5 ms·
Rebutting 33 False Claims About Solar, Wind, and Electric Vehicles
- wiredpancake 1y ago[dead]
- jamezzzboy 1y agoRead the beginning of false claim #28. This paper is such a joke lol. The authors agree with the "false statement" and then propose their own solution. I can't believe this is on an "edu" website.
- aaronbrethorst 1y agoFalse Claim 28: Wind energy is unreliable As with solar energy, complete reliance on wind energy would pose intermittency challenges. However, wind, solar, and storage together can provide the majority of the country’s electricity without compromising reliability The false claim they're rebutting is that because wind is unreliable, we shouldn't deploy wind turbines for clean energy generation. They stipulate that it is a great part of a package of renewables.
- vlovich123 1y agoYes, but there’s no evidence that storage can or will be a cost effective strategy to let solar and wind handle base load power. That’s why China is betting on nuclear hard instead of storage to backfill what solar and wind cannot deliver.
- Reason077 1y agoSure, but our grids have plenty of existing natural gas generation, hydro generation and storage, etc. These aren't going to disappear just because we're building wind and solar. If you can go from a grid that burns natural gas 100% of the time to only 20% of the time, you've still cut carbon emissions dramatically. In the mean time, storage technologies will improve, nuclear might become cheaper, transmission grids will become better and more interconnected, etc. The fact that wind alone can't get us to a 100% renewable grid isn't a valid argument to not build wind power. Solar and wind are the cheapest and fastest technologies available today to expand energy production while reducing carbon emissions.
- vlovich123 1y agoI wasn’t making that claim. I was just highlighting how renewables by themselves are insufficient for base load power. Renewables often help with peak load and that is valuable, but base load is storage+renewables, nuclear, hydro, or fossil fuels.
- mikeyouse 1y agoChina isn’t doing one single thing… they’re rolling out more wind and solar than anywhere else on earth. They’re investing heavily in nuclear. They’re building massive banks of batteries and new hydro dams to store power. Pretending like they don’t have faith in renewables being a massive part of their future energy generation is just silly. They have multiple GWH+ battery projects under construction right now. https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/07/21/china-switches-on-its-largest-standalone-battery-storage-project/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/07/21/china-switches-on-its... https://www.energy-storage.news/powerchina-begins-construction-of-worlds-largest-generation-side-battery-storage-project/ https://www.energy-storage.news/powerchina-begins-constructi...
- Reason077 1y agoYep. China installed 256 GW of new solar capacity in the first 6 months of 2025 (out of 380 GW globally). To further put this into perspective, the United States had 239 GW of total installed PV capacity at the end of 2024. China is now adding more solar every 6 months than the US has installed ever.
- defrost 1y ago> That’s why China is betting on nuclear hard .. Relative to the US, sure, call it 'hard' if you like. Relative to China's total energy demand and current supply build out, coal still dominates (albeit near peak use in China and predicted to fall within a decade), renewables are where the bulk of growth and new generation is at, nuclear following a post Fukishima 'stumble' is planned to expand over the next decade, by 2035, to account for 10% of electricity generation (up from sub 2% now). 10%, perhaps even 15%, of total generation leaves a lot of slack that china plans to address with solar, wind, storage, HVDC transmission, etc.
- Reason077 1y agoYes, the actual claim they are debunking is the subheading: "Because of the wind’s intermittency and high variability, they do next to nothing to reduce the need for other fuels." I agree this one is poorly worded.
- sealeck 1y agoIf you read the claim they are addressing, it is specifically that > Because of the wind’s intermittency and high variability, they do next to nothing to reduce the need for other fuels. They then (correctly) point out that while wind on its own obviously doesn't work, it is still valuable as part of a grid system (with other sources of power). Note that what they say (i.e. "as with solar energy, complete reliance on wind energy would pose intermittency challenges") is not agreeing with the statement, as the statement is that it does "next to nothing" and their argument is that it does a lot, when combined with other power sources.
- scblock 1y agoWind is extremely reliable. And it is relatively predictable, particularly on a short time scale. What it is is intermittent, which is a very different thing.
- danpalmer 1y agoAnd by planning the locations well it's also less intermittent than one might expect, or you can build wind farms in locations with opposing wind trends so that you've always got something running.
