6 ms·
Why It’s Never Mattered That America’s Schools ‘Lag’ Behind Other Countries
- rickmb 14y agoThis whole flag-waving typical Techcrunch rant is based on the assumption that education only serves to feed the economy. Profit is all that matters. So many of America's social problems can be traced back to a lack of a decent educational system, and if anything, this article inadvertently explains why. If someone really thinks economic dominance is enough to keep an empire from crumbling, I suggest some history lessons.
- moistgorilla 14y agoWell put. They don't realize that a well educated population is a more rational one. It's also one of the reasons why I am against this whole shift in only learning things that are "immediately practical" such as math and science (don't get me wrong, I think math and science are important but other subjects are just as important). It's one of the reasons why I wish philosophy and debate were mandatory courses in most schools. I don't believe making kids memorize multiplication tables when they are in kindergarten is going to help them, especially when they are barely able to comprehend them since they are so cognitively underdeveloped. In addition: From what I am noticing, the kids that go to college to study degrees that involve dealing with unsolvable or unsolved problems are the kids that understand and not just memorize what they are taught. The education system downplays understanding and focuses on memorization. This obviously comes from America's result based culture. This leads to a population of people that can't think for themselves and only do what they are told. Something that goes against the whole idea of democracy. TL;DR I believe that at younger ages children should be taught how to think rather than what to memorize.
- genwin 14y agoThe country's taking the opposite path. Kids start their school day with the Pledge of Allegiance to the Wealthy. Ignorance is strength.
- milesokeefe 14y agoWhat does the pledge of allegiance have to do with wealthy people?
- genwin 14y agoPledging allegiance to the flag/country encourage kids to support or fight in for-profit wars and other nefarious gov't activities that mainly benefit the rich. The "under God" part is advertising for religions, again profiting the wealthy few.
- ScottBurson 14y agoSalon had an interesting piece on this just the other day: http://www.salon.com/2012/09/14/conservatives_killed_the_liberal_arts/?source=newsletter http://www.salon.com/2012/09/14/conservatives_killed_the_lib...
- yummyfajitas 14y agoSo many of America's social problems can be traced back to a lack of a decent educational system... Can you explain this claim? I.e., both define what you mean by "social problems", and how a "decent" educational system would help.
- moistgorilla 14y agoNot the person that you are responding to but I made this point in my response to him. America's education system only cares about the results. I.E. how well can he do on a standardized test, how good are his grades, etc. This leads to people taking the easy way out and just memorizing everything without understanding or thinking critically about what they are doing. These people aren't thinking for themselves and instead are just taking everything told to them as fact and regurgitating it when they are asked. This obviously leads to a problem when they become adults and need to make decisions on who is to lead them. Instead of coming to their own conclusion they will listen to their parents, preacher, neighbor, etc. All of whom might have come to their conclusion of who is the best leader faultily. In Addition: Just to give you guys an example of where this is being most blatantly done, literature classes. I remember in my lit classes that almost 90% of the class did not read the book. Instead they just took the spark notes and memorized key points taking nothing out of the text. As soon as the exam was over they forgot everything.
- busyant 14y agoCan you give me an example of a country that does it "right"? I'm genuinely curious, but I also suspect that twenty different people here would give twenty different answers to this question.
- hack_edu 14y agoThe most common critique of the US system is the lack of focus on testing and measurable results. Bureaucrats and teachers unions have fought this push for decades and only now has it taken hold. Even if you are right that the American educational system now focuses too much on standardized tests, this focus pales in comparison to almost any other industrialized nation. And even then, this focus on testing is hardly even a decade old. Speak to a student from China, Japan, the UK, or Ireland and get back to me about focuses on standardized testing.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoFree education is out there for anyone who wants it and has the motivation to get it. Hint: you're soaking in it. The Internet gives us access to a significant portion of the accumulated knowledge of the human race, and access to knowledgeable mentors and colleagues around the world. You can get it free at your local library. True, those educational resources are largely avalable thanks to those evil profit-oriented tech companies, but one can't have everything.
- kmfrk 14y agoThat's all well and good, but some of us don't have an inbox full of job offers, free education or not.
