3 ms·
Uh, it's marked FOUO, not Top Secret, and it's going to be made public when it gets issued anyway, troll. ..... FOUO=for official use only, ie = confidential
by 001sky 14y ago
Uh, it's marked FOUO, not Top Secret, and it's going to be made public when it gets issued anyway, troll.
.....
FOUO=for official use only, ie = confidential
pg internal email = confidential [1]
almost all leaks = confidential
a PR before embargo = confidential
......
What does that even mean?
This is the world we live in...Leaks are a form of "black hat" PR [2]
......
Calling someone a [troll] for suggesting this may be a [trial baloon] seems un-intelligent at best.
Whether or not its good policy or bad or good pr strategy or bad is a fair topic of discussion.
.......
[1] This was a simplification of "internal", if it technically includes portfolio companies that are legally distinct entities from YC. But being pedandtic here is off point. This was being illustrative that "all kinds of data could be leaked", and in particular all manner of private, non-governmental information, that for whatever reason, people feel should not be sent to the press and have a reasonable expectation of privacy around.
[2] I.e. The leak can be by a friend or foe, for information or dis-information, etc.
- tptacek 14y agoIt's easy to keep an argument going if you just ignore what the other party says and repeat your talking points over and over again. But my last comment was pretty simple: Graham's "internal" mail, which went to hundreds of people on a mailing list, wasn't "confidential". For that matter, "FUOU" is explicitly not classified. If you can't make a reasonable analysis of something as simple as Paul Graham's mail to YC companies, what makes you think you're a credible critic of public policy, which is much more complicated?
- 001sky 14y agoGraham's "internal" mail...wasn't "confidential" And Pg and other VC's don't sign NDAs but confidentiality is understood in certain areas...almost all communication relating to corporate finace and investment, BOD internal deliberations, communications for example... For that matter, "FUOU" is explicitly not classified. Again, this is off-point...its not "official" use to send internal <government> documents to the press for "public" consumption. This is really "rookie" 101 type stuff, things that in a BigCo job are subject to all kinds of intenal compliance procedures...ect...not even debatable In addition, there are disclosure rules around market moving informations, and all kinds of stuff... Routinely dis-respected, but thats another story.[1] __________ [1] These rules typically apply to Public companies, and revolve around providing fair access to information for retail investors and the like. Reg FD is an example.
- tptacek 14y agoAlso easy to keep an argument going by saying "my point is understood to be correct" instead of backing it up. You seem to be having a hard time with the point that Graham sent his negotiating advice to a giant freaking mailing list with many tens of companies on it. If he wanted it confidential, he wouldn't have done that. Graham is many annoying things but an idiot is not one of them.
- 001sky 14y agoHow many companies of those is he an investor in? and/or advisor? It was advice on sensitive negotiations for "YC Backed" companies? or are we talking a different e-mail?
- tptacek 14y agoHundreds. Stop trying to argue that Paul Graham was trying to keep a secret on a mailing list that might hit 1000 people. The reason for all the drama about Graham's mail wasn't that it was a leaked secret. It's that dishonest tech publications cynically spun it as one. Just like they're doing on this story.
- 001sky 14y agoStop trying to argue that Paul Graham.... tptacek - you're acting desperate with that smear. ...... You seem to be having a hard time with the point that Graham sent his negotiating advice to a giant freaking mailing list with many tens of companies on it. No. I understand this. These are people with whom he has a investment interest, are portfolio companies, and YC alumn executives and the like. Ie, the types of people he would be giving advice to about raising money. So, I'm not implying anything about PG. I wrote "NOT MARKED TOP SECRET" as a modifier for his e-mail. As a point of fact, he's not a government agency. And the point is certainly not the issue that PG <sent> the email. The only relevance here was that it was "leaked" to the <press>, by a party [intentionally or otherwise] he implicitly trusted enough in the first place send it too. It clearly was not a <press release>. PG made many comments here on HN. It did not seem that he wanted or envisioned his note to be in the press. The point is that non-government, non-top-secret information can be "leaked." Which is true, and not really a debating point.