12 ms·
The UK has an entire IPv4 /8 that it isn't using
- webwanderings 14y agoEventually in the future, people will come to realize the over-exaggeration of running out of ipv4 addresses. The unused blocks will come out of woodwork from everywhere. Well, I hope my opinion is wrong.
- wtallis 14y agoThere's still a finite number of IP addresses that is below all reasonable expectations for how many devices will be wanting an IP address. Reclaiming unused blocks just softens the shock by making the exhaustion less sudden and more gradual. We're still definitely going to run out.
- Retric 14y agoThere are a little over 4 billion IPv4 addresses. If they cost even 10c / month the vast majority of them would still be unused. However, because they where free well over half of them are simply wasted and we are "running out".
- aquark 14y agoMy ISP feels it is 'reasonable' to charge $10\month for one. $10 x 4B x 12 months would solve the national debt in just a few years...
- khuey 14y agoAssuming you mean the American national debt, not really. That's only $480 billion/year. That wouldn't even plug our current deficit, let alone start paying off the debt.
- SG- 14y agoBy future do you mean right now where NAT is being used by some providers already? I know Rogers in Canada has all mobile devices going through NAT unless you pay a nice "VPN" fee. Also the assigned but unused IPv4 blocks don't do anything for other providers that actually need addresses.
- indiecore 14y agoand that's extremely profitable for them. Why would they switch to a format that doesn't give them the easy out to gouge customers?
- SG- 14y agoProfitable? I guess, but it doesn't make them much or any revenue since i'm pretty sure 99% of their mobile customers don't really care.
- anonymouz 14y agoSo a home network will be NAT'ed twice. How nice, we almost got things sort of working with one NAT, now the Internet breaks again.
- shinratdr 14y agoRogers only blocks PPTP VPN connections. Also it's not a VPN "fee" exactly, it's an entirely different APN. If your device doesn't allow you to manually edit the APN, you have no hope of getting your Rogers device to create a PPTP VPN connection over 3G because you cant access the internet.vpn.com APN. However, L2TP and IPSec VPN connections work just fine over 3G on Rogers, no fees or APN changes required. So I'm not positive that NAT is the issue if I can establish the other types of VPN connections although this is hardly my area of expertise.
- andreasvc 14y agoOnce no more unused addresses turn up, they can start economizing on the used ones too. For example my university gives a publicly routed IP address to EVERY computer, even though most are completely firewalled off.
- X-Istence 14y agoIBM has an entire /8 that they use internally for addressing their computers, none of them are publicly routable or even publicly accessible. Even if they were to start announcing them or selling them it would be a HUGE project for IBM internally to make sure that their computers aren't going out on the web for internal resources, and it becomes an huge issue of having to renumber. Unfortunately there is no good way to support something like that. Some companies didn't need to use the private LAN addresses because they had their own /8 and changing it now would require too much effort and work.
- andreasvc 14y agoI see that it would be a lot of work, but so will switching to IPv6 be. The question is: which will be worse? which will actually happen? I don't know. I'm probably forgetting a lot of things but to me it would seem doable to switch to private LAN addresses using DHCP and NAT, as long as there are no hardcoded IPs lingering around (but only hostnames which can be updated in a central location).
- wmf 14y agoThe problem comes when two companies using 10.0.0.0/8 decide to merge. For example, IBM acquires multiple companies every year.
- eru 14y agoYou could still keep the networks separate.
- Zenst 14y agoVery valid point - especialy given that many text-books and other Ip education material would tend to bias you to use 10.0.0.0/8 as that is what you do, remember many companies who used the old SCO IP range as there `network chap` learned IP from a popular book that used SCO IP's in there examples. Thing is though, if a pretty compitent company like IBM who know how to do IT have not moved to IPV6 and use public IP ranges for there internal networks albiet router blocked. Well, it just don't bode well for other less technicaly compitent people to move now does it and the cycle of procrastination with IPV4 carry's on :(.
- CrLf 14y agoNo traces of this block in the public Internet doesn't mean it isn't being used. It may be in use in some internal network(s) instead of a private address range (yes, that happens).