- Silhouette 14y agoFree education is out there for anyone who wants it and has the motivation to get it. I think you're oversimplifying. Thanks to the Internet, today we have the best virtual reference library available in the history of humanity. That solves one problem, but it introduces another: information overload. Quality of teaching has always been a big influence on the quality of learning, but the emphasis is changing. Teaching has always been valuable because those with more knowledge/experience and the ability to convey that knowledge/experience effectively to someone else can help that other person to learn. Today, with better access to raw information, there is less need for teachers to play that role, but it is more valuable than ever to have a knowledgeable guide who can help the student to navigate the mass of information available and to choose which aspects to prioritise for best results at that stage in their personal development.
- Jach 14y agoInformation overload exists, but I don't think it's the problem here. There are plenty of garden paths on the internet, Khan Academy being just one, where a path is set for a student to follow and learn something with their hand being held by a competent teacher. You can also find willing and competent tutors (usually free!) by googling for a forum on the subject of interest. I think the problem is closer related with bad genetics and laziness, and these aren't necessarily mutually exclusive. This isn't the whole picture but it captures a lot more than "information overload".
- batista 14y agoHmm, sounds more like la-la-hands-in-the-ears denial. It's not just schools. The tide's have turned in general. Before the 17th century Britain wasn't much. Afterwards, it was the world's superpower (with France by the side). Before the 20th century, the US wasn't much. After WWI, WWII especially, the exchanged the role of superpower with Britain. Now they're falling by the wayside too. It's not something that happens overnight, might take several decades, but it's not like the world looks to the US as it once did anymore (or will again: those things are not normally reversible).
- michaelochurch 14y agoThere isn't a national superpower anymore, and that may be a good thing. No one can predict the future, but I can't see any nation ever being as globally relevant as the U.S. was in 1945-95. That wasn't just the peak of U.S. power but also the peak of nation-state power. If I'm right, no national government will ever attain it again. Not the European Union (technically a multinational government), not China, and definitely not India. I think China will be doing very well economically in 2100 (and people will be surprised to learn about the extremely widespread 20th- and early-21st-century Chinese poverty) but I think the influence of national governments will have waned by then. I'm actually pretty bullish about the long-term American future, because I think the global trend is not only positive but going to accelerate in the next 20 years. I think the Bush years were a nadir, and I think we're in a long U-shaped valley, but I think the 2020s will be slightly better than the 2010s, which will shape up to be better than the 2000s were. "Decline" for us is going to look like it did for the British: the average Briton is still a hell of a lot better off (happier, wealthier, and healthier) in 2012 than in 1900. People don't actually think about national dominance much when they don't have it, and by 2050, I think that concept itself will be pretty well outmoded. To put it frankly, I don't care if the U.S. is geopolitically #1 or #14 in 2050, but I hope they've done something about cancer.
- justincormack 14y agoBritain started worrying about its educational decline in the 1890s recession...
- 14y ago
- m_ke 14y agoBasically screw 90% of the population. Let private schools educate the rich and if they can't hold up the weight give out student visas to people who actually got legit primary education. I moved to the states when I was 13 and wasted 5 years in subpar new york city schools. If not for the decent education that I received prior to moving here, I would probably be in a similar position as a good portion of my high school classmates. I'd be finishing up a worthless CC degree and have little hope of getting a job that pays much above the minimum wage.
- tete 14y agoI am legitimately curious. What did you do instead?
- Wilya 14y agoI find the conclusion dubious. The US compensates its bad education system by attracting external talent through other factors ? Yeah, I agree with that. But saying "we need not to be scared into trying to be like other countries" is a recipe for disaster on the long term. Because it works until some other country becomes more attractive than the US (not likely right now, but it's imaginable). And, if anything, having a good education system will give you more talent. There's no way it will give you less, since people aren't coming for the education anyway.
- tsycho 14y agoThe immigrants aren't coming for the middle and high school education, they are coming for college/graduate level education, which is top-notch in the US, atleast in the best schools. Combine with that the multiplier effect of significantly better economic opportunities post-college, and its clear why immigrants are willing to jump through hoops (one of the worst immigration systems) to come to the US.
