4 ms·
> I call Chris Mok, a top-ranked local TaskRabbit who earns up to $1,500 a week. Mok was laid off from his job as an art buyer at Macy’s (M) in 2009 and now spe
by egypturnash 14y ago
> I call Chris Mok, a top-ranked local TaskRabbit who earns up to $1,500 a week. Mok was laid off from his job as an art buyer at Macy’s (M) in 2009 and now spends most days, including weekends, on handyman assignments such as assembling Ikea furniture.
TaskRabbit: Distributed underemployment.
- kiba 14y agoIt's better than being unemployed.
- philwelch 14y ago60,000 per year is not "underemployment".
- grueful 14y agoYou know all those jobs claiming you can earn up to $big_number a week? That's their all-time record. The odds of real numbers resembling it are low.
- philwelch 14y agoThe national median household income is around 45k. The third quintile starts just under 35k. Are you really going to say that half of the US population is "underemployed"?
- majormajor 14y agoI don't think egypturnash or grueful are saying that; rather, they're questioning how many TaskRabbit workers come close to that. Let's look at Chris Mok, mentioned in this article as a top-ranked TaskRabbit who makes "up to" $1500 a week, but a Reuter's article from February describes him as making about $3500/month, which works out to 42k per year[1], far far below that weekly "up to" number. And so when TaskRabbit's Leah Busque says people make "up to" 60k a year, my assumption is that most are making much less, especially when a "top ranked" guy appears to be about 18k below that. I'd love to know mean and median figures, at the least, but haven't been able to turn them up—which doesn't do anything to alleviate skepticism about the "up to" numbers. Obviously if someone can make even 20-30k from this in a market where they can't find anything else, then it's a good thing they've got TaskRabbit, but I wouldn't really call that enabling entrepreneurship in line with the TaskRabbit PR message. [1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/09/us-peer-idUSTRE81814F20120209 http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/09/us-peer-idUSTRE818...
- huggah 14y agoLocation also makes a huge difference; in San Francisco (where he lives), median household income is over $65k and the median rental price for a 1 bedroom apartment is over $2k. If Mok makes $3.5K / month, that probably qualifies as underemployment.
- tomjen3 14y agoSorry to say but there is no such thing as underemployment. Clearly there are less need for art buyers (or he wasn't good enough to do the job) than there were in 2009, so he has to do something else.
- chimeracoder 14y agoPeople grossly overuse (and abuse) the term unemployment like this. First, an unemployment rate of 0% is bad. This is because not all unemployment is bad. Frictional unemployment is actually a good thing (to a certain extent), because the alternative is having people stuck doing jobs they don't want when better jobs are available. Structural unemployment is what happens when $old_industry dies because $disruptive_tech_company changes the market. It's definitely bad for the unemployed (who will never be re-employed in the same field), but it's usually the result of positive improvements to society at large. The 'solution' is that those people losing their jobs need to be retrained to work in another field, which is admittedly difficult, or retire. Cyclical unemployment is undeniably bad. That's the result of boom-and-bust economies - people over-hiring during bubbles, and then having to lay off en masse when the market contracts. (The problem is largely that the people are being dumped into the jobs marketplace all at once, creating a glut, instead of being more evenly distributed). The rest - someone who's employed but at a salary lower than what they'd like, or someone who retires because they're laid off... that's not unemployment. Someone may dislike it and they may think it's a 'problem' that needs to be 'fixed', but they need to realize that they're talking about something completely different from unemployment. As for real unemployment, the ideal value is a point of debate amongst economists because it is tricky to measure, but somewhere in the ballpark of 5% is a commonly accepted value for the target 'natural rate' of unemployment. That is, a sustained, unwavering value of 5% unemployment is actually the target for a healthy economy.
- lotharbot 14y agoThe term used was underemployment.
- chimeracoder 14y ago
- brown9-2 14y ago"Underemployment" is a characteristic of the economy that TaskRabbit operates in, not one that they create.