- eckyptang 14y agoSpot on. Some of the unused blocks owned by the MoD are actually provided to a few top secret things. It wouldn't surprise me if this is the case for this as well.
- sjwright 14y agoRunning NAT behind a routable IP address range AND using a totally different range for all servers, VPNs, and various sysadmin crap? I don't believe it. There's no way they would be so diligent to use that IP range internally without even a tiny bit of evidence externally.
- omh 14y agoThis is the government, so it's practically guaranteed that there's at least two layers of firewalls between any internal networks and the internet. If any of those layers was installed by an average IT consultancy then they'll have used NAT (because that's what you always do, right?) and hidden 51./8 completely.
- toyg 14y agoThis. From a comment on the page: "The 51.* addresses are in fact heavily used by DWP, but only internally. The best bit is this: for security reasons, there is a policy that in any communication, the leading octet of all such IP addresses must be redacted. Not like it's a matter of public record or anything. I did once toy with the idea of printing out the XKCD map of the IP4 address space, write "you are here" on it and pin it to the wall near DWP data networks teams, but I didn't think it would go down well."
- InclinedPlane 14y agoIf you're using a /8 for LAN addresses you are doing the entire internet a disservice.
- forgotusername 14y agoI'm not sure about the definition of 'unused', just because a network is not visible from the Internet and has no publicly registered ASNs doesn't mean its numbers are not in private use (which AFAIK, was always a legitimate use-case for getting an allocation, and in many ways preferable to reusing RFC1918 space). Added to that, even if it was seeing only minuscule internal use, the UK government's IT project reputation suggests the renumbering would cost at least as much as the block would sell for, assuming the project would even complete prior to the entire planet properly migrating to v6 and the block losing its value.
- s_henry_paulson 14y agoIf there are no networks defined, as far as RIPE is concerned, it's un-used. We just got audited for RIPE for exactly this reason, and they made us specify details for all of the networks we use on our allocation to be allowed to keep our address space.
- X-Istence 14y agoThat's not the case for older legacy networks. Those don't fall under the purview of RIPE as they were allocated before RIPE existed. I'm wondering if RIPE can even do anything regarding that netblock in terms of possibly pulling it and re-allocating it.
- kiallmacinnes 14y agoAs far as I know, they can't. All they can do (and have already done) is ask nicely for it back.
- wpietri 14y agoWell, if they were feeling ballsy, they could just declare it unused, break it up, and start assigning it. A lot more network nerds would listen to RIPE than to some random UK pension bureaucracy.
- 14y ago
- lmm 14y agoHooray, another /8, that'll last us for a good month or so. Exponential growth people, reclaiming unused IP blocks isn't going to stop it. And that's ignoring the possibilities that a) it's being used internally by its legitimate owners b) it's being used internally by other people. T-Mobile were seen to be (mis)using the /8 that belongs to the UK MOD for their internal networks, I wouldn't be surprised if they were doing that with this as well. There aren't that many IPv4 addresses. There are no easy fixes. Just move to IPv6 already.
- tomjen3 14y agoDo you have an idea of how many IPv4 addresses that are unused or not really needed? Between the bunch MIT got, the bunch that the military got and the bunch that IBM got, we can implement an entirely new protocol before we run out.
- astrodust 14y agoThere's a lot of companies in the Class A club that don't necessarily need their whole allocations, but for reasons of legacy it might be difficult to displace them. When Apple and MIT got their allocations it probably seemed pretty reasonable at the time. "How many organizations like that would be interested in the internet? A dozen? That sounds about right." There was a time where anyone with a .net domain name would be able to apply for and probably get a /16 allocation with hardly any questions asked.