- michaelochurch 14y agoTL;DR summary: we're not good at educating people, but that doesn't matter because (a) only the top few percent matter, and (b) we can import talent to make up for domestic shortfall. I don't agree with either of these. Only the top quartile matter, and therefore the bottom three-fourths can wallow in ignorance and stupidity? We don't have universal healthcare because of this fucking attitude. If you have ignorant people, you end up with an ignorant, fucked-up culture. We pay for the ignorance of average Americans in so many ways that it infuriates me even to get into this discussion. Secondly, I don't think we can count on being a destination country forever. Our immigration policies are getting worse over time, while European countries and Canada are becoming increasingly attractive. The gap is narrowing. There was a time when the smartest in the world wanted to come to the United States-- not necessarily New York or Silicon Valley, but even central Ohio. Now, they're equally attracted to Canada, Australia, Scandinavia, and even Japan (which is less xenophobic than its reputation would indicate). I don't think the smartest and hardest-working people come to "America" anymore. They go to star cities, industries, and companies: Wall Street, Silicon Valley, and U.S. research academia are top-notch, and happen to be in the U.S. People come to the U.S. because a few currently-leading locations are here, but what does this do for the rest of the country? Also, New York is arguably the world's best city and Silicon Valley is the world's best suburb, but these places are also ignominously expensive. Living in the star cities, we can easily delude ourselves into believing that we're insulated from the decline in "flyover country", but the bare fact is that we suffer every day (when we pay rent or make mortgage payments, the prices being so high because it's so hard to get a high-paying job outside of a few locations) for what has happened to the rest of the country. American decline is real, and it's shitty, and it has everything to do with a lack of education and culture. Hours of schooling are just a proxy measure and not a very good one, but the lack of attention paid to education in this country is a big fucking deal.
- dantheman 14y agoWe don't have universal healthcare for a variety of reasons, most of which highly educated agree with. Many people don't seem to understand that federalism is slower and the idea is to see what works. The problem is that healthcare reform is not being appropriately worked on at the state level - primarily due to huge interventions at the federal level that prevent experimentation. Anyway, there are tons of high paying jobs outside of NY and SF - people choose to live there because the like the culture and the cities -- that's why the rent is high.
- jasonjei 14y agoI think it is the fact that we have such a ``weak" education system that America is capable of institutions such as Google, Apple, and the whole startup culture. Lately, this has been less and less relevant due to the Internet (as long as you have uncensored Internet, it probably doesn't matter which locality you're in). Nonetheless, I don't think there is anything inherently so wrong about the US college/university system. People outside of the US wouldn't be spending buckets' loads of money to send their kids here. And lately, Canada seems to be absorbing a lot of influence as a tech powerhouse. I think it is the lack of structure and social order that allows anyone to question any values. As long as America keeps the best and brightest from all over the world in the country, America will stay on top. However, the Internet has been the great equalizer. It is probable and possible to build great companies anywhere, especially if your products are digital.
- michaelochurch 14y agoRich people from all over the world send their kids to school here because rich people from all over the world send their kids to school here. At one time, it was "studying at Oxford". Now it's studying in America. If you have a top-50 U.S. university degree, when you go back you will be one or two levels below the CEO in your first job. That has value to the U.S. and it obviously pumps a lot of money into American universities, but it has more to do with social signaling than quality of education. That's not to say that the top American universities aren't very good (they are) but that's not what it's really about.
- bugsbunnyak 14y agoNonetheless, I don't think there is anything inherently so wrong about the US college/university system. People outside of the US wouldn't be spending buckets' loads of money to send their kids here. And lately, Canada seems to be absorbing a lot of influence as a tech powerhouse. Specific education systems in the US are on-par with the best in the world. People outside the US are not sending their kids to inner-city New Orleans, Detroit, etc. - they are sending kids to Boston suburbs and private schools. The problem is not "all our schools are terrible", the problem is the massive variance in outcomes.
