7 ms·
Study Finds High-Fructose Corn Syrup Contains Mercury
- ckinnan 18y agoThis is huge. The autism community has long suspected that mercury is a driver, yet eliminating it from childhood vaccines hasn't lowered the rate. Could HFCS-borne mercury be the cause? HFCS was introduced into the food supply in the mid to late 1980s, and autism cases have grown 15-fold since then. (I believe HFCS is also the major driver of the parabolic growth in diabetes during the same period.)
- omouse 18y ago"This is huge" no it isn't: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=452906 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=452906 "The US allowable limit for mercury in bottled water (and tap water) is 2000 parts per trillion. The report documents a maximum of 350 parts per trillion in Quaker Oatmeal to Go. Omitting that data which provides context probably tells you a lot about the people who wrote the report."
- blackguardx 18y agoAll my food-conscious friends in northern California are going to love this study. I live in Sonoma county and it seems like everyone I meet chooses not to consume some food product. The most common denominator is high fructose corn syrup. I avoid high fructose corn syrup myself for two reasons. Partly, it's because I'd rather pay for the sugar tariff than send more money to the corn lobby. The other part is that after stopping my consumption of soft drinks for other reasons, I find that foods and drinks that contain high fructose corn syrup are too sweet.
- jws 18y agoThe US allowable limit for mercury in bottled water (and tap water) is 2000 parts per trillion. The report documents a maximum of 350 parts per trillion in Quaker Oatmeal to Go. Omitting that data which provides context probably tells you a lot about the people who wrote the report.
- jcl 18y agoYou mean, the people who wrote the Washington Post article. The report clearly included the data. The report also mentions that the EPA has a "reference dose" of mercury of 0.1 ug/kg/day for women of childbearing age and young children, which they work out to 5.5 ug/day for the average woman -- versus an estimated 28.5ug total mercury/day consumed by the average American via contaminated HFCS. However, it's not clear how this EPA standard compares to the "US allowable limit for mercury in bottled water", which is presumably an FDA standard, or what assumptions went into these standards.
- jws 18y agoPunchline: last footnote of this post... if you lived on nothing but HFCS Coke-a-cola and all of that mercury were somehow transformed into its dangerous organic form, you would still only get 5% of your reference dose. For those following along, the mercury report is at http://www.healthobservatory.org/library.cfm?refid=105026 http://www.healthobservatory.org/library.cfm?refid=105026 I found the FDA/EPA limits at http://www.state.nj.us/health/eoh/hhazweb/mercury.pdf http://www.state.nj.us/health/eoh/hhazweb/mercury.pdf page 11 has the numbers. The mercury report does not include the 2000ppt FDA limit on mercury. It contains a different limit on methymercury which is not measured in any test of this report. Middle of page 12... The 0.1ug/kg/day is for methylmercury. The numbers measured in the report are for mercury. They researchers admit in the next paragraph that they have no idea if the mercury in HFCS is methymercury. (Presumably there are tests which they chose not to perform.) But look what they do with the numbers: - 20 samples of HFCS tested. - 11 have no detectable mercury (<5ppb) [1] - 1 sample was 570ppb They then estimate mercury ingestion using the 570ppb outlier times the 50g USDA daily HFCS number to get 28.5ug. A scary number since it is about 5 times the limit they just showed you. Except the number these illusionists showed you in their left hand was for methylmercury limit of 3/4 scale women[2] and the number they showed you in their right was total mercury (inorganic plus organic) of full scale people, and the one in the right assumes that all the disparate sources of HFCS in a day's food happened to use the same outlier source[3]. [1] I wonder why the HFCS tests have a 5000ppT limit of detection and the foods test (page 14) have limits in the 20-100ppT range. Different tests? Something about HFCS that confounds the test? No answers. [2] For the “average” 55 kg American woman I suppose the "average 55kg woman" weighs 55kg. The average American woman however weighs 74.5kg. 55kg gives a more dramatic number though. [3] They don't report any sort of average or distribution of the 20 samples other than the 9 of them are above the limits of detection. I suspect the average did nothing for their argument so they went with an outlier. Let's check their data... I just finished a 257mL american Coke (the little half can) with 2.5g of HFCS (1%, yes I mixed volume and mass, but we are estimating here) in it. Their one reported test of Coke was 60ppT mercury, which if we assume it all came from the HFCS would be 6ppB mercury in the HFCS. What if the 570ppb HFCS number were real and was used for Coke? That would be 5700ppt in the food test. There is nothing within an order of magnitude in the table, and there isn't much in the way of consumable food that is more heavily sugared than American sodas. What if you got ALL of your calories by drinking 20 tiny Cokes a day and what if ALL of the mercury in the Coke was methylmercury? 50g of HFCS at 6ppb would give you 0.3ug/day, about 5% of your EPA reference dose.
