3 ms·
> If the ranking algo considers hundreds of influences, then it is an overcomplicated mess! "overcomplicated mess" seems to imply "it's a bad solution". While
by anamax 18y ago
> If the ranking algo considers hundreds of influences, then it is an overcomplicated mess!
"overcomplicated mess" seems to imply "it's a bad solution".
While Google's ranking system may be "bad" (they believe that it isn't good enough), "bad" or even "overcomplicated" doesn't follow from "hundreds of influences".
Consider the "design" of a common house cat. Its design is the result of thousands of influences.
It may be difficult for people to think about systems with hundreds of influences, but that's a people problem and doesn't imply that such systems are inferior to more understandable systems.
- palish 18y agoHousecats weren't designed, they were evolved. That's a big difference. There can be cleanliness and simplicity in design. Also, a housecat's goal is to live and to reproduce, which involves solving many problems, whereas the ranking algorithm's goal is to match text to relevant pages, which requires solving far fewer problems than a living creature, so it's really not a fair metaphor.
- anamax 18y ago> Housecats weren't designed, they were evolved. That's a big difference. What properties of a design do you think are determined by the design process as opposed to its outcome? > whereas the ranking algorithm's goal is to match text to relevant pages, which requires solving far fewer problems than a living creature While "relevance" is the commonly used term, "utility" or "value" would be more accurate. And they're far more complicated than you seem to think. There is no "best" search result for a given query. There's not even a best result for a given person. Add in their context, and you're getting close, but there are still other factors that are relevant to determining "best".
- bd 18y agoI suspect a large part of ranking algorithm's complexity comes also from evolution - they need to coevolve with all SEO stuff. Optimal ranking is a moving target, parasites break your fitness.