I don't think we're at odds on Islam. I'm not blaming Islam was just pointing out the fallacy I saw there. "it is culture" Few points: (1) Culture is a sort

I don't think we're at odds on Islam. I'm not blaming Islam was just pointing out the fallacy I saw there. "it is culture" Few points: (1) Culture is a sort of catchall term for anything that's not genetics. Whatever 'this' is that we are talking about, it's going to be pretty easy to file it under culture. (2) What exactly is 'this' we're talking about? The latest violence in Libya/Egypt and elsewhere correct? How is this fundamentally different from riots/mob violence/brutish behavior in other cultures? When we raise the flag of culture the quick litmus test should be whether other cultures (controlling for other dimensions as much as possible) also show the same symptoms.