4 ms·
Who cares? IPv4 is a dead technology and this is like complaining that the UK has a bunch of fax machines in storage somewhere. 10 years ago, this would have
by jrockway 14y ago
Who cares? IPv4 is a dead technology and this is like complaining that the UK has a bunch of fax machines in storage somewhere. 10 years ago, this would have been a waste. Now it doesn't even matter.
Even Comcast supports IPv6.
- wglb 14y agoSo how do you envision the transition taking place? Given that 6 and 4 talk past each other.
- jrockway 14y agoThe transition has sort of already happened. Most software stacks support IPv6 now, and many server hosting companies are giving out IPv6 addresses like candy. (I think I have a /48 or something for jrock.us. That's 2 to the 48th IPv4 Internets! I have a lot of computers, but not that many.) All that's left are the clients, and the way I see that transition happening is in the low-cost sector. Sort of like an AOL where you won't have IPv4, so you'll have to access everything through a proxy except IPv6 sites. Eventually businesses will want to cater to this demographic and the stragglers will flip the IPv6 switch. With nobody on IPv4, it won't be a premium value-add anymore, and that era will be a distant memory of the past like BBSes are now. Right now the IPv4 situation is not bad enough to make widespread IPv6 support critical to one's economic viability yet. Being able to see the animated turtle on kame.net isn't quite enough of an incentive, but the incentives will slowly shift. (I see the same transition away from fossil fuels. Right now, an investment in alternative energies is pure speculation: it may pay off someday, but we don't know when that day is. When we've run out, though, the payoff will be clear: you will get infinite money the second you figure out some way to give humanity energy. This will encourage more investment than some nebulous LEED certification will. Tax credits are nice, but not as nice as cash.)
- geofft 14y ago"The transition has sort of already happened," he says, over IPv4. Seriously, unless you want to be posting to HN via IPv4 in 2050, there is clearly something major left undone. Don't call it a transition if you think that concept is undone, but it's not yet functionally possible to be on the Internet with no IPv4 stack or (possibly NATted) address, and I don't see that becoming the case anytime soon. See http://cr.yp.to/djbdns/ipv6mess.html http://cr.yp.to/djbdns/ipv6mess.html for a description of the problem that I mostly agree with. The depressing thing is that those complaints are no less valid a decade later.
- wglb 14y agoThat was the answer that my question was leading to. Thanks.
- wmf 14y agoThe transition plan is called Dual Stack Lite or NAT64.
- jrockway 14y agoOnly because HN is IPv4-only. I'm sitting in a remote office on my laptop this morning, and it has an IPv6 address. When I visit google.com, it's over IPv6. It's happening.
- geofft 14y agoWhy is HN IPv4-only? And why should they bother to spend any effort fixing it? Given that, e.g., techcrunch.com and github.com and everything else linked from HN is IPv4-only, you can't usefully use Hacker News from an IPv6-only connection, so why should HN care? You're expecting altruism or geekiness on the part of every single website ever -- it's fair to expect that from Google, but not from everyone. The transition may or may not be happen_ing_, but it will never finish.
- jrockway 14y agoNo I'm not, I'm expecting anti-altruism from low-cost ISPs. (Name one consumer ISP that you think is altruistic.) Then, to capture that market, servers will start deploying IPv6. Today, IPv6 is billed as a premium feature. Tomorrow, IPv4 will be the premium feature.
- geofft 14y agoWait, you expect any low-cost ISPs to offer IPv6-only, and have any customers at all? And that IPv4-only sites will say "gee, better support those IPv6-only users" instead of saying "get a better ISP" (or more likely "We have no idea what's wrong, but it works from Comcast, complain to your ISP")? I don't think you understand how the Internet works. Or business. There is no foreseeable point at which it makes sense to bill an "Internet" service that's IPv6-only. That's doable _after_ the transition, but expecting that to happen now is not a transition.
- kanzure 14y agoHow did you get a /48?
- justincormack 14y agoIts pretty standard, you either get a /64 or a /48, normally just ask your ISP.
- harshreality 14y agoComcast is only one ISP. AT&T hasn't yet deployed IPv6 for their residential customers. (I think there are ipv6rd routers available, but you have to know about them and configure your own router to use them, and since it's not an official service, it could be discontinued at any time). Then there's software. Many web apps don't support IPv6 (db fields limited to ipv4 format, or code assuming ipv4 format). For instance, Internet Brands is too busy with important business, like frivolous lawsuits, to fully support IPv6 in vBulletin. [1] Some webapps have 3rd party hacks (or even first party hacks) to "support" ipv6 without modifying a lot of ipv4-dependent code, typically by hashing the ipv6 address, taking 32 bits, and using that as the ipv4 address. It's both disgusting and funny. There's a long way to go before IPv4 is dead. [1] http://tracker.vbulletin.com/browse/VBIV-9397 http://tracker.vbulletin.com/browse/VBIV-9397 (you need a vbulletin.com forum login, unfortunately, and maybe also a linked license; in summary, it's a 2-year-old bug for full support of IPv6, it has no comments from vbulletin devs and no assignee.)
- InclinedPlane 14y agoHere's my "bold" (aka safe) prediction: IPv4 will still be the dominant network addressing system in use in 2025.