- tete 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kalleboo 14y ago> The U.S. holds roughly 17% of the world’s International students, compared to 2nd-place Britain (~12%) and far more than education powerhouses, Korea, Switzerland, and Sweden (all below 5%). Considering the U.S. has a population of 300 million vs. the UK's 63 million (and Sweden's 9 million), aren't these numbers actually damning? Or are they just saying "size matters"?
- learc83 14y agoWell since the UK is so close and economically/politically connected with other large developed countries you would expect their rate of international students to be greater than the US all things being equal.
- justincormack 14y agoI think the majority of the uk's international students are from less developed countries. Historically they were from the countries in the Empire, although recently there are more from Europe as our universities are better than many other countries.
- ucee054 14y agoour universities are better Do we really compare better? Recommend any references?
- justincormack 14y agoNot better than all other countries in Europe, but a substantial number. Italy's awful University system is well documented eg http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/family-fiefdoms-blamed-for-tainting-italian-universities-2089120.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/family-fiefdo... Look at these rankings for example, the UK is right up at the top, followed by Switzerland, the Netherlands, Germany and France, but many other countries are right down the list. http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/world-university-rankings/2011-2012/europe.html http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/world-university-ranki...
- MrJagil 14y agoTotally off-topic: Shouldn't it be "countries'" with an apostrophe? To denote possession?
- Uchikoma 14y agoThere are some reasons for US economic power (e.g. WWII) but the main reason is companies got larger and more successful than elsewhere because until China it was the largest domestic market. Successful companies attract money, money attracts people.
- Jach 14y agoDon't forget the very important fact that in the US companies are allowed to get massive (modulo a few antitrust cases) and keep their profits, of which there is no artificial limit. Both the companies and the citizens are, to a large extent, left unmolested by the government. This is not the case everywhere. There are many other factors as well.
- Uchikoma 14y agoGranted by view is limited, but I'd assume companies are allowed to get massive in the UK, France, Germany, Italy, Japan and elsewhere too. What these countries lack is a large domestic market - with Japan the second largest, and Japan the second largest economy for most of the 20th century after WWII. The UK was large when it had the empire as a domestic market.
- tokenadult 14y agoThe article says, "While the United States has a dismal track-record of inequality, we treat our brightest minds quite well." And the second part of that statement is baloney. While everyone knows that the United States does badly in educational equality, the idea that we do well by able students is directly disagreed with by scholars who have spent years studying the issue. http://educationnext.org/teaching-math-to-the-talented/ http://educationnext.org/teaching-math-to-the-talented/ "Unfortunately, we found that the percentage of students in the U.S. Class of 2009 who were highly accomplished in math is well below that of most countries with which the United States generally compares itself. No fewer than 30 of the 56 other countries that participated in the Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) math test, including most of the world’s industrialized nations, had a larger percentage of students who scored at the international equivalent of the advanced level on our own National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) tests. Moreover, while the percentage of students scoring at the advanced level on NAEP varies considerably among the 50 states, not even the best state does well in international comparison. A 2005 report from the National Academy of Sciences, Rising Above the Gathering Storm, succinctly put the issue into perspective: 'Although many people assume that the United States will always be a world leader in science and technology, this may not continue to be the case inasmuch as great minds and ideas exist throughout the world.'" The full report underlying this online article can be found here: http://www.hks.harvard.edu/pepg/PDF/Papers/PEPG10-19_HanushekPetersonWoessmann.pdf http://www.hks.harvard.edu/pepg/PDF/Papers/PEPG10-19_Hanushe... Anyway, this is implausible based on recent reports that millions of United States students find school boringly easy, http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/story/2012-07-09/school-too-easy/56120106/1 http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/story/2012-07-09/scho... "The findings, out today from the Center for American Progress, a Washington think tank that champions "progressive ideas,' analyze three years of questionnaires from the Department of Education's National Assessment of Educational Progress, a national test given each year. Among the findings: •37% of fourth-graders say their math work is "often" or 'always' too easy; •57% of eighth-graders say their history work is 'often' or 'always' too easy; •39% of 12th-graders say they rarely write about what they read in class." The claim is also implausible on the basis of comparisons of the national score distribution in a variety of countries on the