And like you said it was rhetorical. And the implication was clearly that asking for review of X implies they "should" ask for review of all things that weakly

And like you said it was rhetorical. And the implication was clearly that asking for review of X implies they "should" ask for review of all things that weakly resemble X. Which your point was to make the initial request seem dumb but I'm pointing out is logically incoherent.