4 ms·
Cases are great because everyone can get one that matches their risk level and frequency of drops. Having a sacrificial outer layer that I can replace for $10
by Aurornis 1y ago
Cases are great because everyone can get one that matches their risk level and frequency of drops.
Having a sacrificial outer layer that I can replace for $10 is also preferable to letting the $1000 phone take the damage.
- raverbashing 1y agoYup for both counts I don't see what's the big deal honestly Some people just seem to like making things harder on themselves Meanwhile if I drop my phone (which I'm very careful, so it was probably once or twice and not from too high) it's really nbd
- hombre_fatal 1y agoYeah, I never understand these caseless discussions. I went caseless once since I didn't realize my case would arrive a week after I bought the phone. The phone was slippery (couldn't temporarily rest it on my knee), and I found myself inspecting the restaurant/bar table any time I put the phone down after that one night I placed it right into a puddle of beer condensation and some mysterious food that got in the mic on the back of the phone and grossed me out. The phone could be indestructible to drops and it still wouldn't solve those issues.
- giraffe_lady 1y agoI just use one of those pop out nubbin grip things that were popular like ten years ago.
- cosmic_cheese 1y agoI go caseless just because of sheer amount of bulk cases add, even the "thin" ones. It significantly impacts how easy the device is to hold and pocket. The Air I might consider putting a bumper case on since its thinness offsets the bulk increase, but it's specifically made to be resilient to drops so it's a coin toss even with that. I barely drop my phone though, it happens maybe twice a year, usually on carpet. In the last decade my phones might've had a run-in with concrete or pavement 2-3 times, tops.
- selectodude 1y agoMy case is AppleCare+.
- garbagewoman 1y agoThat seems wasteful
- wlesieutre 1y ago$120/year on an iPhone 17, or $140/year on Air, Pro, and Pro Max Even for one year that's more than I'd spend to avoid using a phone case, and if I keep it for five years again that's $700. There are other benefits to AppleCare (a case doesn't cover theft or loss) but I'm not very worried about any of them.
- garbagewoman 1y agoI mean its wasteful in terms of the energy/co2 required to service your phone replacements. Wasting resources unnecessarily.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- sedatk 1y agoAppleCare One is about $240/year and covers three devices. https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2025/07/apple-introduces-applecare-one-streamlining-coverage-into-a-single-plan/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2025/07/apple-introduces-appl...
- estimator7292 1y agoThe caseless argument is that a multi-thousand dollar device shouldn't be so fragile that you MUST wrap it in plastic to be in any way functional. A $1k phone SHOULD NOT be a frictionless glass prism. It should not skate away from you ob smooth surfaces. It should not be destroyed by falling 3 inches onto a hard surface. It should have some durability inherent to it. But instead apple spends billions of dollars making phones even more fragile and it's everyone's problem. We now have to spin up factories processing plastic into custom cases, and throw out all the old plastic cases and the older, more functional phones. The argument is that phones could (and should) be inherently more robust and durable all on their own. It should not be a hard requirement for you to go out and buy your own case just for the phone to survive any level of daily use. If they made phones out of plastic instead of glass, this wouldn't be an issue. Plastic backed phones almost always have a texture and when they don't even smooth plastic offers more friction. Plastic phones don't slide away like they're on ice. They don't shatter like my Note 10 did when it slid out of my pocket two inches to the ground. They also don't usually self destruct when you repair them. The caseless argument isn't that cases suck, it's that we MUST use cases because phones intentionally suck. A phone is not a functional object, it's artistic ego masturbation.
- hombre_fatal 1y agoBut didn't I just make a case (heh) that it's not only about drop fragility? It's a cheap sacrificial shell that adds utility. My examples were non-slip and grime from a public table. Maybe add scratches and impact damage in there too because every material is susceptible to that, and avoiding them helps me resell it. There's no way to build that into a phone. I don't want rubber non-slip bumpers on my phone or a built-in clawed up plastic shell when I can have them in a swappable shell.
- raverbashing 1y agoWell, you're not technically wrong. But 99% of people won't like the solution where this has to work out of the box Every moderately "needs impact resistance" in the prosumer/professional sector either comes with a case, or has a "builtin" case, making it thicker/heavier. Just search for 'Cat mobile phones' A grain of sand will scratch most metals and most glass surfaces, even hardened ones. If Apple managed to make this more resistant props to them, but it is not infallible Vandalism resistant electronics are thick and have glass/polycarbonate/acrylic combinations that don't look good for the most part but will take a baseball bat like a champ
- everdrive 1y agoPretty crazy concept; I wonder if someone could ever figure out something for a replaceable battery.
- n8cpdx 1y agoMagnetically attachable external batteries exist. Apple basically came up with the concept (MagSafe).
- shpx 1y agoYou usually just need to replace the front or back glass, which is $30 with Apple Care or $60 for both, not the entire iPhone. I crack mine about once a year.
- garbagewoman 1y agoEver thought about getting a case and lowering your carbon footprint?
- dcow 1y agoHow do you replace just the glass with AppleCare? They always tell you it’s a full phone replace if the glass is broken, unless it’s changed recently (which would be welcome).
- shpx 1y agohttps://support.apple.com/iphone/repair https://support.apple.com/iphone/repair
- whycome 1y agoWe call these the “use case scenarios”
- realityfactchex 1y agoAre the $10 "rugged defender style cases" found online actually as protective for drops as the $80 actual Otterbox Defender branded case? I really wonder, seems like maybe, and might be worth looking into. If so, that would be fantastic and would make the case round to 2 orders of magnitude less costly than the device, instead of just 1.
- Moto7451 1y agoThis, and the options you probably would hate on the phone stock. For my 17 Pro I got a case with a kickstand. If the kickstand breaks off I get a new $16 case. If it was built into the phone I’d possibly need a new backplate depending on the damage. Probably not $16 to fix. A built in kick stand would certainly become a love it or hate it feature based on how people use the thing. And there are people out there who are going to be huge fans of the Flower Power iMac. They can get just such a case and Apple doesn’t have to take the loss on that given 2025 design aesthetic .
- tshaddox 1y agoBut you’ll only ever see the “sacrificial layer,” and never see “real layer,” right? So are you only concerned about protecting against major functional breakage? Or maybe only concerned about resale value?