5 ms·

> Price is not determined until a voluntary transition takes place youre talking about market value. price is definitely set before the transaction takes place

> Price is not determined until a voluntary transition takes place youre talking about market value. price is definitely set before the transaction takes place. you can set the price at whatever you like.

9rx 1y ago
> youre talking about market value. No. I am talking about price. Price measures what you are giving up to receive value. > price is definitely set before the transaction takes place. No. You're likely thinking of an offer. Offers are made before the transaction takes place. Offers are spoken of in terms of the price the seller (or buyer) hopes to see, but it is not yet set. Negotiation can still occur at this stage, as can rejection. Vendors with a lot of traffic are able to gain a pretty good handle on what consumers are willing to pay, so often, for all intents and purposes, the first offer and price end up being equivalent. Perhaps that is what you are thinking of? Regardless, CPI looks at what consumers are actually buying. No matter how you want to define price in some sort of vacuum, price with respect to CPI can only increase if the buyers are willing.
- skeezyboy 1y ago
  > No. I am talking about price. Price measures what you are giving up to receive value. but you said "Price is not determined until a voluntary transition takes place" so does it happen before or after the "transition" takes place? id say price is set before, market value is what actually someone paid for it and comes after
  - 9rx 1y ago
    > so does it happen before or after the "transition" takes place? As the quote you offered says, it is measured after. I suppose theoretically in some kind of bending of space and time it could be measured during the exact instant it is created, but as we return back to reality... It certainly cannot be measured before. One cannot measure that which does not exist. > market value is what actually someone paid for it and comes after Value is, let's say, intrinsic. Whereas price is the measurement of it. To use an analogy, it is like the difference between distance and length. > id say price is set before While you are certainly welcome to make up any old random definition on the spot, given that we're talking about price within the context of CPI we know it is not "set before". CPI measurement is taken in hindsight, after consumers have already made their purchases. The values it gathers are post-sale.
    - skeezyboy 1y ago
      >As the quote you offered says, it is measured after. i was quoting you... but you have tried to have it both ways. you said.... > Price measures what you are giving up to receive value. notice you didnt say gave, you said giving. There is a price before the "transaction" > Price is not determined until a voluntary transition takes place But we had a price before we made the purchase??? If you swap price with market value in the second quote youre completely right. Market Value is determined in this offer/sell kind of fashion precisely because it ISNT intrinsic.
      - 9rx 1y ago
        > but you have tried to have it both ways Nope. Your misinterpretation may have lead to you to believe that, but intent supersedes interpretation. Which you no doubt understand given that you came back to ask for clarification given the apparent discrepancy. That would have been completely pointless otherwise. > notice you didnt say gave, you said giving. There is a price before the "transaction" I'm pretty sure it said "transition", not "transaction". Regardless, while it is thoughtful of you to point out what lead to your misinterpretation, we already cleared this up in a previous comment. What are you trying to add here? > Market Value is determined in this offer/sell kind of fashion precisely because it ISNT intrinsic. The value was always there. We just don't know what it is until we create an environment that allows us to measure it. > If you swap price with market value You'll have to talk to the government agencies. I don't pick the terminology used around CPI. I am not sure where you got the idea that it is up to me? And I'm especially unsure of why you'd want it to be up to me given that you recognize that I am not the clearest of communicators.
    - skeezyboy 1y ago
      >but intent supersedes interpretation so dont worry about what i wrote, whats important was what i was thinking? fair enough If market value is the instrinsic value, how could two separate markets get different prices for the same asset? edit: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/methodologies/consumerpriceinflationincludesall3indicescpihcpiandrpiqmi#methodology-background https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/meth... methodology states it is based on prices quoted

9rx 1y ago

> youre talking about market value. No. I am talking about price. Price measures what you are giving up to receive value. > price is definitely set before the transaction takes place. No. You're likely thinking of an offer. Offers are made before the transaction takes place. Offers are spoken of in terms of the price the seller (or buyer) hopes to see, but it is not yet set. Negotiation can still occur at this stage, as can rejection. Vendors with a lot of traffic are able to gain a pretty good handle on what consumers are willing to pay, so often, for all intents and purposes, the first offer and price end up being equivalent. Perhaps that is what you are thinking of? Regardless, CPI looks at what consumers are actually buying. No matter how you want to define price in some sort of vacuum, price with respect to CPI can only increase if the buyers are willing.

skeezyboy 1y ago
> No. I am talking about price. Price measures what you are giving up to receive value. but you said "Price is not determined until a voluntary transition takes place" so does it happen before or after the "transition" takes place? id say price is set before, market value is what actually someone paid for it and comes after
- 9rx 1y ago
  > so does it happen before or after the "transition" takes place? As the quote you offered says, it is measured after. I suppose theoretically in some kind of bending of space and time it could be measured during the exact instant it is created, but as we return back to reality... It certainly cannot be measured before. One cannot measure that which does not exist. > market value is what actually someone paid for it and comes after Value is, let's say, intrinsic. Whereas price is the measurement of it. To use an analogy, it is like the difference between distance and length. > id say price is set before While you are certainly welcome to make up any old random definition on the spot, given that we're talking about price within the context of CPI we know it is not "set before". CPI measurement is taken in hindsight, after consumers have already made their purchases. The values it gathers are post-sale.
  - skeezyboy 1y ago
    >As the quote you offered says, it is measured after. i was quoting you... but you have tried to have it both ways. you said.... > Price measures what you are giving up to receive value. notice you didnt say gave, you said giving. There is a price before the "transaction" > Price is not determined until a voluntary transition takes place But we had a price before we made the purchase??? If you swap price with market value in the second quote youre completely right. Market Value is determined in this offer/sell kind of fashion precisely because it ISNT intrinsic.
    - 9rx 1y ago
      > but you have tried to have it both ways Nope. Your misinterpretation may have lead to you to believe that, but intent supersedes interpretation. Which you no doubt understand given that you came back to ask for clarification given the apparent discrepancy. That would have been completely pointless otherwise. > notice you didnt say gave, you said giving. There is a price before the "transaction" I'm pretty sure it said "transition", not "transaction". Regardless, while it is thoughtful of you to point out what lead to your misinterpretation, we already cleared this up in a previous comment. What are you trying to add here? > Market Value is determined in this offer/sell kind of fashion precisely because it ISNT intrinsic. The value was always there. We just don't know what it is until we create an environment that allows us to measure it. > If you swap price with market value You'll have to talk to the government agencies. I don't pick the terminology used around CPI. I am not sure where you got the idea that it is up to me? And I'm especially unsure of why you'd want it to be up to me given that you recognize that I am not the clearest of communicators.
  - skeezyboy 1y ago
    >but intent supersedes interpretation so dont worry about what i wrote, whats important was what i was thinking? fair enough If market value is the instrinsic value, how could two separate markets get different prices for the same asset? edit: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/methodologies/consumerpriceinflationincludesall3indicescpihcpiandrpiqmi#methodology-background https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/meth... methodology states it is based on prices quoted