5 ms·
The White House's Draft Cybersecurity Executive Order
- tptacek 14y agoExtremely boring. The executive branch has to work within the framework of existing laws (like the ECPA) and cannot do things like shielding private entities from liability. So where CISPA and Lieberman Collins had certification programs and information sharing, this EO says only that an "information exchange network" will be established to share "indicators and warnings". The overwhelming majority of this document has to do with security inside the federal government, which is again the largest IT operation in the world.
- samstave 14y agoI wonder if this EO stating the requirement for the information exchange network is designed to serve as de facto budget approval for building it out - circumventing any potential congressional blocks.
- slurgfest 14y agoThis was leaked, ergo it must contain something illegitimate and embarrassing...
- tptacek 14y ago"Leaked"? It's been shown verbatim to reporters.
- 001sky 14y agofrom the vague-enough-for-ya? dept -- sub-heading.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm not sure what this means. Techdirt here claims the EO has been "leaked" (because that will drive pageviews). Reporters at real publications have already read the entire order. It wasn't "leaked". Techdirt is just making things up like they normally do. Techdirt is horrible and people should feel bad for posting their stories here.
- 001sky 14y agopeople should feel bad for posting their stories here Ad hominem or shoot the messenger? Take your pick...
- tptacek 14y agoI'm shooting at the messenger for sure.
- 001sky 14y agouser: tptacek created:1780 days ago karma: 106,895 avg: 8.09 Nice... But you're off base.
- 001sky 14y agoviz "Reporters at real publications have already read the entire order. It wasn't "leaked". -- This makes no sense. To those that are following along.[1] _________ [1] "Draft Cybersecurity Executive Order" was marked for official use only.
- tptacek 14y agoThe one thing every faction in government agrees on is that there needs to be public/private threat sharing. Also, that's just not how the "budget" works.
- HistoryInAction 14y agoYes, you're spot on here. It might still be ineffective, almost certainly so, but because of existing laws, it's almost all internal to the federal government rather than L-C or CISPA affecting our relationships with Facebook, Google, or any other private company with mass storage of our user data. It also won't mean startups need to collect user data in case the feds come calling. Very insightful comments throughout the discussion, thanks, Thomas.
- Zenst 14y agoThe fact that this draft bill about cyber-security was leaked does in itself highlight that they need to go back to the drawing board and rethink it. One day this incident will be listed as the definition of ironic.
- dguido 14y agoUh, it's marked FOUO, not Top Secret, and it's going to be made public when it gets issued anyway, troll.
- 001sky 14y agoUm, "leaked" like pg "not marked top secret" email? Lots of reasons to "leak" all kinds of data. Leaked simply means distributed prior to official release. This is likely a "trial baloon" or sum such. then, they change it after the criticism to avoid further embarrassmnet, nor not. either way.
- tptacek 14y agoWhat does that even mean? Graham sent an email blast to hundreds of people with negotiation advice in it. The problem isn't that the mail got out --- of course the mail got out. He sent it to a giant mailing list. The problem is that publications like Venturebeat and Techdirt went to town on the email spinning it into something it wasn't. And the problem is people who promote that cynically packaged excreta on sites like HN.
- 001sky 14y agoUh, it's marked FOUO, not Top Secret, and it's going to be made public when it gets issued anyway, troll. ..... FOUO=for official use only, ie = confidential pg internal email = confidential [1] almost all leaks = confidential a PR before embargo = confidential ...... What does that even mean? This is the world we live in...Leaks are a form of "black hat" PR [2] ...... Calling someone a [troll] for suggesting this may be a [trial baloon] seems un-intelligent at best. Whether or not its good policy or bad or good pr strategy or bad is a fair topic of discussion. ....... [1] This was a simplification of "internal", if it technically includes portfolio companies that are legally distinct entities from YC. But being pedandtic here is off point. This was being illustrative that "all kinds of data could be leaked", and in particular all manner of private, non-governmental information, that for whatever reason, people feel should not be sent to the press and have a reasonable expectation of privacy around. [2] I.e. The leak can be by a friend or foe, for information or dis-information, etc.
- HistoryInAction 14y agoReportedly, this might be of more relevance: "There is apparently a different executive order in the works, and it is described in this Washington Post story http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/white-house-drafting-standards-to-guard-us-against-cyberattack-officials-say/2012/09/07/0fbb173e-f8fe-11e1-a073-78d05495927c_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/white-... as a 4-page executive order that would create voluntary standards to guide companies in guarding themselves against cyberattacks, and would establish a special council made up of key government agencies to identify cyberthreats. The Cybersec Council would be led by DHS and would have representatives from Commerce, Defense, Treasury, Energy, Justice and the DNI. That seems more of a reaction to non-passage of the Lieberman-Collins bill, Title 1 of which would have done all of these things, than does the 19-page order that Bloomberg described."
- danbmil99 14y agoI read this as "The White House's Daft Cybersecurity Executive Order" which maybe would have been more entertaining