- Retric 18y ago"In the first study, researchers found detectable levels of mercury in nine of 20 samples of commercial HFCS." Debatable and harmful can be widely separated. Without any real numbers I am going to assume that this is a tiny amount of contamination and hardly meaningful. PS: I might be an environmentalist, but I hate bad science reporting.
- robotron 18y agoActual info here: http://www.iatp.org/ http://www.iatp.org/
- jcl 18y agoFrom that page (PDF): http://www.healthobservatory.org/library.cfm?refID=105040 http://www.healthobservatory.org/library.cfm?refID=105040 This chart lists several brand-name foods that had "detectable" levels of mercury, the worst of which is about 350 parts per trillion. According to Wikipedia, the "action level" of mercury in fish (the point at which government takes action) is one part per million. So it sounds like you'd have to eat/drink thousands of servings of this food to equal one particularly bad helping of fish. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercury_poisoning#Prevention http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercury_poisoning#Prevention On the other hand, Wikipedia lists the legal limit for water as two parts per billion ("inorganic mercury" instead of "methylmercury"), which would be easier to hit. I'm not sure which limit applies in this case. Edit: It might be worse than this for some portion of the population. From the "Not so sweet" paper: Using the USDA’s estimate of 50 grams of average consumption HFCS per day, one might roughly estimate potential total mercury ingestion via HFCS of up to 28.5ug total mercury/day (50 grams HFCS X 0.570 ug/g). Using these same assumptions, high-end HFCS consumers potentially could have much higher total mercury ingestion. It is difficult to know to what to compare this figure. The EPA has established a "reference dose," or maximum recommended dietary intake of methylmercury. Methylmercury is the form typically found in fish and seafood. The reference dose of 0.1 ug/kg/day applies to women of childbearing age and young children, who are thought to be the most at risk from methylmercury exposure. For the "average" 55 kg American woman, this would translate into no more than 5.5ug/day of methylmercury. There is no reference dose for total mercury. The mercury found in HFCS may be a different form of mercury than the methylmercury typically found in fish (we just don’t know), but it poses a risk just the same. Mercury in any form can be toxic to the developing brain.
- coryrc 18y agohttp://www.ens-newswire.com/ens/dec2005/2005-12-14-01.asp http://www.ens-newswire.com/ens/dec2005/2005-12-14-01.asp "emissions from power plants in 10 states - Alabama, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas and West Virginia - represent almost 60 percent of U.S. mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants" And what do we find in IL, IN, KY, MI, OH, and PA? Though, to be fair, coal isn't responsible for the majority of mercury emissions, see: http://www.tva.gov/environment/air/ontheair/merc_emis.htm http://www.tva.gov/environment/air/ontheair/merc_emis.htm http://www.epa.gov/mercury/reportover.htm http://www.epa.gov/mercury/reportover.htm
- jcl 18y agoThe papers, however, were specifically looking for mercury that was "lost" during the creation of caustic soda, at plants that literally use tons of mercury for this purpose. That is, the mercury is being added when the HFCS is made, not when the corn is grown. (One paper indicates that the four plants responsible are in GA, TN, OH, and WV.) Switching to a better caustic soda process should eliminate the detectable mercury, regardless of the proximity to coal plants. And some food producers are doing so; as one of the papers points out: "No mercury was detected in the majority of beverages tested."
- coryrc 18y agoAh, I see. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_hydroxide#Manufacture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_hydroxide#Manufacture Wikipedia claims "the membrane cell process is economically the most viable", which does not use mercury. Also, as shown in my previous links, chloralkali plants (which make caustic soda) pollute a significant amount of mercury (needlessly, in my opinion).