- lmm 14y ago>Do you have an idea of how many IPv4 addresses that are unused or not really needed? If by "really needed" you mean just in terms of having one address for each machine then sure there's a bunch not being used. Let's suppose half of them. Assuming a constant growth rate, that would last us for ten more years. But actually internet adoption is still accelerating. A safer assumption would be something like five. But our routers would collapse under the strain of the enormous routing tables long before then. To be able to route efficiently subnets need to be logical regions in the network topology, not arbitrary collections of 2^n machines. CIDR, needed to mitigate against the shortage of IPv4 addresses (or more properly the shortage of subnets) has been slowing the internet down since 1993. >Between the bunch MIT got, the bunch that the military got and the bunch that IBM got, we can implement an entirely new protocol before we run out. Given that we've been working on IPv6 for 15 years and it's not fully deployed yet, no we can't. Even if every single address was unallocated today, we'd use them up before then.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoNo doubt part of the strategic IP reserve :-) There are a number of ways the IP addresses can not appear to the outside user and still be used as several have mentioned, and of course they can be for some project that isn't yet 'done' (the Coast Guard had a huge block like that as I recall) but the more interesting bit is to track the cost of getting an /24 network its inching up. At the time where the easy stuff has been reclaimed it will shoot up.
- lucb1e 14y agoI find this funny. The IANA holds 15 IPv4 /8 blocks, even mentions "Reserved for future use" when whoissing, and nobody cares.
- wmf 14y agoNot really. All the blocks that are marked "reserved" are more like "unusable"; e.g. real equipment cannot use class E. People have been over this stuff with a fine-toothed comb. http://www.iana.org/assignments/ipv4-address-space/ipv4-address-space.xml http://www.iana.org/assignments/ipv4-address-space/ipv4-addr...
- lucb1e 14y agoI know, but I still think it's stupid. Nevermind though, it's an endless opinionated discussion.
- lolryan 14y agoAmateur radio also has an unused IPv4 /8 block as well. That $500 mil could go quite a ways towards building a few amsats.
- aidenn0 14y agoIs it held by the ARRL?
- X-Istence 14y agoHey, some of us HAMS are still using AMPRNet ... not many, but some. That being said, here is a list of people in charge of allocations: http://www.ampr.org/oldsite/amprnets.txt http://www.ampr.org/oldsite/amprnets.txt
- TheGateKeeper 14y agoI'm currently enjoying its usage as well. Whoever said it was unused doesn't know what they're talking about.
- jrockway 14y agoWho cares? IPv4 is a dead technology and this is like complaining that the UK has a bunch of fax machines in storage somewhere. 10 years ago, this would have been a waste. Now it doesn't even matter. Even Comcast supports IPv6.
- wglb 14y agoSo how do you envision the transition taking place? Given that 6 and 4 talk past each other.
- jrockway 14y agoThe transition has sort of already happened. Most software stacks support IPv6 now, and many server hosting companies are giving out IPv6 addresses like candy. (I think I have a /48 or something for jrock.us. That's 2 to the 48th IPv4 Internets! I have a lot of computers, but not that many.) All that's left are the clients, and the way I see that transition happening is in the low-cost sector. Sort of like an AOL where you won't have IPv4, so you'll have to access everything through a proxy except IPv6 sites. Eventually businesses will want to cater to this demographic and the stragglers will flip the IPv6 switch. With nobody on IPv4, it won't be a premium value-add anymore, and that era will be a distant memory of the past like BBSes are now. Right now the IPv4 situation is not bad enough to make widespread IPv6 support critical to one's economic viability yet. Being able to see the animated turtle on kame.net isn't quite enough of an incentive, but the incentives will slowly shift. (I see the same transition away from fossil fuels. Right now, an investment in alternative energies is pure speculation: it may pay off someday, but we don't know when that day is. When we've run out, though, the payoff will be clear: you will get infinite money the second you figure out some way to give humanity energy. This will encourage more investment than some nebulous LEED certification will. Tax credits are nice, but not as nice as cash.)
- geofft 14y ago"The transition has sort of already happened," he says, over IPv4. Seriously, unless you want to be posting to HN via IPv4 in 2050, there is clearly something major left undone. Don't call it a transition if you think that concept is undone, but it's not yet functionally possible to be on the Internet with no IPv4 stack or (possibly NATted) address, and I don't see that becoming the case anytime soon. See http://cr.yp.to/djbdns/ipv6mess.html http://cr.yp.to/djbdns/ipv6mess.html for a description of the problem that I mostly agree with. The depressing thing is that those complaints are no less valid a decade later.
