7 ms·
How Much Should Startup Employees Earn? Wealthfront Tells Us With A Clever Tool
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoAm I reading this wrong - out of 8,000 employees surveyed, no-one had more than 1/10th of 1% of equity. That's a nice pension contribution not an equity share. If you were in facebook at that level, you might get a house. But really why is that level of equity share of any influence in anyone's hiring equation? Or am I missing something?
- dkf 14y agoYou're basically right for the initial display. But equity is heavily dependent on company size, click on "Company Size" to see it break down. Or "Job Function" == Software Engineer and then click "Company Size".
- 2is10 14y agoOn the initial view, only the 40th to 60th percentiles are shown. On subsequent views, only the 25th to 75th percentiles are shown. There are many above those ranges, including some outliers with 3% or more of their company (choose Scientist > Fellow for one example). Also, according to the Source line at the bottom, executives and founders are excluded from the data set. Getting a large share of equity of a private company is rare for everyone else.
- untog 14y agoEquity offers to employees (past, say, the first ten) are usually at joke levels and used to try to negotiate your salary down and prevent you from leaving. Sometimes they'll even throw in a statement about "keeping you connected" or "making sure you're motivated". It's all crap- at best, the money you'll get from it will be equivalent to the bonus you'd get working for a larger company.
- potatolicious 14y agoWelcome to the ugly, ugly truth about startups. Employees have so little equity compensation it's almost hilarious - and yet founders will hand out 0.1% offers and expect you to take huge haircuts for the privilege of owning a tiny sliver of a 7-8 figure exit (potential exit, actually). Having seen the stock and bonus structure at Amazon and Google, I can confidently say that your expected outcomes are considerably higher at a top-tier tech company than at your average startup. Sometimes I wonder where all of this "take a haircut for equity" advice is coming from for employees. It's patently terrible given the amount of equity that most deals involve.
- pork 14y agoI'm sorry, do you mean "paycut" or is this some sort of idiom I'm not familiar with? What does hair have to do with it?
- potatolicious 14y agoIt's a Valley-ism - but yes, "haircut" simply refers to a (substantial) pay cut.
- loganfrederick 14y agoWhile the term has more specific meanings in finance, "haircut" it has been generalized to often mean "a small paycut". Wiki page with more info: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haircut_%28finance%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haircut_%28finance%29
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoHaircut is usually a term for taking a reduced return on an existing investment that is otherwise unlikely to pay off - for example many European banks have taken a haircut of upto 50% on Greek government bonds, otherwise the greek government would leave the Euro, default anyway and take its chances. Said haircut of course then stuffs their balance sheets, so they need bailing out, from for example Spainish government, which then cannot payout its loans and threatens a haircut to its investors. Who are the same damn banks it just bailed out. This leads to two situations - one ECB chief saying it will pay anything to anyone to stop this idiocy, just ask. And two, the philosophical approach to wealth "hair today, gone tomorrow"
- qq66 14y agoIt's probably an artifact of the data that Wealthfront is collecting. They're catering to people with wealth to manage, and critically, they omit founder-level employees in this chart. If you look at the people who've made over, say, $5 million from equity in Silicon Valley in the last couple of years, there are probably many more Facebook employees with 0.01% stakes than there are 1% employees at companies acquired for $500 million, or 2% employees at companies acquired for $250 million (above that and you're probably a founder).
- columbo 14y ago> But really why is that level of equity share of any influence in anyone's hiring equation? To be fair the article doesn't say if it influences many people or not. I do think it is putting emphasis on something that is simply of no real importance to most people in the job market. For example, it isn't clear to me if those jobs are paying market rate salaries or not. If that is the case then "equity" may as well be lumped into the 'free E-ZPass', 'paid gym memberships' category (not something to write home about, but nice all the same). With that said, I'd cut any interview short that was expecting me to take a serious pay-cut for a fractional equity share.
- chudi 14y agoSo if I moved to SF and work in the same start up that I'm working right now I would be rich by my country standards.
- NonEUCitizen 14y agoYour rent would go up a lot. But if you are careful about other spending, you can probably save up some money.
- clarkmoody 14y agoI would really appreciate a link to the page with the tool itself instead of to the blog post describing the page with the tool ;-)
- BrandonM 14y agoThe submission is mostly-useless blog spam around a cool tool: https://blog.wealthfront.com/startup-employee-equity-compensation/ https://blog.wealthfront.com/startup-employee-equity-compens...
- danielweber 14y agoThank you, this makes it a lot easier to select which JavaScript to run. (I needed to enable wealthfront and cloudfront.)