TIMSS and PIRLS data on achievement in mathematics, science, and reading. http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/TIMSS2007/PDF/T07_M_IR_Chapter1.pdf http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/TIMSS2007/PDF/T07_M_IR_Chapter1.... (See Exhibit 1.1 for country distributions of scores in mathematics.) http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/TIMSS2007/PDF/T07_S_IR_Chapter1.pdf http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/TIMSS2007/PDF/T07_S_IR_Chapter1.... (See Exhibit 1.1 for country distributions of scores in science, where the United States fares somewhat better, comparatively, than in mathematics.) http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/PDF/P06_IR_Ch1.pdf http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/PDF/P06_IR_Ch1.pdf (Exhibit 1.1 in this PIRLS document shows reading achievement distributions for fourth grade, not including eighth grade data as in the two charts linked above.) The United States certainly has societal advantages that result in better economic performance than could be expected from the results of its school system. The United States is internally peaceful, stable, free http://www.freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-2012 http://www.freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-wor... and noncorrupt http://cpi.transparency.org/cpi2011/ http://cpi.transparency.org/cpi2011/ enough to attract immigration from all over the world, and several United States immigration categories strongly favor persons who received strong primary and secondary educations in their native countries. The "brain drain" is a phenomenon of long standing, and helps the United States make up for what it doesn't do for its own native-born students. AFTER EDIT: The Hacker News management writes in the Hacker News welcome letter about how to write a good comment: "The test for substance is a lot like it is for links. Does your comment teach us anything? There are two ways to do that: by pointing out some consideration that hadn't previously been mentioned, and by giving more information about the topic, perhaps from personal experience." And I just remembered, as I am about to do an activity with my son, that my personal experience includes running an ongoing course in advanced mathematics (prealgebra mathematics for elementary age pupils) that draws client from throughout the native-born and immigrant community in Minnesota, a state with strong public schools. My course location is in one of the very best school districts in Minnesota. But parents who are American-born and graduates of MIT, and first-generation immigrant parents from China, from India, from Poland, from Romania, from Ghana, from Korea, from Pakistan, and from other countries I may have forgotten sign up their children for my courses, even though they already live in school districts that are considered good school districts, because they know very well that American schools don't do as good a job teaching foundational mathematics as schools in many other countries. http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf http://www.ams.org/notices/199908/rev-howe.pdf http://www.ams.org/notices/199908/rev-howe.pdf I learned this in Taiwan, where the school system in general does better at lest cost than in the United States. It is the basis of my current occupation that people living in the United States who are actually aware of the situation in other countries seek mathematics education besides that which is poorly provided by United States public schools.
- hugh4life 14y agoAmerican schools don't lag behind other countries... American demographics lag behind other countries. If you break down the PISA scores by american demographic groups then you'll see that whites do better than whites in almost every European country... Asians better than practically every Asian country... and the same goes for Blacks and Latinos.
- TheEzEzz 14y agoReference?
- Derbasti 14y agoOnly caring about the top quartile (aka ignoring the majority) is dangerous, because it has been proven that humans are not very good at judging the relative intelligence of people more intelligent than they are. Thus, a dumb population will elect dumb leaders who make dumb decisions. One has to wonder if we currently see something related to that.
- MrFoof 14y ago>The U.S. is the 6th worst in terms of high school graduation, with 23% failing to attain a diploma I'm surprised that the graduation rate was that high, as I was expecting the "did not graduate rate" to be closer to 30%, not closer to 20%. Personally, my high school only graduated 59.1% of its incoming freshman for the class of 2000.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Tycho 14y agoI think everyone would agree that it's pointless to send children into a public education system and then act like it doesn't matter what the outcome is for the majority of them. Unless you are totally indifferent to the wastage of tax revenue.
- rotskoff 14y agoThis article fails to specify exactly to what end "it has never mattered." Assuming that the reasoning of the article is correct (the other comments have sufficiently questioned this issue), it still "matters" that the U.S. public education is subject glaring inequalities, that low-income schools often fail to graduate the majority of their students, that income level is so positively correlated to academic achievement, that students can be trapped in classrooms with 40+ students with no hope of individual attention. Addressing and reforming these problems is independent of the privilege and success of elite students.
