3 ms·
gbog sounds a bit like the main character from Verne's Paris au XXe siècle, a classics scholar who is shunned for searching for timeless truth in a modernist, m
by bitwize 14y ago
gbog sounds a bit like the main character from Verne's Paris au XXe siècle, a classics scholar who is shunned for searching for timeless truth in a modernist, materialist world that focuses only on technology and business.
The classics are classics for a reason: they are universal and timeless, and contain deep truths about the human condition that resonate forever. If Gates had read them early in life, maybe he would not have developed the predatory personality that characterized his business career and Microsoft in general?
- gbog 14y agoYes, that's my point, and the anti-culture trend I can feel on HN, while somewhat justified, because there are culture douche in some places, is missing the bigger picture: culture, classic books, and so on, are the only way to build a better world.
- irahul 14y ago> and the anti-culture trend I can feel on HN What do you mean by anti-culture trend? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture Of all the definitions listed here, what on earth would anti-culture mean? This is the 20th century definition: In the 20th century, "culture" emerged as a central concept in anthropology, encompassing the range of human phenomena that cannot be attributed to genetic inheritance. Specifically, the term "culture" in American anthropology had two meanings: (1) the evolved human capacity to classify and represent experiences with symbols, and to act imaginatively and creatively; and (2) the distinct ways that people living in different parts of the world classified and represented their experiences, and acted creatively. If by culture, you mean the practices which have been followed for some time(won't that be tradition?), count me in as anti culture and tradition. "Something exists for a long time, hence it is useful" is bullshit. Culture and traditions are mostly dynamic, and people who think of a them as a static rather than ever changing snapshot of current human behavior are some of the biggest, bigoted assholes I have ever seen. > culture, classic books, and so on, are the only way to build a better world. Do you have anything other than your personal opinion to back up culture(whatever that means) or classic books building better world?
- gbog 14y agoThere is another meaning: culture is what a cultivated man has. I think this meaning is continental, French and German. It is something one person gains with time by broadening his familiarity with the best products of the human mind, like classic books, paintings, etc.
- irahul 14y ago> There is another meaning: culture is what a cultivated man has. Cultivated as in "educated and refined"? And somehow who doesn't give a shit about Kant isn't educated or refined? > It is something one person gains with time by broadening his familiarity with the best products of the human mind, like classic books, paintings, etc. Expanding your horizons is good. Claiming reading obscure books is the way towards a better world is douchebaggery.
- irahul 14y ago> gbog sounds a bit like the main character from Verne's Paris au XXe siècle, a classics scholar who is shunned for searching for timeless truth in a modernist, materialist world that focuses only on technology and business. Search for whatever you want - I couldn't care less. But when you come out saying "I read Kant. Look at you simpletons and your not-real-books" then you deserve a slap. Let me re-iterate, no one is stopping you from reading whatever you want. But when you come out categorizing books as real and non-real based on a handful of old books you read, you are a douchebag. > they are universal and timeless I am neither universal nor timeless and I have a very limited amount of time which I have to invest accordingly. You carry on with your Hamlet, I will carry on with my "To Kill a mockingbird". > and contain deep truths about the human condition that resonate forever And are you assuming these so-called "deep truths" of yours are exclusively found in your 1000 year old obscure books? Care to list me a few of these deep truths? > If Gates had read them early in life, maybe he would not have developed the predatory personality that characterized his business career and Microsoft in general? Armchair theorizing much?