5 ms·
Elsewhere on the thread I pointed out that I'd noticed the video doesn't show anybody doing actual prep; making an easy but deliberate thin slice of a tomato is
by tptacek 1y ago
Elsewhere on the thread I pointed out that I'd noticed the video doesn't show anybody doing actual prep; making an easy but deliberate thin slice of a tomato is one thing, quickly dicing an onion or a bell pepper is a very different thing.
To that observation I'd add (h/t my Slack friends) this interesting site Seattle Ultrasonics stood up:
https://seattleultrasonics.com/pages/knife-database https://seattleultrasonics.com/pages/knife-database
One thing I notice here is that Japanese knives (and my trusty MAC) fare really well on the BESS and CATRA scale, but relatively poorly on the "Food Cutting Rank", which is based on an ad-hoc seeming performance scale of how well their robot fared with a bunch of cutting tests that included stuff like bread and cheese (h/t again Slack friends) --- which nobody uses a chef's knife to cut.
That's a weird scale to plot chef's knives across --- unless the purpose of building that scale was to showcase an electronic knife that does well on tasks people don't normally use chef's knives for, but maybe not as well on chef knife daily driver tasks.
- SilverElfin 1y agoI was surprised by that too. The Shun did surprisingly well in the real world test despite lower scores on the other two categories.
- data-ottawa 1y agoA slight tangent but I find sharpness tests often don’t represent the experience at the macro level, but it’s easily benchmarked and quantified. As an example are tons of people pushing Feather or Astra or similar ultra sharp shaving razors. I bought a ton of sample packs the ones I liked the most were Kai, which are considered relatively dull, but have properties which make the overall experience better (I recall reading they’re thicker and vibrate less during cutting). To me that makes this knife cutting benchmark more attractive than sharpness or retention, but I still have questions about technique used in the benchmarks, and how that affects knife performance (e.g. I would never try to cut bread by just pressing down as this move does).
- ReptileMan 1y agoThe problems were even bigger than that - they tested factory sharpness and factory geometry that often are shit. And not thinning and sharpening them properly. Let alone that the steel on the factory edge has high chance to fatigued/softer than the rest.
- CamperBob2 1y agoOne obvious question is where on that list the product in question would fall.
- formerly_proven 1y agoMy question for this product is entirely different: It's well-known that ultrasonic sound can still damage your hearing despite being inaudible or nearly so. Does this?
- condiment 1y agoA talented chef might cut vegetables at 25hz, while the blade is moving at 44khz. So whatever cutting improvement is conferred by the ultrasonic tech will certainly be applied towards fast cutting. It seems that the main benefit for fast cutting would be that food doesn't stick to the blade. I'll cut bread with my chef's knife (amazon shun knockoff) when I want to make less of a mess. One interesting thing I noticed is that when Scott was cutting bread in the video he was cutting a croissant and no crumbs fell. It will be interesting to see the knife in the hands of real chefs. Two things I'm curious about are whether the ergonomics of the button are good, and whether the ultrasonic action atomizes foods as they're being cut, changing the experience of cooking in some way.
- tptacek 1y agoI'm not saying it can't work, just that they didn't show it, and after the required thin-tomato-slice that's the thing I'd most want to see the knife doing.
- knifemaster 1y agoFor reference it would be also nice to see your (and your Slack friends) knife handling skills.
- tptacek 1y agoWh...why? I'm not selling anything. I'm just saying dicing an onion is a better test of a chef's knife than taking a single thin slice of a tomato. Seems like that's an argument you can just take on directly. I don't think there's anything interesting about my onion dice. You'd be seeing a video of a banged up MAC, scraped up from all the times I've casually sharpened it in a hurry, doing the standard one-cross-cut Jacques Pepin onion dice. You know, an onion dice. (The "Slack friend" thing was just that I felt bad about sharing a link I'd gotten just a few minutes while pretending as if I'd known about it myself. I have no idea their level of expertise! Probably better than mine though.)
- 1y ago
- neilv 1y agoGinsu confused us about use cases. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wzULnlHr8w&t=25s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wzULnlHr8w&t=25s
- jfim 1y agoI can see why one would use a serrated knife to cut bread, but what knife would one use to cut cheese other than a chef's knife?
- mgiampapa 1y agoA Santoku or other knife with scalloped sides do well. There are also in fact, cheese knifes, for cutting and serving that are popular for self service cheese boards. Wire is also popular for cutting large block cheeses.
- rcpt 1y agoThere are cheese knives that are either very high aspect or have a holes so nothing will stick.
- tptacek 1y agoIronically, the cheeses I would cut with a chef's knife are exactly the ones that aren't going to stick to the knife. The ones that get messy are just as easy to cut with a butter knife. (Amusingly, butter is one of the demos in this video.)
- realityfactchex 1y agoJacques Pépin suggested at [0] "basically you need three knives": - a chopping knive, 9-12" depending on one's hand - a utility knife for slicing, about 6" - a paring knife, a cheaper ordinary one is fine Of those, other than the chopping/chef's knife, I imagine that one could generally slice cheese with the utility knife (depending on the cheese, of course). [0] https://youtu.be/nffGuGwCE3E?t=12 https://youtu.be/nffGuGwCE3E?t=12
- maxnoe 1y ago> That being said, I probably have 300 knifes in my home Don't forget the follow up
- helsinki 1y agoA cheese knife.
