4 ms·
> Isn't trading higher profit for +11% more deaths also violence? I have a friend who firmly believes that speed limits higher than 50MPH are violence because
by Aurornis 1y ago
> Isn't trading higher profit for +11% more deaths also violence?
I have a friend who firmly believes that speed limits higher than 50MPH are violence because they lead to increased deaths. He argues that if we cared about people's lives we would impose a strict 50MPH limit on the roads and even force all cars to top out at 50MPH from the factory.
There are millions of tradeoffs in the world where we could reduce deaths, but there's never and endpoint where it's truly done. It's really easy to imagine revenge on PE firms by crushing their profits for a noble cause, but the conversation becomes a lot murkier when the impact starts hitting closer to your own paycheck or lifestyle.
- Muromec 1y agoIn residential area it is at the very least negligence on the part of authorities who set the limit
- Aurornis 1y agoThe claim was that 50mph should be the highest limit anywhere, including freeways. Combined with a hard 50mph limit imposed on vehicles. You buy a new car, it can't go faster than 50mph, period. The movement has roots in Ralph Nader going back to the 50s https://nader.org/1970/12/11/the-american-automobile-designed-for-death/ https://nader.org/1970/12/11/the-american-automobile-designe...
- Muromec 1y agoThat's a little bit out there if taken out of context. On my street the limit is 15 KM/h, on most city roads it's 30 (again, KM/h, not MPH), but on the actual highways where only cars are present and where you don't necessarily need to be, the limit is over a 100. Now I can probably understand how one can take such radical position, when living in a place that doesn't restrict cars as much as they are restricted here. It's like being so much disillusioned with US that USSR propaganda starts to be appealing and belieaveble. I guess?
- selimthegrim 1y agoJust wait until they start stealing wiper blades.
- tptacek 1y agoThis is what I'm getting at in the sibling comment. Most people make decisions that in the aggregate cost lives. The causal connection and moral weight of taking a life through speeding (or, more likely, by helping create the permission structure for everybody else to speed by speeding yourself) is pretty clear. And I'm saying this as someone who drives at the prevailing rate, rather than the posted limit. None of this is to say that PE firms squeezing vital hospitals aren't morally culpable. Just that there's a meaningful distinction between immoral decisionmaking and violence.
- potato3732842 1y agoThat's the "magic" that underpins all the perverse things modern western societies engage in. Life is considered valuable in integer quantities but fractional life is considered value-less. People are free to do, endorse, concoct and peddle all sorts of things that waste people's time (life) or waste people's money on the basis that it "saves lives" because it prevents lives from being lost in whole numbers but the sum total of the little fractions ad up to more.
- tptacek 1y agoI just think we can express the idea that things are very bad without doing violence to the word violence.
- rybosome 1y agoI see your point, but I’m not sure that I agree. Consider that when speeding, you might cause an accident. Such an accident would most likely impact a small number of people other than yourself. When a PE firm engages in extractive hospital management, it provably increases mortality rate, and it does so at scale. The first choice carries possible risks of lower magnitude, the second choice carries guaranteed risk of higher magnitude. “Risky behavior” vs “ruthless greed”, the latter feels much closer to violence.
- lkey 1y agoIntentionally and artificially reducing the quality or quantity of life-saving resources to the point of excess death is, in fact, violence. I think you wouldn't have trouble recognizing the starvation campaign is Gaza as intentional violence. Thus, I have no trouble asserting that PE firms commit intentional violence against patients. Indirection allows you diffuse the responsibility into the anodyne 'immoral decisionmaking' while social murder remains as it ever was.
- potato3732842 1y ago>I have a friend who firmly believes that speed limits higher than 50MPH are violence because they lead to increased deaths. He argues that if we cared about people's lives we would impose a strict 50MPH limit on the roads and even force all cars to top out at 50MPH from the factory. If you really want to stir shit ask him what we enforce those speed limits with. (hint:violence, but with extra steps)
- lkey 1y agoYou open your hood to see a 50 mph max speed engine in your vehicle... You notice that roving speed enforcement is no longer necessary except in school zones, freeing up public resources. You contemplate this new world... Is this... violence? It must be... manufacturing regulations are violence against businesses (people)! You relax a little. You imagine someone 'woke' being angry at your incisiveness, you are calm.
- degamad 1y agoI have an engine with a 50mph speed limiter on it. I open the hood and add a resistor across the input sensor so that it thinks I'm going 20% slower than I really am. I start driving at 60mph. How does society enforce the speed limit regulation against me? (Hint: the threat of, and eventually the use of, violence.)
- lkey 1y ago"we could reduce deaths, but there's never and endpoint where it's truly done" What a wonderful argument for never trying to improve the world you also reside in. "your own paycheck or lifestyle." If excess mortality is required for your lifestyle, change how you live. Do you deny insurance claims for fun? Are you the human avatar of GE and Raytheon? Do you need to manufacture child-vaporizing bombs to maintain your 'lifestyle'? Genuinely, what is wrong with you? PE firms are not people to take vengeance on. They are not necessary, if they vanished from the Earth tomorrow, the 'worst' outcome is the wealthy owners and workers would need to find new, less violent, employment.
- NekkoDroid 1y agoI recently saw an article which was talking about a study thatc concluded that if the Autobahn here in Germany had a speedlimit of 120 Kph we would save a grand total of roughtly 58 lives per year. German article: https://www.spiegel.de/auto/tempolimit-120-koennte-58-menschenleben-pro-jahr-retten-studie-zeigt-weniger-verkehrstote-a-9d3d51ba-c870-4fe6-a105-26368a4e21c4 https://www.spiegel.de/auto/tempolimit-120-koennte-58-mensch...