- tptacek 14y agoThere are lots of stories like this. Many of them are worse; at least you can imagine that the UK is holding these addresses in reserve. There are companies with giant allocations that are holding them so that they can give every desktop and every printer in their enterprise a routable address; others are doing the same thing, but also operating flat, unrouted networks. More evidence for the core problem: fiat allocation doesn't work. If there was a functioning, liquid, accessible market for advertisable IP prefixes, you wouldn't have to convince anyone that a /8 was worth $1bn; it just would be.
- bo1024 14y ago...and, anyone who didn't have $1bn to spend would be SOL. There's plenty of numbers to go around; the sooner we get to v6 and get around this mess, the better.
- debacle 14y agoIf you need 16 million IP addresses, you probably have $1bn.
- cynicalkane 14y agoWhat the heck? If you want an /8 you're probably SOL anyway.
- pash 14y agoWhat an embarrassing failure of economic reasoning. IPv4 addresses are a scare resource. Acknowledging that, and allowing them to be traded at a price that reflects their value, is the surest way to get them out of the hands of those who are wasting them in the way tptacek and the article describe and into the hands of those who will do something more productive with them. Pricing IPv4 addresses would hasten adoption of IPv6 by providing a financial incentive to switch from IPv4 to IPv6 to those who can do so most easily (i.e., cheaply). In other words, if you want to "get around this mess", stop allocating scarce and valuable IPv4 addresses as if they have no value.
- 14y ago
- cbs 14y agoWe need to quit looking back at the v4 space like this, bite the bullet and deploy v6. It's already in use on some networks, and inevitable on 95+% of the rest. The amount of time spent bike-shedding "well, v4 isn't running out as fast as they say it is" or "NAT will save us" (lol, no) that time is better spent deploying v6. For many installations, its actually not that big of a deal to do.
- sjwright 14y agoAnd we will move, but it's not going to happen until 98% of the world's networking infrastructure (both public and private) is IP6 ready, which probably won't be for another decade.
- cbs 14y agoThat's the thing though. If everyone is waiting on everyone else, nothing gets done. If your network doesn't already support v6, you're the person everyone is waiting on! You don't need to wait for your upstream provider to supply you with v6, tunnels are super easy to get. The only exception to tunneling is if you're hosting a public-facing service, don't have v6 connectivity and don't trust existing tunnel providers. In this case: First, why are you at you're current host or colo center? They're probably shit. Second, set up a box at a provider with good connectivity to run the tunnel yourself. This is basically what we already do when we want to use our public v4 space but the ISP doesn't want to let us talk BGP.
- eddanger 14y ago51.0.0.0/8 the secret IP block otherwise known as Block 51.
- 7952 14y agoCan IP blocks actually be sold?
- drucken 14y agoYes. Privately and normally as part of bankruptcy proceedings. The most famous recent example is probably Microsoft's purchase of Nortel's addresses, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-12859585 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-12859585
- gioele 14y agoNot generally, say ARIN an RIPE: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPv4_address_exhaustion#Markets_in_IP_addresses http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPv4_address_exhaustion#Markets... IP blocks are "licensed", not sold. These licenses can be transferred, but only under certain strict conditions. The ARIN CEO stated [1] «As you may be aware, ARIN is the Regional Internet Registry (RIR) responsible for Internet number resource management for Canada, United States, and parts of the Caribbean. In keeping with the policies developed by the community in this region, there are two possible ways to transfer IPv4 number resources to another party (via merger & acquisition transfer or via specified transfer), and these are detailed in section 8 of the Number Resource Policy Manual on the ARIN website at <https://www.arin.net/policy/nrpm.html> https://www.arin.net/policy/nrpm.html> It is important to note that transfer of number resources via either method must be to another party that can demonstrate corresponding need. ARIN's registration services department can assist with this determination in advance or at the time of transfer. ARIN reiterates the importance of veracity in transfer requests and supporting documentation as fraudulent information can result in resource revocation.» NRPM section 8 [2] says «Number resources are nontransferable and are not assignable to any other organization unless ARIN has expressly and in writing approved a request for transfer. … It should be understood that number resources are not 'sold' under ARIN administration. Rather, number resources are assigned to an organization for its exclusive use for the purpose stated in the request, …» Older blocks allocated directly from IANA have different conditions attached to them that may render the transfer of the these licenses simpler or harder. [1] http://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2011-August/038888.html http://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2011-August/038888.... [2] https://www.arin.net/policy/nrpm.html#eight https://www.arin.net/policy/nrpm.html#eight
- infinitivium 14y agowhat if IP addresses were allocated / confirmed by a bitcoin-like network?
