3 ms·
When a member of a group says that a term used to refer to them is pejorative, is it now an acceptable response to simply say ‘no it isn’t’? That hasn’t been t
by YurgenJurgensen 1y ago
When a member of a group says that a term used to refer to them is pejorative, is it now an acceptable response to simply say ‘no it isn’t’? That hasn’t been the case for decades.
- maxbond 1y agoKeep in mind that I am also WEIRD. Please help me to understand by referring to the specific part of the article where WEIRD was used in the pejorative.
- YurgenJurgensen 1y agoAre you saying that self-hating westerners aren’t real? It’s an entire industry at this point.
- maxbond 1y agoNo, I never said that. To be perfectly clear: if you want to argue that a text says X, you need to provide evidence from the text. Everything I see you commenting in this thread appears to be based your preconceptions around this acronym, nothing you've said even indicates you've read the article. Read it or don't, it's your business, but if I ask you for evidence from the article and your response is to try to put words on my mouth (on an irrelevant tangent, at that), I'm going to write off your argument entirely.
- watwut 1y agoYou know, are you seeing it as pejorative or just want to silence the whole idea? Because people who came up with WEIRD acronym were ... WEIRD. They were literally talking about themselves and about weakness of studies that were made.
- janalsncm 1y agoWEIRD isn’t insulting to be because it’s simply descriptive of you take the terms themselves. However. No one gave them the right to speak for everyone, and in regular parlance “weird” isn’t a super nice thing to say about someone. They could’ve chosen something else like WESTED “Western, Educated, Stable, Technologically-advanced, Economically Developed” but didn’t. And they don’t get to choose how people will react when they’re called weird.
- maxbond 1y agoThe claim at issue isn't, "I find the term WEIRD insulting." As you say, everyone is entitled to feel that way. It's "the term WEIRD is intended by the authors of TFA as an insult and reveals their agenda as being 'anti-west' [1]". I can understand how someone would find it insulting, but in the article we are discussing, it is descriptive and not pejorative. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45298741 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45298741
- johnisgood 1y agoAnother acceptable response is "take a break, go touch grass". There is too much victim mentality going on nowadays, and we continue rewarding that behavior so I am not surprised.