6 ms·
"The end result, though, despite Apple’s best efforts to convince us otherwise, is a phone that is reactionary rather than revolutionary, or even evolutionary."
by bane 14y ago
"The end result, though, despite Apple’s best efforts to convince us otherwise, is a phone that is reactionary rather than revolutionary, or even evolutionary."
I've been struggling with the right word to describe this update and "reactionary" hits the nail on the head. Almost everything this phone has, the competition has had for quite some time. It doesn't quite feel like catchup, with typical panache Apple has built a best-in-class phone design. But it just doesn't feel like something anybody wants to be chasing any more.
Bigger picture, I'm not sure what this means for the smartphone ecosystem as a whole w.r.t. innovation. The heat of competition feels like it's finally let off.
- iProject 14y ago> doesn't feel like something anybody wants to be chasing any more A reasonable speculation. Of course the best data will take a while to become available. The one data point (showing in headlines this morning) is that, judging that it took only 1 hour for iP5 shipping time to move back from 1 week to 2 weeks, this phone is selling several times as fast as any iPhone predecessor. Apparently some body is "chasing it."
- recoiledsnake 14y agoJust because something sells well doesn't tell us everything. It's a good data point though. http://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240080531/Windows-Vista-sales-outstrip-XP-launch http://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240080531/Windows-Vista-...
- bradleyland 14y agoEven the very first iPhone was "reactionary". It wasn't a class leader if you're looking at it from a bulleted-list perspective. The first iPhone was EDGE only at a time when everyone was clammmoring for 3G phones, and it wouldn't run third-party apps. Many feature phones can run third-party apps; albeit crappy ones. The iPhone couldn't run third-party apps for a full year after its release. Talk about reactionary! The tech press does the same thing every time a new iPhone is released. They look at it on paper and say dumb things like: > Don’t get me wrong: the iPhone 5 is a beautiful phone, and in true Apple fashion its design and construction are probably second to none… but is that really enough? So, there is no other phone that can beat its design and construction, but "is it enough"? Is being the best enough? That has to go down as one of the dumbest, most contradictory rhetorical questions in history. I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Consumers don't care about implementation details. They care about the experience, and year after year, Apple delivers the best experience (proved by JD Power's smartphone satisfaction results).
- cooldeal 14y ago>So, there is no other phone that can beat its design and construction, but "is it enough"? Is being the best enough? The Nokia N9, Lumia 800, 900 and 920 are pretty well built and designed too. If you haven't, try going to a store and playing with one. Coming to the design itself, it's tied in with fashion and at this point the design has not changed(except for the new back) since the iPhone 4 over 2 years ago. Design and fashion do age. The iPhone 4's design was a leap over the 3GS and combined with other features warranted a new version number, while this iteration feels that it should've been named iPhone 4X, X for extra long. Why get a new iPhone 5 when you already have an iPhone 4 or 4S and can add a Galaxy or Lumia and keep the old phone around as a iPod Touch music player? Also, even if the design is superlative and timeless, for many consumers it is just one factor. The other factors are raw power, technical specs, camera quality and features(which the Lumia 920 is going to have a head start on). If the iPhone 5 cannot compete on specs with this years phones, what chance does it have with the Android phones of the next year? However, there's another bigger factor that I previously commented on: I think their problem right now is that users' choice is overwhelming them and the one-size-fits-all approach of the iPhone has diminishing returns after a point. The variety, choice of screen sizes and price ranges of the competition is only getting better by the day. A new iPhone is released only once a year, so it better be very good with a lot of new technologies, features, new designs etc. for sales to last all through the next year. iPhone 4S sales started lagging in the 3Q itself this year, compared to the 4th quarter for the iPhone 4. This is because people start waiting for the next version or switch to the competition because they have better specced devices with more features. I think Samsung timed their Galaxy S3 launch perfectly to coincide with the iPhone 4S getting old enough to beat, and they beat it in monthly sales for the first time, which is a noteworthy thing in itself. The whole situation is reminding me of the PC wars in the 80s, where Apple had a seemingly unassailable innovation lead, and then squandered it away by offering limited choice and higher prices, while Microsoft very smartly licensed DOS to Compaq and others like Dell and HP, and the rest is history. Apple's marketshare is now 17% vs. Android's 67% which is about 4 times more. No wonder Apple is going crazy with the patent war against Android. That's probably their only weapon against the equivalent of the attack of the hordes of beige boxes' that previously took them down. The iPhone 5 is good enough to get great sales and beat all sales records ever, but the key is how well it does starting about 6 months from now.
- majormajor 14y agoIMO, Phones have been pretty much commodities feature-wise for at least two or three years. The iPhone was the first modern smartphone, and I'd call the 260+ ppi Droid the first "truly modern" smartphone. Apple leapfrogged that screen density a bit further with the iPhone 4, but the usability/readability jump for text was biggest in that first jump made by the Droid. There aren't any current truly game-changing features out there. Heck, despite missing free turn-by-turn navigation for years (and there being much complaining about this from iPhone users) iPhones still sold in ever-increasing numbers. Even if the geek crowd is feeling like the iPhone is increasingly just more of the same, I think it'll take a long to for that feeling to permeate the masses. And it would probably take some serious marketing/design failures on Apple's part for it to happen any time quickly. So while Android's carving out a ton of sales in the cheaper/free-smartphone area, Apple still has a ton of mindshare as the premium smartphone for heavy users, which further drives development of the latest apps to be targeted for iOS first, etc. (And that's without mentioning the iPad sales beast.) But unless someone figures out something truly novel to do with NFC or whatever other new features introduced, people aren't going to care much. Right now those features look promising to people in the know, but they're still far from essential. Apple gets some more help in the US with the subsidy situation—for instance, on AT&T, the new-customer unsubsidized price of the 16GB S3 is $100 less than the 16GB iPhone 5, but the two year contract one is the same price. The One X is $200 less unsubsidized, but only $100 less with a two year contract. Some quick searching makes it appear that the S3 was only $50 less than the current iPhone 5 price unsubsidized at initial launch, but that's still a nice little trick on Apple's part to have AT&T sell a pricier phone for the same price.
- gte910h 14y agoIt's a very very pretty screen. People are going to be chasing that.