5 ms·
The article says, "While the United States has a dismal track-record of inequality, we treat our brightest minds quite well." And the second part of that state
by tokenadult 14y ago
The article says, "While the United States has a dismal track-record of inequality, we treat our brightest minds quite well."
And the second part of that statement is baloney. While everyone knows that the United States does badly in educational equality, the idea that we do well by able students is directly disagreed with by scholars who have spent years studying the issue.
http://educationnext.org/teaching-math-to-the-talented/ http://educationnext.org/teaching-math-to-the-talented/
"Unfortunately, we found that the percentage of students in the U.S. Class of 2009 who were highly accomplished in math is well below that of most countries with which the United States generally compares itself. No fewer than 30 of the 56 other countries that participated in the Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) math test, including most of the world’s industrialized nations, had a larger percentage of students who scored at the international equivalent of the advanced level on our own National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) tests. Moreover, while the percentage of students scoring at the advanced level on NAEP varies considerably among the 50 states, not even the best state does well in international comparison. A 2005 report from the National Academy of Sciences, Rising Above the Gathering Storm, succinctly put the issue into perspective: 'Although many people assume that the United States will always be a world leader in science and technology, this may not continue to be the case inasmuch as great minds and ideas exist throughout the world.'"
The full report underlying this online article can be found here:
http://www.hks.harvard.edu/pepg/PDF/Papers/PEPG10-19_HanushekPetersonWoessmann.pdf http://www.hks.harvard.edu/pepg/PDF/Papers/PEPG10-19_Hanushe...
Anyway, this is implausible based on recent reports that millions of United States students find school boringly easy,
http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/story/2012-07-09/school-too-easy/56120106/1 http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/story/2012-07-09/scho...
"The findings, out today from the Center for American Progress, a Washington think tank that champions "progressive ideas,' analyze three years of questionnaires from the Department of Education's National Assessment of Educational Progress, a national test given each year.
Among the findings:
•37% of fourth-graders say their math work is "often" or 'always' too easy;
•57% of eighth-graders say their history work is 'often' or 'always' too easy;
•39% of 12th-graders say they rarely write about what they read in class."
The claim is also implausible on the basis of comparisons of the national score distribution in a variety of countries on the TIMSS and PIRLS data on achievement in mathematics, science, and reading.
http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/TIMSS2007/PDF/T07_M_IR_Chapter1.pdf http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/TIMSS2007/PDF/T07_M_IR_Chapter1....
(See Exhibit 1.1 for country distributions of scores in mathematics.)
http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/TIMSS2007/PDF/T07_S_IR_Chapter1.pdf http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/TIMSS2007/PDF/T07_S_IR_Chapter1....
(See Exhibit 1.1 for country distributions of scores in science, where the United States fares somewhat better, comparatively, than in mathematics.)
http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/PDF/P06_IR_Ch1.pdf http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/PDF/P06_IR_Ch1.pdf
(Exhibit 1.1 in this PIRLS document shows reading achievement distributions for fourth grade, not including eighth grade data as in the two charts linked above.)
The United States certainly has societal advantages that result in better economic performance than could be expected from the results of its school system. The United States is internally peaceful, stable, free
http://www.freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-2012 http://www.freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-wor...
and noncorrupt
http://cpi.transparency.org/cpi2011/ http://cpi.transparency.org/cpi2011/
enough to attract immigration from all over the world, and several United States immigration categories strongly favor persons who received strong primary and secondary educations in their native countries. The "brain drain" is a phenomenon of long standing, and helps the United States make up for what it doesn't do for its own native-born students.
AFTER EDIT: The Hacker News management writes in the Hacker News welcome letter about how to write a good comment:
"The test for substance is a lot like it is for links. Does your comment teach us anything? There are two ways to do that: by pointing out some consideration that hadn't previously been mentioned, and by giving more information about the topic, perhaps from personal experience."
And I just remembered, as I am about to do an activity with my son, that my personal experience includes running an ongoing course in advanced mathematics (prealgebra mathematics for elementary age pupils) that draws client from throughout the native-born and immigrant community in Minnesota, a state with strong public schools. My course location is in one of the very best school districts in Minnesota. But parents who are American-born and graduates of MIT, and first-generation immigrant parents from China, from India, from Poland, from Romania, from Ghana, from Korea, from Pakistan, and from other countries I may have forgotten sign up their children for my courses, even though they already live in school districts that are considered good school districts, because they know very well that American schools don't do as good a job teaching foundational mathematics as schools in many other countries.
http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf
http://www.ams.org/notices/199908/rev-howe.pdf http://www.ams.org/notices/199908/rev-howe.pdf
I learned this in Taiwan, where the school system in general does better at lest cost than in the United States. It is the basis of my current occupation that people living in the United States who are actually aware of the situation in other countries seek mathematics education besides that which is poorly provided by United States public schools.
- ferenstein 14y agoThank you for a very thoughtful critique. The nature piece talks about number of students, not percent. The US has 300 people people, so we have a lot more high performing students, as a result.
- DavidAdams 14y agoI'll chime in here to say that indeed we don't treat our brightest minds quite well. For one, by trying to let no child be left behind, and raise average test scores, our schools are spending most of their time trying to raise the bottom half to the standard. Kids who can easily pass the tests are left to languish. And I mean this literally. My son has been relegated to the corner of the classroom to spend hours poking around in the meager classroom library while the teacher worked intensively with the laggards. Programs for "gifted" kids are unpopular with parents because they seem "elitist" so schools have to go to crazy lengths to obfuscate them and make them as low-profile as possible. You're unlikely to even hear the term "gifted" in a school nowadays. They have to use euphemisms like Early Learning Program. Even in high schools where it finally becomes politically workable to sort the smarter kids into AP classes, the "best" schools use those classes and the bright students as a factory farm of AP credits earned, which raise the rankings of their school system, and make it easier to justify continued budget increases. So rather than encouraging critical thinking, writing, and creativity, they're teaching to the test. I actually agree with many of the facts that the article lays out. I actually don't think that there's much point in getting heartburn about the US's standing in the ratings, because a lot of the ratings are probably useless or easily-gamed metrics. And it's critically important for US interests that we make it easy for the world's best and brightest to continue to immigrate. The big problem with the article is that, as other readers point out, it's a self-defeating argument. The reason that our poor education outcomes don't matter is that we import the top performers from other countries? Well, it's a good thing that we import the top performers (in a selfish way of seeing things). But that's beside the point. I think that one of the factors contributing to our education challenges is that we have a large and diverse population, but we also have naive notions of what equality means, and we too often think that correlation equals causation. Going to college correlates with success later in life. That's because smarter, harder-working kids tend to go to college. It does not mean that sending dumb lazy kids to college you'll make them successful. If you send dumb kids to college, you end up with dumb kids with no college degree and $40,000 in student loan debt the incurred before they dropped out. I'm using the term "dumb" to make a point, but the truth is that there's nothing wrong with not being cut out for the academic life. In fact, if you are prepared in childhood to be determined, hard-working, and creative, you can become a very successful person without having ever been an academic type. I spent three years doing carpentry, and I got to know a lot of tradespeople who did important things, enjoyed their work, and lived comfortable middle class lives, and sent their kids to college. But we're allergic to the idea that people are cut out for different kinds of life purpose because some people are more academically oriented than others.