3 ms·
Fiber cut https://aviationweek.com/air-transport/cut-cables-trigger-dallas-flight-disruptions https://aviationweek.com/air-transport/cut-cables-trigger-da...
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
Fiber cut
https://aviationweek.com/air-transport/cut-cables-trigger-dallas-flight-disruptions https://aviationweek.com/air-transport/cut-cables-trigger-da...
- ranger_danger 1y ago> “This is a clear example of the FAA’s outdated infrastructure and underscores the urgent need to modernize our air traffic control systems,” the agency said in its Sept. 20 update. “Moving from aging, analog systems to more resilient, digital technology, is critical to maintaining the reliability and resiliency of the national airspace system.” Umm, what? How is a fiber cut an "aging, analog system"? They even admitted that there was supposed to be redundancy in place but the system did not work.
- fishgoesblub 1y agoOh you know, analog telephone wires, digital fibre, they're both wire shaped so they're the same.
- imoverclocked 1y agoIt's not the fiber that's the problem. I mean, it is ... but that's not the analog part we are talking about. ATC communications are still over two-way radio. It's like walkie-talkies but on aviation bands instead of citizen bands. There are digital communications in some cases but it's definitely not the baseline.
- bigfatkitten 1y agoAnd that part is not the problem.
- anon7000 1y agoIt’s a good example of legacy technology with severe flaws
- bigfatkitten 1y agoAnd with nothing approximating good (let alone better) to replace it.
- ranger_danger 1y agoWhat are you calling better? I would think digital spread-spectrum encrypted communications are arguably better in just about every way... except maybe simplicity.
- bigfatkitten 1y agoThis comes with some massive and obvious issues with no clear benefits. The first is the loss of the very desirable property of AM voice, which is that one station can talk over another station in an emergency and still be heard. Another is that encryption creates lots of new problems, and solves no existing problems. The issue of people impersonating pilots on VHF AM, or broadcasting spoofed ADS-B positions is well managed procedurally and through technologies that can cross check each other. The entire system is built on the premise that no single source of information is always reliable. Key management is a non starter, given that pretty much anyone in the world is entitled to own and operate an aircraft, and to generally fly it where they please, and so it needs to work anywhere. The replacement needs to work on any aircraft that will operate in a civil CNS/ATM environment. That means anything from a hot air balloon to an 80 year old warbird, to an F-35 or a large transport category jet. The technology cannot be subject to any export controls globally. Then there’s the fact there are hundreds of thousands of aircraft globally out there that would need to be retrofitted, and ground infrastructure replaced, at a cost of hundreds of billions of dollars. Replacing a radio on an aircraft is not a case of just buying one from Best Buy and plugging it in. It needs to integrate with other aircraft systems. This means getting STCs and other approvals, with very substantial engineering effort, with varying (or nonexistent) levels of manufacturer support. The same applies for CNS/ATM systems on the ground segment.
- imoverclocked 1y ago
- emchammer 1y agoFiber can be and often is used to carry wideband analog signals.
- Spooky23 1y agoIt sounds better than “we fired everyone who didn’t quit”