2 ms·
Yeah I've definitely noticed subtle coloration changes with Seedream / Qwen 20b as opposed to Nano-Banana. OTOH, Qwen is capable of accomplishing edits that Nan
by vunderba 1y ago
Yeah I've definitely noticed subtle coloration changes with Seedream / Qwen 20b as opposed to Nano-Banana. OTOH, Qwen is capable of accomplishing edits that Nanobanana can't handle. [1]
Nanobanana has a strong tendency to just return the exact image back to you in those cases. So it's a bit of a pick your poison issue.
I think it comes down to your use-case. If your intent is professional studio grade photograph manipulation then NanoBanana is your best bet. Otherwise Seedream and honestly Qwen are both perfectly servicable.
[1] https://genai-showdown.specr.net/image-editing https://genai-showdown.specr.net/image-editing (see the M and M test)
EDIT: What does "Nano Banana operates directly in pixel space" mean? Information on the internals of Nano-Banana seem to be pretty sparse. Do you have a source for this?
- BoredPositron 1y agoIt means it doesn't use a vae. I usually do some tests with pixel grids on new models 16x16,8x8,4x4,2x2 and with nano bana there is none of the typical degradation of Vae models. It's probably a similar to what lodestone does with the new chroma radiance model. https://huggingface.co/lodestones/Chroma1-Radiance https://huggingface.co/lodestones/Chroma1-Radiance