By that metric all of science has failed, or at least the biomedical fields. Psychology looks like particle physics compared to fields like dentistry, and not

By that metric all of science has failed, or at least the biomedical fields. Psychology looks like particle physics compared to fields like dentistry, and not a lot different from a lot of biomedical fields. Psychology is just the messenger — meta-science goes under the radar but it's probably its biggest contribution to science at large. I agree about replication in any case (not just psychological studies), but I have to say this seems like it probably would. If anything I think it underrepresents the phenomenon it studies because support for corruption and unethical behavior is likely to be underestimated in this kind of setting/design.