5 ms·
The long release cycle for new versions of IE is irrelevant. Internet Explorer security patches get pushed regularly through Windows Update, which Microsoft enc
by greenyoda 14y ago
The long release cycle for new versions of IE is irrelevant. Internet Explorer security patches get pushed regularly through Windows Update, which Microsoft encourages users to set up for automatic installation. So this problem will get fixed for the average user as soon as Microsoft sends out the patch. It requires no more knowledge than updating Chrome does.
Note that I'm not recommending that anybody use IE. I'm just pointing out that it does get automatic updates, just like other browsers.
- just2n 14y agoI don't think I'd compare Windows Updates (the most broken updating system I've ever seen) to how Chrome manages updates. I've fixed computers running IE7 and with WU disabled. I ask why and I'm told "because the popups are annoying, and because upgrading IE is a pain in the ass." I agree. When I install Chrome for them, then later point out that it has updated 10 times in the past few months, they say "I never saw anything." As it should be.
- ladzoppelin 14y agoI find Windows update to be the most reliable update of any software. Since 2005 I can't even imagine how many updates I have run on thousands of computers that never once "broke" because of an update. MS worked out how to test updates years ago and now , unless you have malware, its probably not going to break anything. Also keep in mind that if Chrome was released in 1998 with its current update model it would of failed with people screaming to governments that Google was spying on them.
- thaumaturgy 14y agoTrue, but there is an important difference between Chrome background updates and Windows Updates: Windows Updates are easy to disable, and, in our experience, frequently are disabled by users for various reasons. Users find that they hate trying to reboot (or start up) one day and then wait for 30 minutes while their computer does nothing more than display a "Now installing update 3 (of 30)..." screen. (This is especially obnoxious on big Windows Server installations where this process can take a server down for an entire weekend.) Or they hate being nagged all the time that there are updates available. Or they hate having their computer insist every five to ten minutes that it needs to be restarted now. Or they're gun-shy about it because an update once changed the layout of Windows Live Mail and left them completely confused about why it was suddenly so different even though they hadn't changed anything. In one fun case, we had a corporate client disable automatic updates for their entire research lab because one night Windows update decided it needed to automatically reboot every single system there. They were running overnight experiments and came in the next morning to find that all of the night's data was missing or corrupted, costing them a day on a tight schedule. Microsoft does software updates in a very, very wrong way, and that means that a rather large number of people think it's better to just ignore the updates.
- com2kid 14y agoWindows Update is very configurable, both through AD policies and on a per user basis. If a machine shouldn't be auto-updating, set it to manual reminders. Plain and simple. As for updates, in my experience they are generally small and fast to install once you have gotten over the initial update push of a clean Windows installation. And of course in domains, you can setup custom update roll outs, no need to use MS's update servers. Finally, for servers, install the OS onto an SSD. Updates will take seconds. Problem solved. While it would be nice if more components could update without restarts (and I think people forget how much better things are now than they used to be!), the fact is every major piece of software out there requires restarts to install updates. Of course there are awesome-cool Linux and other OSs that do not require restarts (IBM obviously has had that tech for ages, really cool stuff), but with how Windows is designed (back-compat first), that isn't likely coming any time soon. I've also had long running work disrupted by Windows update. The simple solution was to check "Ask before installation". Problem solved. (And to be honest, Browser restarts are just as troubling to me now days as rebooting my entire PC!)
- thaumaturgy 14y agoEverything you said is technically correct, and helpful to some people, but it doesn't change the fact that most users opt to simply disable automatic updates in one fashion or another. Manual updates, and "download-but-don't-install" are both different from the Chrome example, and in both cases, will cause IE to not be immediately patched for all of its users even once Microsoft pushes an update for it. And, if I may push back just a little bit more: "install an SSD" should ideally never, ever be a serious solution to the problem of software updates. I'd like to think that I'd have the good grace to be completely embarrassed if I ran a software company that had advocates telling other people that my long update process could be "solved" by installing an SSD. Not that you're technically wrong.
- cooldeal 14y ago>but it doesn't change the fact that most users opt to simply disable automatic updates in one fashion or another Most people disable auto updates? Do you have a reference for that or is that just your personal anecdote? Most people and PCs I've been auto update. Normal users don't even care to take the time to find out if they can be disabled. You can only force users so much. Installing updates and restarting is a default and people who go out of their way to prevent it deserve to take some responsibility, it's their machine after all, not Microsoft's nor yours. If Windows forced everyone to update and restart automatically without a way to turn it off, a lot of people will raise hell over it. Some people don't like even browsers autoupdating under them.
- mtgx 14y agoI disable the automatic updates as soon as I install Windows. I find them very annoying, and unless there's a serious issue with that version of Windows, I'd rather just wait a couple of years for the next service pack or something, before I install the updates.
- greedo 14y agoThere are serious issues on an extremely frequent basis with Windows and all it's applications. Whether it's the OS, Office, or IE, it's rare for there not to be critical updates on a monthly basis. This month was the first time in four years that my team had the option to defer patching til next month.