- llimllib 18y agoHere's the actual paper: http://www.ehjournal.net/content/pdf/1476-069x-8-2.pdf http://www.ehjournal.net/content/pdf/1476-069x-8-2.pdf . They found a maximum of .57 ppm mercury in corn syrup; the allowable limit of mercury in sushi is 1 ppm. .57 is probably high, and whatever source they found that from should be checked out; but this doesn't seem to me like reason for drastic action. But I'm no expert! Anybody want to tell me why I'm wrong?
- arockwell 18y agoAccording to wikipedia average american eats 70 pounds of HFCS syrup a year, so that's significantly more risk.
- blackguardx 18y agoPeople generally don't eat sushi in the US as often as they consume high fructose corn syrup containing food products.
- llimllib 18y agocertainly true, though you must temper that with the fact that HFCS forms a very small fraction of the volume of a drink/snack, serving to dilute the potential mercury to an extraordinarily small amount per drink/snack.
- blackguardx 18y agoLook at soft drinks. High fructose corn syrup is usually number 1 or number 2.
- llimllib 18y agoAbout.com[1] says a soda contains 23 grams of HFCS, and a there are about 226 grams of soda in an 8-oz can[2], so HFCS makes up about 10% of a soda (wow!). From the worst of the tested sources, in this survey, a soda could contain .06ppm mercury, more than an order of magnitude smaller than what the government considers dangerous in seafood. It's interesting to read about Jeremy Pivens' mercury toxicity[3]. In order to reach a point where it affected his ability to live life normally, he had to eat sushi twice a day, every day. Furthermore, his doctors said that a few months of treatment would solve his problem. It seems likely to me that the amount of HFCS you'd need to eat in the very unlikely worst case to get actual mercury poisoning is going to give you diabetes before the mercury affects you. Which is not to say that we shouldn't stop allowing people to sell mercury laden HFCS! If 9/20 studied samples contain no mercury, they all should, it's clearly a public health problem. What I mean to say is just that this is likely only to be a serious problem for a very few very heavy HFCS consumers, if any, and that people shouldn't take it to mean "I can't eat HFCS because I'll get mercury in me", because they probably won't get clinical amounts of mercury. There's plenty of good reasons to avoid HFCS, I advocate that to everyone, but I don't think that the fear of the mercury found by this study is one of them. [1] http://www.answers.com/topic/high-fructose-corn-syrup-1#cite_note-31 http://www.answers.com/topic/high-fructose-corn-syrup-1#cite... [2] http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_much_does_a_can_of_soda_pop_weight http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_much_does_a_can_of_soda_pop_we... [3] http://www.webmd.com/news/20081218/jeremy-pivens-high-mercury-count http://www.webmd.com/news/20081218/jeremy-pivens-high-mercur...
- time_management 18y agoThe good news is that mercury-free HFCS ingredients exist. Food companies just need a good push to only use those ingredients The good news is that arsenic-free dogshit exists. Dogs just need a good diet of arsenic-free dog food.
- ewiethoff 18y agoYet another reason why I'm glad I'm allergic to corn. Yet another reason to be fed up with the Corn Cartel's push to have everything under the sun made from corn.
- ckinnan 18y agoHFCS exists ONLY because of US government policy. The US sugar program drives up the price of sugar by limiting domestic supplies and imports. As as result it is profitable to mill corn into sweetener, and U.S. food makers use it as a substitute everywhere possible (mostly liquids) as it is slightly cheaper than sugar. Soda outside the US,for example, still uses traditional sugar. As a result, the corn growers are a vociferous lobby in support of the sugar program.
- michaelneale 18y agoYes when I travel to the US I notice the taste immediately in soft drinks (and consequently stop drinking them all together, which is probably not a bad thing for me !). HFCS seems to have all the "sweet" hit without any flavour for it, quite horrible once you have had the alternative.
- tlrobinson 18y agoI'm not much of a Coke connoisseur, but some of my friends also think that imported Coke (from Mexico... Mexicoke!) tastes better.
- ckinnan 18y ago"Mexicoke", with sugar instead of HFCS, is the real "classic" Coke!
- michaelneale 18y agoI love it - but I try to only have 1 can every few days at most - but only cause here in .au its sugar ! If it was readily available I would drink it all the time (which would be quite bad for me).