4 ms·
The best thing Kickstarter could do to stop people from being disappointed by getting a much worse product that they were expecting when they thought they "paid
by mtgx 14y ago
The best thing Kickstarter could do to stop people from being disappointed by getting a much worse product that they were expecting when they thought they "paid for it", is to not allow the people behind the project to say stuff like "for $99 you can get the product, too".
Basically, they shouldn't mention on their page at all that they will be getting the product. So whether you're donating $1 or $100 or $1000, it's just that - a donation to the cause. You're not "buying" anything. That should make things a lot more clear, although I expect the project donations to drop, but probably better than for Kickstarter to get its reputation ruined forever because most projects "don't deliver" the products people were "expecting", when they thought they bought it or "pre-ordered" it.
- rjtavares 14y agoI would rather have them display a standard warning sign saying that Kickstarter can't guarantee the successful delivery of products, and there is no money back policy. I quite like the pre-order style Kickstarters (like the recent Project Eternity by Obsidian), and as long as people are aware that you effectively donating money I don't see the problem with it.
- AndrewDucker 14y agoThey do this. When you click to donate you get this (in the top right): Kickstarter does not investigate a creator's ability to complete their project. The claims and responsibilities of this project are solely its creator's.
- s_henry_paulson 14y agoKickstarter would never do this, because this would virtually eliminate the largest incentives for donation. Many people would never reach the goals they need for production, and kickstarter themselves would be out millions as well.
- Smerity 14y agoIt's worse than that. Kickstarter have explicitly said they have no clue what they'd do that day. The fact they're either ignoring the (admittedly complicated) issue or are so naive as to think it's fine to only handle failed projects when they happen is disturbing. Kickstarter is an amazing concept but the coming wave of failed projects is going to mark the cumulative jumps of the shark. From an earlier interview with Kickstarter's founder[1], "I don't know. I mean, no, I don't think that we would. But certainly, the kind of thing you're talking about is not a bridge that has been crossed yet. Someday it will. And you know, I think if something did go awry, it would be — it wouldn't be my favorite day." [1]: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4472776 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4472776
- robryan 14y agoJust make it clear that you only get the product if things pan out. The tricky bit is if the money is only there to deliver some of the products. Needs to be some protection as well on people taking the money and running, but apart from that users shouldn't feel like they didn't get what they paid for if it doesn't pan out.
- Xylakant 14y agoBut that's not what Kickstarter is about. Kickstarter is not a donation page, why would I donate to someone who's trying to start an enterprise or a product? I could imagine donating to an artist, but that's about it. Nobody donated for my company either. So Kickstarter is a "It would be awesome if this product came to existence and I'm willing to buy the alpha version even if it doesn't exist yet and may never exist" kind of thing. It's the pledge that I buy one of those, unseen and unproven because it would be cool if I had one of those. You just need to be aware of the risk and you won't feel screwed over as badly. And don't go for kickstarters that just look too good. It's a hard to solve problem, but I think the only thing that kickstarter can actually do is to better communicate the risk.
- prawks 14y agoThe key word you used is "alpha". As the OP of this thread said, you're not buying a product, you're donating to someone (probably not a very large company with lots of resources) to develop and make something you're interested in, and in return you may get the 1.0 (or perhaps earlier) version of what you're donating for. I don't believe it's Kickstarter's fault in any way if people view it otherwise.
- Xylakant 14y agoIt's not donations. Donations are given without return to a cause you consider worthy. An exchange is promised, but the promise is not a sale, it's "We try and make this, and if we pull it of, you get one." It's more of a high-risk investment where you already consider the money lost, the moment you spend it. And I'm on your side: It's not kickstarters fault, if people think otherwise - still they could make that point a little stronger.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoKickstarter supports the arts. Many, many people support artistic endeavors solely for the tshirt and the satisfaction. Its the larger part of their base.
- 14y ago
- jaimebuelta 14y agoAgree that the main problem in Kickstarter is communication. You should NEVER put money if you don't understand that you are betting on the product and the team. It is a high risk decision, which hopefully most of the times goes reasonable good (I got last week headphones by a Kickstarter project and everything went just fine) But removing the possibility of offering a product seems too much. I think that, after a little while and a few big "unfortunate" projects, the process (specially for deliverable goods) will be more understood and there will be more pressure in showing the team skills, previous products, etc. Right now that's not very clear (though you can research on your own, of course)