- IMTDb 1y agoHow far away from each other are those opposing wind trends ? It’s one of the issues with the global grid in europe; if you look at weather patterns; all of western europe often tends to be contained in the same cell. And assuming you can find those opposing wind trends not too distant from each other how reliable is that (anti)correlation.
- bluGill 1y agoThat planning means you can ask factories to plan their energy use around high wind power times.
- danpalmer 1y agoSomething I learned a while ago that stuck with me is that it takes roughly the same electricity to refine oil to gasoline as an EV uses to drive the distance that gasoline would get you, and that only accounts for refining, not transport and storage of that gasoline, loss due to evaporation, etc. In other words, you can pretty much ignore where the electricity comes from and EVs are still better than gas cars for the environment.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoEVs reduce climate pollution, but by how much? New U-M research has the answer - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45110270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45110270 - September 2025 Across the US, EVs beat hybrids and gas in life cycle emissions study - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45016172 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45016172 - August 2025 Vehicle Lifecycle Emissions Calculator - https://vehicle-emissions-calculator.vercel.app/ https://vehicle-emissions-calculator.vercel.app/
- tptacek 1y agoI assume the big issue isn't electrical production at all, but rather the resource, energy, and waste costs of producing new EVs.
- fnordpiglet 1y agoEVs are generally more wasteful to produce but their efficiency covers the excess in 1-2 years of operations, and can operate without meaningful maintaining for 200-300k+ miles and 15-20 years. There are no obvious upsides to ICE beyond political ideology.
- tptacek 1y agoRight I'm not making an argument about EVs generally either way, just saying that the cost of the energy used to propel them on the road wasn't the controversy. For a lot of us, the question isn't "new EV vs. new ICE"; it's "new EV vs. current gen ICE".
- crmd 1y agoBy far, my priority for energy policy, in the US where I live, is to lower the cost of energy. After reading Claim 11, starting on page 29, where the authors state that: >unsubsidized solar energy is now generally cheaper than fossil fuels; and > solar energy compares favorably in terms of levelized cost (total lifetime energy production / total lifetime cost) The authors build this argument over three pages, including several charts, citing a Lazard paper that prices solar at $60/Mwh vs gas combined cycle at $70/MWh. But only in the last paragraph do they concede that when you include the cost of intermittency (firming), solar is only cheaper than gas peaking plant cost ($168/MWh). As someone who lives in New York City and is drowning in inflated energy bills, lacking any engineering explanation why my residential electricity $/MWh is triple that of Beijing, I am sick and tired of phony academic papers such as this that begin with a conclusion and work backward to fabricate extremely misleading arguments. I don’t care how my energy is generated. I strongly prefer it comes from sources that pollute less. But that preference is miles behind the priority for cheaper energy. Bullshit research like this, written by attorneys, including arguments like claim 11 which tries to hide the fact that solar only produces energy during daylight, annd does not account for storage/firming costs are not helping move our national energy dialog forward.
- malfist 1y agoSo you're saying we can't use solar because at some point, a small percentage of the time (i.e., peaking demand), it's more expensive than an alternative? Did you miss that overall it's still cheaper? There's nothing stopping us from using solar and nuclear as a baseline and firming/peaking with the cheapest fossil fuel. And given the cost reduction in batteries that's been going on, I doubt fossil fuel peaking will still be the cheapest in the next few years.
- tptacek 1y agoThey clearly didn't miss that it's cheaper overall, since they quoted that from the paper.
- standardUser 1y ago> As someone who lives in New York City Energy costs in NYC are double the national average, and little of that has to do with energy production and a lot to do with living in a place with extreme energy demands and infrastructure needs. And of course taxes. If energy prices in NY are driving you to the brink, you'll get a nice discount by living literally anywhere else.
- sren 1y agoIf anyone likes data visualization. Australia are betting heavily on renewables for their 2030 targets (despite some State Govt's opposition ahem Qld) and it's pretty magical see this in action day-to-day: https://explore.openelectricity.org.au/energy/nem/?range=7d&interval=30m&view=discrete-time&group=Detailed https://explore.openelectricity.org.au/energy/nem/?range=7d&... I'd also reccomend having a look at David Osmond's projections, where he looks at if we scaled up storage, wind and solar, by a few factors how close we would get to 100% stable and renewable. https://bsky.app/profile/davidosmond.bsky.social/post/3lyhcqfguw22j https://bsky.app/profile/davidosmond.bsky.social/post/3lyhcq...
