5 ms·
California electric vehicle drivers will lose carpool lane privileges
- nahtnam 1y agoFun while it lasted. I foresee a lot of cops pulling over Teslas in the carpool lane because they didn't realize the program is over
- avidiax 1y agoSince Newsom doesn't like the program ending, I have a suspicion that the enforcement will be lax.
- burnt-resistor 1y agoThere will be some sort of alternative pay to play privilege fast lane for rich people.
- aplummer 1y agoThat’s how it works now, for 5 bucks you just zoom down fastrak. Always blows my mind seeing 911s sitting in traffic instead of using it
- nostrademons 1y ago$5? Rush hour on 101 is $20 to drive the ~10 miles between Brittan and Embarcadero.
- red369 1y agoOff topic, but prompted by your 911 comment. I had a couple of friends buy cars at the same time - one bought a new Subaru, and the other a used 997 Porsche 911. The 911 cost more, but not a large difference in price. In that part of the world, the Subaru (and almost all new cars) loses 40% in the first year in depreciation, and continues to drop off at 10% - 15% per year. The 911 has more expensive maintenance and insurance, but has so far, and could easily continue to be depreciation-proof. The difference in fuel is less than you might think too given how much lighter (and risky in crashes) older smaller cars are. So far the 911 has turned out to be by far the more sensible financial decision. Obviously there are much more financially-prudent alternatives to both, but I find it interesting how older interesting cars are looked at as frivolous purchases, but new utilitarian cars aren't. Your comment was presumably talking about new or expensive 911s, and I don't want to criticise what you said at all. I just wanted to say something to hopefully encourage some people to consider sillier, more-fun cars as perhaps not a crazy option. There are a million practicality reasons why this wont work out for most people, but a lot of families have two cars. I really like seeing the 2nd car being something in that realm of interesting but nearly as reliable, costs more in maintenance but less in depreciation, less practical but more enjoyable. It feels to me like that has gotten less common, and a lot of people think every vehicle needs to be as practical as possible.
- aplummer 1y agoOh yeah I’m a big fan of 911s (and fun cars in general) that’s why I’m always looking! But I’m also a new Maserati owner and your Subaru friend is doing rookie depreciation numbers above…
- slaw 1y ago40% depreciation in the first year is a myth. Show me one year old vehicle you can buy for 40% off.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- nothercastle 1y agoSometimes you would be lucky to see the supposed 10% first year depreciation Numbers
- red369 1y agoIt seems that I was talking about a place with one of the highest depreciation rates (1) in the world, so what I said may not be widely applicable at all. I didn't realise it varied so much by country. I should have remembered that New Zealand has unusual prices because it gets a lot of used car imports from places like Japan and Singapore who get rid of their cars quickly. 1) https://www.stuff.co.nz/motoring/news/89145417/new-zealand-has-highest-car-depreciation-rate-in-the-world-says-study https://www.stuff.co.nz/motoring/news/89145417/new-zealand-h... This is an old study which points to New Zealand having quick depreciation in the first year. Looking around briefly, I think depreciation reduced substantially since COVID, and I think those numbers in that study may have been too high anyway (the study found over 50% in the first year). I'm interested in what happened, so I'll try and find what the reality is when I get a chance.
- mleo 1y agoAlready exists in some parts of southern california as toll lanes for single drivers.
- jdlshore 1y agoPlease don’t post cynical fantasies here.
- Rebelgecko 1y agoThey already announced a 2 month "grace period" where it won't be enforced
- D-Coder 1y ago"Beginning Oct. 1, motorists with a Clean Air Vehicle decal will no longer be able to drive solo in carpool lanes because the program was not extended by the federal government..." So it's a special EV privilege that is going away (because of the Feds). Now they'll be treated like other vehicles. Not as bad as the headline could be interpreted.
- altairprime 1y agoWell, no, they still won’t be taxed for miles driven per year like gas vehicles are. Not yet, anyways! Probably two or three years left on that watt-o-mobile owner loophole (that Priuses have been exploiting for years, but with far less road damage per mile traveled due to being hybrids). Or maybe less if the feds starve California of transportation funding in petulance at whatever.
- triceratops 1y ago> they still won’t be taxed for miles driven per year like gas vehicles are If you're referring to gasoline taxes, California taxes electricity too. > with far less road damage per mile I agree, let's tax all vehicles by weight. I'd love to see all those pickup trucks and full-size SUVs pay.
- jaredhallen 1y agoPickups are taxed by weight.
- Braxton1980 1y agoI believe they mean the gasoline tax not the registration cost which isn't a huge increase between size
- altairprime 1y agoSolar charged vehicles, such as with a Tesla powerwall, would pay zero dollars of tax per mile driven if you depended on an electricity tax. Doesn’t really work out in road repair costs to leave a massive tax loophole open. By weight and by tire count! Have to made sure to deal with four-tire axles and such, not to mention electric semi trucks. I believe the California pilot determined that odometer reporting and occasional DMV drive-thru checks will be the solution. I’d post the newsletter to HN the next time it comes out but this isn’t really the sort of group that appreciates taxation.
- paxys 1y agoI don't understand what the federal clean air program has to do with anything? California can make whatever rules about their carpool lanes they want.
- itake 1y agoJust a guess, but the federal government probably paid for the roads, not the state. With that funding, are strings
- andsoitis 1y agoThe Clean Air Vehicle (CAV) program requires federal approval under Section 166 of Title 23 of the U.S. Code. The federal government is notnot be extending the program, which means the underlying authority for the program expires. California passed legislation to extend the program, but this extension is contingent on federal approval, which was not granted.
- chrismeller 1y agoI was wondering the same thing, so thanks for the explanation. Disappointing that the article didn’t bother to explain it. From Section 166 it looks like the state can also convert an HOV lane to an HOT lane and set the toll amount. The contrarian in me wants to believe there’s some ridiculous loophole in there…
- kelnos 1y agoGood. I always found that weird. To me, the carpool lane is there to encourage drivers to put more people in their cars in order to reduce traffic. Allowing a single-rider EV to use the carpool lane doesn't do that. It just felt like a ham-fisted way to incentivize EV purchases, when there are better ways to do that.
- tanaros 1y agoIt makes sense if you view the HOV lane primarily as a way to reduce emissions, not traffic. This is also why e.g. single-rider motorcycles are often allowed to use HOV lanes as well.
- lurking_swe 1y agobuying an EV does not actually reduce emissions like magic, unless the owner drives that car for a looooong time. Like 10-15+ years. Manufacturing an EV car uses a lot more emissions than an ICE car initially, due to the huge battery. If the goal is to reduce emissions overall, then target incentives appropriately: - tax deduction at purchase - tax deduction for drivers of old (10 yr+) EV vehicles. This incentivizes EV purchase AND driving that vehicle for a long time. In contrast, allowing EV drivers to use a carpool lane does no such thing IMO.
- tanaros 1y ago> buying an EV does not actually reduce emissions like magic, unless the owner drives that car for a looooong time. Like 10-15+ years. I find this timeframe surprising. I did some quick searches and there are models like GREET that suggest the break-even point is much sooner than that in the US. It is difficult to know for certain, of course, as there are many variables. Regardless, it is of course better to incentivize long-term ownership as well. I think of HOV access as similar to a tax deduction on purchase. It’s a cheap way to provide a carrot for initial EV adoption.