- polyfractal 14y agoI know Techcrunch posted this...but why is it on HN? This has nothing to do with technology, hacking, or really anything that is remotely interesting. This thread is just going to turn a giant shitfest about government vs free market, why collegiate education is the root of all evil, etc etc. Same tired old debates. Flagged.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThe article assumes that given that the U.S. thrived in the post-war environment with a K-12 system subpar on a given set of metrics, those metrics don't matter. It fails to acknowledge that today's environment of several emergent, competitive countries viably aspiring for at least global significance is very different from one where every viable competitor raced to outdo each other in the orgy of self-destruction that bombed much of the first world to the third. An educated population, as measured by PISA scores, "has powerful effects on individual earnings, on the distribution of income, and on economic growth," e.g. a "one country-level standard deviation equivalent to 47 test-score points in PISA 2000 mathematics higher test performance [yielded] around one percentage point higher annual [per capita GDP] growth rates", with broader evidence quoted in the same paper pointing to a 1.5 to 2 percentage point effective size. From a social perspective, test score inequality and earnings inequality across OECD countries have a simple correlation of 0.85 [1]. The link between schooling and test scores is not 100% causal, with the aforementioned study [1] conceding that "cognitive skills may be developed in formal schooling, but they may also come from the family, the peers, the culture, and so forth.". That said, the data suggests that "strong accountability systems that accurately measure student performance; local autonomy that allows schools to make appropriate educational choices; and choice and competition in schools so that parents can enter into determining the incentives that schools face" have been shown to have a significant positive effect on the economically relevant metrics of cognitive skill. It should be noted that there is little evidence of education expenditure per pupil and any relevant metrics being related. TechCrunch quotes a Nature article that asserts that the “average test scores are mostly irrelevant as a measure of economic potential". Unsurprisingly, the original article [2] is mis-represented. Far from arguing that we can sit on our laurels the commentary in Nature argues that given "90% of the variance in the scores is within countries rather than between countries" we need not drill our students for hours as they do in Singapore or India, but "should [instead look] at how our best schools educate top performers". The argument is thus on how we improve our education system rather than whether we need to. TL;DR Just because we got to market in a jalopy for the last half century doesn't mean a tune-up isn't in order. Even if we have a larger population that hedges against trashing up a good portion of our human capital so long as a lucky few succeed, an under-performing school system, hinted at by the U.S.'s PISA scores, leaves potential growth on the table. This is unfair and inefficient. [1] https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/7154/wps4122.pdf?sequence=1 https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/7... [2] http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v453/n7191/full/453028a.html#an1 http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v453/n7191/full/453028a...
- lucian303 14y agoInnovation is never the primary factor to obtain a good education for oneself. One only learns of innovation once one has a good education. The conclusions of this article are atrocious and frankly, appalling. When just about all of the problems in the US and US policy abroad come because of an uneducated populous how can one claim that this is not important? A lot of immigrants don't really want to come here anymore and many are leaving or planning to leave because of the conditions caused by the horrific education in the US. It's ironic that this is one of the problems that we have it in our power to fix, yet one of the things that keeps the status quo thus removed from politicians' agendas.
- nancyhua 14y agoHas anyone here had a positive educational experience? The article brings up the USA and china and although I had to supplement my usa education (we used the same textbook for 4 years in my elementary school) and saw that my cousins in china were learning calculus while my class was still on extremely basic algebra, I never envied them their Chinese education steeped in rote memorization. My impression is other countries might test better but they have their own problems. My cousins in China had the curiosity beaten out of them and had no time to really understand what they were studying or pursue what really interested them. The cutthroat testing environment really harmed them psychologically as well. I consider myself really lucky. The first rule of education should be "do no harm" and often that just means being more hands off. Many of my friends learn better on their own and at least the USA lets smart kids do that more than many other countries do. I have a bias in that I tend to think most problems can be solved by technology. Maybe this whole conversation is on a problem fast becoming obsolete due to the great equalizer: the Internet. That's my hope, anyway. (btw the best open courseware stuff comes out of USA universities.)