5 ms·
Do you have an idea of how many IPv4 addresses that are unused or not really needed? Between the bunch MIT got, the bunch that the military got and the bunch t
by tomjen3 14y ago
Do you have an idea of how many IPv4 addresses that are unused or not really needed?
Between the bunch MIT got, the bunch that the military got and the bunch that IBM got, we can implement an entirely new protocol before we run out.
- astrodust 14y agoThere's a lot of companies in the Class A club that don't necessarily need their whole allocations, but for reasons of legacy it might be difficult to displace them. When Apple and MIT got their allocations it probably seemed pretty reasonable at the time. "How many organizations like that would be interested in the internet? A dozen? That sounds about right." There was a time where anyone with a .net domain name would be able to apply for and probably get a /16 allocation with hardly any questions asked.
- lmm 14y ago>Do you have an idea of how many IPv4 addresses that are unused or not really needed? If by "really needed" you mean just in terms of having one address for each machine then sure there's a bunch not being used. Let's suppose half of them. Assuming a constant growth rate, that would last us for ten more years. But actually internet adoption is still accelerating. A safer assumption would be something like five. But our routers would collapse under the strain of the enormous routing tables long before then. To be able to route efficiently subnets need to be logical regions in the network topology, not arbitrary collections of 2^n machines. CIDR, needed to mitigate against the shortage of IPv4 addresses (or more properly the shortage of subnets) has been slowing the internet down since 1993. >Between the bunch MIT got, the bunch that the military got and the bunch that IBM got, we can implement an entirely new protocol before we run out. Given that we've been working on IPv6 for 15 years and it's not fully deployed yet, no we can't. Even if every single address was unallocated today, we'd use them up before then.
- zokier 14y agoThere are approximately 52 unadvertised /8s. Before the addresses ran out, we were using about one /8 per month. So even if we'd reclaim all unadvertised ranges, that would still buy us maybe 4 years (probably less considering the explosive growth in Asia). The design of IPv6 began in the mid-90s, and RFCs were released in 96-98. Now, 15 years later, we are mostly still using IPv4. In conclusion I think saying that we would have enough time to implement entirely new protocol if we'd reclaim unused addresses is way too optimistic. Even getting IPv6 really deployed at large in 4 years would be challenging enough.
- koide 14y agoI have no clue about serious networking, so I have to ask: why would you have your public, routable addresses unadvertised? What's the benefit of using them instead of a 10.0.0.0/8?
- carlisle_ 14y agoSomebody explained up above, but one example is that it can be used to mitigate collisions. If you have a company merge with another, and both are using 10.0.0.0/8 you could spend a lot of time and money renumbering or you could use unadvertised IPs to connect the networks.
- mayneack 14y agoAt MIT a 30 person living group gets 18.n.x.x
- clarkm 14y agoPosting from our own 18.n.0.0/16 Class B subnet right now. There's a few thousand available IPs for each person who lives here.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sprobertson 14y agoWhich will be great for testing my Raspberry Pi distributed web server. But useless for anyone who doesn't know / care what an IP address is (70% of us?)
- mayneack 14y agoI would imagine that you'd have more of a problem finding enough ethernet ports than ip addresses.
- Dave_Rosenthal 14y agoAs an 18.205.x.x alum, I can confirm this incredible fact.
- rdl 14y ago18.209.0.1 is still my default test IP (it was our internal router interface at Fenway, but it also is a reasonable remote test IP). Heh.