- protomyth 14y agoNormally, I like to dig down to the first source, but I've noticed those articles don't get the same attention as submitting from "the big sites". I submitted the original source for a lot of today's A6 articles, but it got no upvotes and only one comment. Looking over my submission history, the original source rarely gets the attention, and the rewrites articles get a lot of upvotes and comments. I'll keep alternating to see if there is some secondary pattern.
- at-fates-hands 14y agoThis is actually a pretty interesting tool. Not sure how accurate it is, since its telling me I should be making the same salary I've made at large corporations the last two years. Based on the interviewing I've been doing, most of the start-ups around here (Midwest) were offering close to 30-40K less than my corporate gigs.
- svdad 14y agoIn SF Bay area, my experience in the last year or so has been that salary comp is pretty much the same between start-ups and big companies, the only exception being super-early-stage startups (i.e. pre-series A) where they really don't have the money yet. The difference is that at bigco, they add bonus and equity grant that have real value, while at startup, they add some % of equity with unknown value. Companies like Amazon and Netflix are also different because they adjust the base salary up to compensate for their different equity award policies.
- Evbn 14y agoAmazon pretty famously does not adjust base salaries upward compared to other big companies.
- svdad 14y agoYeah, I think I misspoke somewhat, but not entirely. The Amazon comp structure, at least for the first four years after you join, as far as I know is something like this (and take this with a grain of salt, I haven't worked there): Y1: Base + large annual cash (non-perf) bonus + 5% stock vest + optional perf stock bonus Y2: Base + large annual cash (non-perf) bonus + 15% stock vest + optional perf stock bonus Y3: Base + 40% stock vest + optional perf stock bonus Y4: Base + 40% stock vest + optional perf stock bonus So yeah, they don't adjust the base upward, but they do give you extra cash in the first two years to compensate for their back-loaded stock vesting schedule. That's what I meant.
- rbellio 14y agoSo, am I right in assuming that this does not clearly reflect that early stage in development when there are less than 20 people in your company and there are individuals with multiple roles? I understand that there's a 6-20 group in there, but what happens when your software engineer is also your administrator, QA and tech support and your CFO is also your sales developer and sales engineer. Cool graphs though.
- urish 14y agoCould someone help me understand what is meant by job levels 1 - 5 ?
- chrisa 14y agoIt's a fairly common way to do advancement in large companies, and is usually based on experience. "Software Engineer I" is entry level, "Software Engineer II" has 3 – 5 years of experience, etc.
- mcherm 14y agoCan you fill in "etc."? I'd be interested to know what definitions they used for the levels (and whether it was consistent across different sources of data).
- Evbn 14y agoBeyond II (intermediate dev, not a college hire, the majority of working engineers) there is no meaning beyond "suitably impressive resume or reputation at the employer".
- paulsowden 14y agoSee here: http://www.bls.gov/ncs/ocs/ocs95apb.htm#programmer http://www.bls.gov/ncs/ocs/ocs95apb.htm#programmer
- dsolomon 14y agoWhat a load of crap. If companies paid that much then unemployment would be next to nil.
- purp 14y agoFor engineers in Silicon Valley, it very nearly is.
- noahc 14y agoI don't think unemployment is caused by out of work programmers. It's more the folks who have no or low skill jobs and those effected most by the recession such as construction workers. It's hard for me to imagine a construction worker being able to transition from the blue collar culture to the white collar culture that most of these jobs fall into. Again, It's not so much that construction workers are stupid, but if the ones that reroof my apartment are any indication, insulting each others mothers and swinging hammers at each other when one pisses the other one off are standard fair.
- portlander52232 14y agoActually, since the recession, unemployment increased by the same proportion in all sectors of the economy. That is, software engineering unemployment is about twice what it was before; construction unemployment is about twice what it was before; etc. etc. etc. This indicates that the problem is not structural (i.e. not due to people having the wrong skills), but due to a shortfall in demand: everybody tightened their spending at the same time. Sources can be dug up if desired.
- noahc 14y agohttp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/business/unemployment-where-are-the-jobs/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/business/unempl... seems to suggest otherwise.
- jasonkester 14y agoI've noticed you make comments like this every time salaries are mentioned around here, with usually the same reception. You seem to honestly believe what you're saying, and you seem to be genuine when you say that you've observed lots of low salaries in your portion of the industry. http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=dsolomon http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=dsolomon But you'd benefit from knowing that it's not like that, pretty much anywhere else in the developed world. Real developers really are making six figure salaries writing code for a living, working 40 hour weeks, no tricks. More important to you, specifically: You could be making six figures as a software developer. You just need to step out of your niche and go find a job for a public sector company. Given your comment history, I doubt you'll believe me, or any of the others here replying to you, or the dozens of people who have replied to you over the years. But it's true. We look forward to seeing you out here some day.