- montag 1y agoThe nerdy sales pitch got me excited about a knife. Also, I have to wonder if the name is a deliberate nod to the Seattle Supersonics...
- Mtinie 1y agoI shared this with my tech friends: “This has all the hallmarks of a product that’s going to be disappointing but I’m so optimistic it won’t be.” I’m seriously hopefuls it works because vibroblades (I mean, “progressive knives” and “high frequency blade”) are awesome and the timelines of Neon Genesis Evangelion and Metal Gear are getting closer. Which may, or may not be a good thing.
- SilverElfin 1y agoWell we know this tech works because there are already ultrasonic cutters in medical and industrial equipment. So it’s more about whether they implemented it well, rather than some new fundamental discovery.
- john_minsk 1y agoIs it realistic to have enough power in such a small form factor for this effect?
- SilverElfin 1y agoYes think of it as a more powerful electric toothbrush. There are actually already toothbrush sized ultrasonic knives you can buy online. This just applies the same tech to what largely looks like a normal chefs knife.
- ars 1y agoAnd for home use: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FK9SB5KR https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FK9SB5KR HOZO NeoBlade Wireless Ultrasonic Cutter
- slug 1y agoI got a wired (usb-c) ultrasonic cutter for around $100 (not this one), and it's amazing for cutting precise holes on electronic project boxes (plastic / abs).
- saxonww 1y agoThe two things that stood out to me: "The best tools shouldn't only be accessible to the pros" but his knife costs more than every knife in that database. The weight is listed in their help articles as 330g. I also think that handle is chunkier than a typical high end chef's knife. It may be easier to cut things with it, but I think your hand and arm are going to get tired of using it more quickly than with a regular knife at ~100g less. And I realize these fare worse than the high end japanese and german knives, but it's hard to get excited about a $400 knife you can't put in the dishwasher when you can get a perfectly credible fibrox knife for about a tenth of that, which doesn't require charging and can tolerate 'careless home cook' levels of abuse.
- tptacek 1y agoYeah the handle was the first thing I saw here that gave me pause. The handle shape matters a lot! Though: do. not. put. your. $300. knife. in. the. dishwasher.
- saxonww 1y agoI felt the collective cringe from everyone reading that comment :).
- CamperBob2 1y agoFor those of us who aren't knowledgeable in this field, what happens if you do?
- tptacek 1y agoIt's hard to do irreparable damage to the steel of a knife. It's just an inert lump of metal. But you could fuck up the handle. Theoretically, the detergent could dull your edge. If you don't isolate your knife and it rattles around, that'll definitely dull it. Mostly: it should only take a couple seconds to clean off your knife in the sink.
- defrost 1y ago
- comfysocks 1y agoFeel free to correct me if I’m off base, but it doesn’t seem like the robot is actually slicing. Looks more like it’s just mashing the blade into the tomato. In this case I can see how the vibration can make up for the lack of slicing action. Ie sliding the blade across the tomato. My question is: would there still be an improvement if they used a slicing action?
- _9ptr 1y agoThe difference in sharpness remains if there's no slicing motion with either knive/setting, right?
- cwong430 1y agoThe lower the better on the Food Cutting Rank
- tptacek 1y agoYes, I get how the scale works, just not why I should take that scale more seriously than sharpness x edge retention.
- jaredhallen 1y agoNobody uses a chef's knife to cut cheese?
- KingMob 1y agoAhh, but now they could. No need for specialized cheese-cutting tools with this knife, presumably. Ditto for bread knives.
- eagle2com 1y agoHm, I never understood the need for serrated bread knives. They make a mess and my chef's knife cuts bread just fine?
- KingMob 1y agoI believe the thinking is serrated knives work best for things where the skin is tough, but the internal structure is weak. So crusty bread with a lot of air inside. Also, surprisingly, tomatoes. Lots of people suggest small serrated knives (if you have them) for tomatoes.
- lightedman 1y ago"nobody uses a chef's knife to cut." Hi, originally-trained Oriental cook here. Yes, we do use chefs knives to cut cheese. Also cleavers. Also wires.
- spott 1y agoI don’t understand judging a knife by any measure of “sharpness”? Sharpness is what the sharpener brings to the knife. Edge retention is the steel, but the skills of the sharpener (against how easy the steel is to sharpen) are what defines the edge sharpness. This is mostly just a remark on the fact that BESS is probably just measuring the factory edge… which only matters until it has dulled the first time?
- tptacek 1y agoThat... seems wrong? It leaves out edge geometry and carbide size?
- spott 1y agoEdge geometry only matters after the initial cut. BESS measures how much force it takes for the knife to cut a calibrated thread. Carbide size maybe? But mostly I think it changes toothiness (so slicing, not push cutting). Also, I think that affects how hard or easy it is to get a given edge, but not how good the edge (as measured by BESS) can actually be.
- bjt 1y agoI also noticed that while they show the traditional knives struggling to make their way through something hard like a carrot, they never show the ultrasonic knife cutting a carrot. I suspect the ultrasonic feature helps more on softer things.
- aidenn0 1y agoMaybe it changed since you posted it, but right now the top 3 knives there by "Food Cutting Rank" are Japanese (Shun, Moritaka, Tojiro), with a Wuesthof coming in at 4th? All of the Japanese brands I recognized were in the top 10 (out of 21) with the MAC being exactly in the middle.