- littlestymaar 1y agoI'm sorry, but this paper is disappointingly bad. There are plenty of false claims about solar, wind and EV and they are worth debunking. But there are also a few topics for which the real answer is much more nuanced (for instance claims #9, #12 and #13), where the claim itself is way exaggerated but there are still significant challenges to address, and treating those the same way you treat blatant bullshit is damageable, because of course opponents are going to exploit these to discredit the paper altogether… I wish academics could be a little more level headed an avoid taking needlessly polarizing takes like that.
- ggm 1y agoThis, and other documents are important, but will not prevent continuance both of the misleading claims, and opposition to wind, solar and EV. This is because the opposition is oftentimes not rooted in logic and reasoning but in emotions. If you don't like something, being told it's good for you doesn't magically make you like it.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoA South Dakota county drove away millions in solar energy - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45244165 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45244165 - September 2025
- Naru41 1y agoUtility-scale solar is very unpopular in Japan. Because most suitable lands of them are densely forested, and installing utility-scale solar systems requires destory the forests. There are concerns landslides due to reduced water storage functionality, and emotional antipathy at having their hometowns' mountains covered with solar panels.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoHow does the depopulation of rural areas contribute to this, if at all? https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/8/15/in-japans-ageing-countryside-communities-are-facing-extinction https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/8/15/in-japans-ageing-co... https://theconversation.com/when-a-countrys-towns-and-villages-face-extinction-88398 https://theconversation.com/when-a-countrys-towns-and-villag... https://old.reddit.com/r/japan/comments/bcnga2/japan_population_change_map_20152018_bluer_colors/ https://old.reddit.com/r/japan/comments/bcnga2/japan_populat... (utility scale solar generators typically have a 35 year lifetime, so in areas of Japan where you’re not cutting down forests, it makes sense to build where depopulation is occurring in a “last person out shut off the light” sort of way before the rural community goes extinct)
- LargoLasskhyfv 1y agohttps://japaninsides.com/japans-floating-solar-farm-with-50000-solar-panels-is-the-future-of-energy-52328 https://japaninsides.com/japans-floating-solar-farm-with-500...
- Incipient 1y agoPreface to this is I generally do believe that renewables are cheaper, however I'm not entirely certain of how much because so rarely are full assumptions and details documented. Storage costs, knock-on effect of intermittency, maintenance costs, etc.
- billbrown 1y agoMy personal true claim about solar that is generally ignored or unknown is that dust reduces solar efficiency by 40% and that the mitigation is frequent washing of panels, which results in considerable water use in precisely the worst areas for that. This 2024 paper cites a 2016 paper about clouds and dusts that finds 10.4% reduction in efficiency when the relative humidity was 52.24% after two weeks. (The 2016 study is cited in footnote 184 under clasim 12). That's not a desert condition, I can assure you. https://sustainenergyres.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40807-017-0043-y#:~:text=In%20desert%20area%2C%20the%20accumulation%20of%20dust%20on%20PV%20panel%20surface%20is%20very%20high.%20The%20reduction%20in%20solar%20efficiency%20due%20to%20dust%20on%20PV%20panel%20is%20approximately%2040% https://sustainenergyres.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s...
- IAmBroom 1y agoI think it's important to note that "efficiency" means something different in solar versus ICE. For combustion engines, a drop in efficiency increases your daily cost, and the carbon footprint. For solar, it simply means a lower maximum energy storage per day, which implies a higher initial outlay. The "wasted" sunlight doesn't cost anything.
- billbrown 1y agoWhat an odd response! I never mentioned ICE so I suspect you're arguing against someone else. The 40% "wasted sunlight" doesn't have a cost—sure, yes, kind of besides the point—but it also generates no electricity. That efficiency is further compounded by reductions in incidence by latitude, cloud cover, and time of day. The diminishment thus could be quite serious on any given panel or farm.