- izx 14y agoyou mean namecoin? http://www.bluishcoder.co.nz/2011/05/12/namecoin-a-dns-alternative-based-on-bitcoin.html http://www.bluishcoder.co.nz/2011/05/12/namecoin-a-dns-alter...
- TheGateKeeper 14y agoYou mean completely unstable and essentially useless? No thanks.
- dfox 14y agoEvery router would then need several gigabytes of memory for routing tables.
- jwatte 14y agoThis is why organizations should pay $1 per year for each IP address they own.
- fpp 14y agoWhen looking into unused IPv4 /8 blocks besides private companies, could somebody please explain how much of the 201,326,592 addresses (12x /8) allocated to the US DoD have ever been used
- wmf 14y agoThey'll never tell you and it doesn't matter since they'll never give those addresses up.
- Zenst 14y agoHow many mobile phones made per day that support some form of internet access and how many of those use IPV6? Scary thought is it not! The first real opertunity to move to IPV6 in any way would be mobile smartphones and there like and yet that is not happening. It realy is a case of the ISP's and mobile telco's that need to start initiating the IPV6 move and until they do nobody will be dragged into following. Maybe if it was illegal to sell devices that don't at least support IPV6. But of a messy situation when you can buy devices made brand new that still dont offer IPV6 support, criminal realy. Still when you look into the history of British railways and the better modern alternatives you can see how some legacy designs just carry on with there limitations of capacity oversight. Another aspect is cunsumers have in many respects forgotten how to complain to a company and let there frustrations out on the internet in area's were the companys offering the services will completely fail to notice and allow you to complain and vent of without them even knowing or indeed having to care. How many of you have asked there internet service provider if they support IPV6 or indeed what there plans are to offer it? Reason I ask is that I can bet it's lower than 1 in 100 or indeed 1 in 100,000. I can't even recall any one of my friends or anybody I know or have dealing with ever mentioning they had made such an enquiry. I know I have, please tell me I'm not alone at least.
- wmf 14y agoVerizon and T-Mobile are running quite a bit of IPv6 but nobody noticed since it just works.
- FuzzyDunlop 14y agoThe argument is that if our government disposed of this 'asset' now, they'd rake in almost £1bn. IPv6 is still not mainstream, so this figure can reasonably increase over time with the increase in IPv4 scarcity. Thus it stands to reason not to sell out just yet.
- nerd_in_rage 14y agoI have my own /24 routed to my basement. Back in the early/mid 90's could get their own provider independent block. If I knew now what I knew then, I would've gone for a class B block. lol.
- rightyeah 14y agoHow much does it cost to "produce" an /8? Nothing. In the "magical" world of the internet, you don't even need to build a network to use the addresses on. Nor do you need to prove that you actually have any sort of "rights" (as the legal kind) over the addresses. Because there is no one who can grant you such rights. Hate to spoil the magick trick, but no one owns the internet. The whole scheme works on cooperation of network admins and acquiescence of everyone else. And the top post claims it would be worth $1BB. Keep dreaming. The truth is that the value is not in addresses, the value is in the network, and those who own the infrastructure, but of course there is no single infrastructure for the internet because it's a network of networks, owned by various parties. The telephone company can charge you for a telephone number. It owns the network that you're going to use it on. If it didn't own the network, you would not pay for the number. You are paying to use the network. The number is just a formality. This same is not true for the internet and IP numbers. The RIR's don't own any networks. There isn't even a clear line to the source of their authority to "allocate" address space. Does the US Government own the internet? Good luck with that argument. RIR's charge fees to "allocate" addresses, an administrative job, but we have no idea how the fees are spent. Maybe to pay the CEO's generous salary? How much work is it to keep track of some numbers? Maybe we should ask IANA. The whole scheme works based on cooperation and acquiescence. No organisation ever paid $1BB for an /8. They got theirs for "free" (inconsequential maintenance fees notwithstanding).