- jstultz 14y agoFrom the actual Wealthfront page: "I illustrate the importance of growing the size of the pie to one’s share of pie to my entrepreneurship students at the Stanford Graduate School of Business by reminding them of the formula for a circle’s circumference versus its area. The formula for circumference (a proxy for share of pie) is linear (2 πr) vs. the formula for area, which is exponential (πr²)." It seems to me that the value of growing the size of the pie as well as one's share of the pie is pretty easily understood and not in need of an analogy. But yet, this guy has decided to use one, and it is terrible. Not only is it quadratic, not exponential (a relatively minor detail), but what on earth, exactly, is the radius meant to represent in this analogy?
- confluence 14y agoThe bullshit you buy when you became a startup employee. Big companies grow their bullshit in linear time - whereas startups are exponential (whoops - I'm a wealth manager to stupid to do basic maths - of course I mean quadratic). Seeing these math flaws make me wonder if most wealth managers are, in fact, morons. I'm guessing they are - otherwise wouldn't they be making their own wealth to manage? Oh wait - this is how they are going to do it - ride the tech bubble and impressionable young millionaires to make their fortune. Clever girl (Jurassic park reference). /sarcasm
- SG- 14y agoI was hoping to read some real details instead of a simple paragraph and this tool. My opinion is that if you're a startup and you hire some people that don't get a share in the company, you're going to have to likely pay them a decent salary and not make promises of wealth one day. You'll also have to pay them more than you plan on paying yourself even if you're more qualified since you are getting more out of it if it succeeds. I worked for someone that started a small company (we were 2), I was simply a contractor/employee. The problem was and why I left was that he treated me as an equal in terms of responsibility even tho I had no stake in the company.
- peacemaker 14y agoI guess I'm doing something wrong according to this tool! I recently moved to the bay area and as a software engineer (I'd say level 4-5 on this tool) I'm earning nowhere near the numbers this tool is showing. No equity either... Are these numbers a true reflection of the compensation levels?
- moocow01 14y agoId say from being involved with hiring in a few different spots that they are definitely on the higher side but not insanely so. There are a lot of jobs in startups that are quite low on salary but higher on the equity side (or atleast thats what the pitch is) and those may not be as represented here. The shock to me was how little of difference there seems to be in salary based upon location - with cost of living put into the mix it makes me question being in California
- rabidsnail 14y agoWhy would I use this instead of the BLS data: http://www.bls.gov/ncs/ocs/sp/ncbl1627.txt http://www.bls.gov/ncs/ocs/sp/ncbl1627.txt Search for "Software Engineers, Applications"
- confluence 14y ago> We know Mark Zuckerberg did not build Facebook to get rich. His vision of “making the world more open and connected,” is Facebook’s real raison d’être. Sounds like ex post facto rewriting history bullshit to me. You start companies to make money (otherwise you'd start a non-profit). You may or may not have other reasons for starting the company. However saying that you didn't want the money after you become rich is false modesty and a form of social signalling. Founders may or may not want to change the world - but they unequivocally want to make a lot of money regardless of their other reasons. Indeed, most of these other reasons should be classified under the "reality distortion field" umbrella. These are used so that founders can say "Come with me and help me change the world!" - when what they really mean to say is "Come make me filthy rich and get paid less for pleasure of doing so you ingracious B player!". Psychological arbitrage is a real factor in start-ups and a lot of social negotiation. Be careful when dealing with others and remember - everyone is trying to screw you in some form or another (see Facebook founder fight over rights to stock). Trust no one (this is a PR piece and I'm 100% biased).
- aidenn0 14y agoThere are exceptions; Elon Musk clearly started SpaceX because he couldn't afford to develop the technology at a non-profit. Similarly it is common for well-off people who are retirement age to start a business that has no possibility of making any significant money just to have something to do.
- exxec 14y agoI'm from Germany, and 100k$ sounds enormous to me. This are saleries only top tier manegement is getting paid. But I'm curious about your additional costs like health insurance, unemployment insurance and so on. Also I'm curious about how much taxes you have to pay and whats a common net-salery (right word? opposite to gross^^)
- donavanm 14y agoAfter taxes, insurance, etc figure $65-70,000 net or "take home". Then you can invest up to $16,000 with deferred/sheltered taxes for 401k (private pension).