4 ms·
all those crooked, lopsided, curvaceous streets, going off in so many directions, I can't help wondering, what would it be like to wander there? It would be li
by jrockway 14y ago
all those crooked, lopsided, curvaceous streets, going off in so many directions, I can't help wondering, what would it be like to wander there?
It would be like the suburbs in the US. Houses are all on cul-de-sacs that wind around and eventually join larger streets which eventually join arterial streets. Pretty much like the map of Istanbul they chose.
- roc 14y agoCul-de-sac suburban developments rarely connect to neighboring developments. They don't even always connect to all of the larger streets that they border. This lack of connectivity between them is the primary criticism. The map of Istanbul suggests that you might wander into a dead-end alley or cul-de-sac, but one does not enter what amounts to a neighborhood full of dead-ends, the only exit from which is the way you came in. It certainly doesn't suggest that any notable fraction of city is subdivided that way.
- davidw 14y agoI don't buy it at all. One of the things I love about Italy is that the level of diversity and odd details in the architecture is amazing, and "fractal" in the more pop-science sense of being able to look at things closer and closer and find new and interesting things to see. I find US burbs incredibly boring in their sameness, although they do have other advantages.
- oh_sigh 14y agoSomething tells me you've either never walked around Istanbul, or you've never walked around a suburb, or both.
- illuminate 14y agoI had to walk around some US suburbs recently to visit a friend, it was hilarious how sprawly, labyrinthine areas with zero sidewalks and the barest of shoulders were advertised on the real estate signs as "walkable". I suppose you can technically walk from one place to another, but not easily, and not with any density of things to walk to.