3 ms·
Seems like it's all about the Islam movie, which is not really what I'd call 'Hacker News'.
by davidw 14y ago
Seems like it's all about the Islam movie, which is not really what I'd call 'Hacker News'.
- huhtenberg 14y agoDon't know why you are downvoted as I am too unclear what this thing is doing on top of HN.
- davidw 14y agoI don't care about downvotes. Karma to me is only useful in that it allows me to say things that aren't popular occasionally.
- markyc 14y agoIt's because with size, HN is getting more stuffed up with fluffy common interest news, which get upvoted by the "late comers". sadly, it's the price of popularity.. maybe a reddit style h/startups h/misc h/programming h/design is in order?
- _delirium 14y agoI don't think in this case it's purely due to being random common-interest news, but due to being something Neil Gaiman, a popular figure in geek culture, posted on his blog. You see similar things when a well-known tech or geek-culture figure posts something about economics or politics on his/her blog.
- nandemo 14y agoThis post also appears at the top of the classic view, so I don't think "late comers" are to blame. http://news.ycombinator.com/classic http://news.ycombinator.com/classic
- moo 14y agoHacker News articles are usually related to: Internet startup business news/ideas/management. STEM news/discovery/training. Software tools for web applications. Also allowed but generates complaints is: Civil liberties issues like freedom of speech. I think this article could fall under that. Maybe we can have a StackOverflow tag system to mark the relevance for some readers. I'm glad we have a capitalist system because businesses like freedom of speech because they like to advertise.
- hef19898 14y agoWhat's pretty much hacker news to me is that this post shines some light on the whole story. Up to now, I didn't know it was a fraud, even in hindsight it is pretts obvious. Where all that turns hacker news is that quite often it's "hackers" (read anonymous etc.) that are dragging truth out. Up to now, the story behind this video was never in news I read or watched. All we've got over here in Germany are some pseudo discussions about freedom of speech and art with some undertones of general freedom in the internet. Not one word about the fact that some terrorists used an apparently made-up movie to stage attacks at western embassies and causing civil unrest. Which is, by the way, also helping all the western "islam is evil EVIL" sayers. As always the radicals on both sides of the line are profiting and mainstream media is playing the game along the whole way down. So yes, upvoted the post to promote a different view and new bit of information about this whole mess.
- davidw 14y ago"This whole mess" is not hacker news though, so neither is new information about it, just as new information about Mitt Romney's tax returns, Obama's former pastor or Ron Paul's nose hair would likely not be suitable for this site.
- blrgeek 14y agoThis movie would not have reached the millions it did without Youtube or the Internet.
- scotty79 14y agoBig name SF writer helping little gal to publish message about how she was abused by digital media manipulation that impacted the world through internet? Seems to overlap with HN audience interests. Hence the front page.
- saraid216 14y agoI wouldn't call Gaiman an SF writer. He does a lot of genre-overlapping, but he never really strays into SFish stuff. /nitpick (Unless you know of something he's done? I mean, there's that one poem about alien abductions, but I don't feel like that counts.)
- scotty79 14y agoYou are absolutely right. My mistake.