and I'd be happy to read replies about why this is a bad idea.
- atestu 18y agoI agree with you that some people downvotes others because they don't agree with them, and that's a shame. I personaly downvote one-line-and-2-smileys comments and upvote comments that teach me something. I really don't feel the need for 2 little arrows, it would just be confusing, and users would hit the wrong buttons, etc. Instead, we should just encourage the "new guys" to read the guidelines : http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]