5 ms·
The Murder of Charlie Kirk Didn't Help Anyone
- afavour 1y agoI don't think this is a remotely controversial viewpoint. The vast, vast majority of people (among those who even know who he is) think his murder is an awful act. But because clicks and outrage rule supreme we end up with screenshots of a couple of dozen nobodies saying controversial things used to paint the "other side" as unhinged and violent. I wish we could all move beyond it but we seem unable.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoEach side sanewashes themselves by amplifying the other side's most deranged extremists.
- tstrimple 1y agoOne side seems to keep electing their deranged extremists to represent them.
- johnnyanmac 1y agoIs this really "both sides"? Just for this community here, compared the reaction: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45202200 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45202200 To this one https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44276916 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44276916 You won't even get the names of the latter on this site if this is how you consume news.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoYou missed my point. I'm not talking about the violence. Charlie Kirk gets killed. There's some number of right-wing zealots who go on X or BlueSky or whatever and say "Kill all the Democrats!" Then the left (all the left, not just the zealots) points to that and says "See, they're completely insane!". But it's not all the right, it's some number of unhinged plus some number of trolls. Same thing happens with the left. AOC says something or Mandami says something, and the right (not just the complete nut jobs) say "look, they're completely insane!" Both sides use the statements of the extreme of the other side to paint the entirety of the other side as complete wackos.
- silverquiet 1y agoI've seen it referred to as nut picking, and certainly it's something that both sides are prone to. I'd say the difference is that one side has chosen to elect an obvious malignant narcissist to represent them who literally declared war on Chicago over the weekend and regularly vilifies entire groups of Americans.
- krapp 1y ago[flagged]
- iszomer 1y agoOr maybe we can acknowledge that we are all potentially being played. - Chase Hughes, former US Navy behavioral analyst -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=azE7nqqQMmo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=azE7nqqQMmo
- rasengan 1y ago> But I recognize that violence can sometimes become a necessity—which is why I say that people should forgo the use of violence unless all non-violent paths to resolve a conflict have either been exhausted or taken off the table. > Lethal violence is the line that should only be crossed when it, too, is the last available option. No, violence is never necessary. Once you use violence, you start the downward spiral of perpetual hatred; after all, if someone harms one that you love, forgiveness becomes difficult. The only solution to perpetual hatred is peace, understanding and love. As long as you think violence is a solution, you'll gravitate toward the short term gratification that may or may not come therewith. Get that out of your head. Violence is never the answer.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoSo if you were in Utah yesterday and came upon the shooter preparing to fire, you wouldn't kick the rifle out of his hand?
- nullocator 1y agoI don't think this is a fair question. Answering the question you asked to someone else: It's hard for me to personally know how I'd react in such a situation. I'd like to say that I'd do everything possible to stop one person from killing another even if (lesser) violence is required to do so, and I think that's okay. But I think it's equally likely that I could be afraid or unsure of how to react in such a situation and therefore fail to act which is also okay I think? Not everyone wants to be or can be a hero or a statistic.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoIt's perfectly fine that you wouldn't know what you'd do in that hypothetical. But you answered the question I asked, you'd choose the lesser violence to stop the greater violence. I think a lot of people would agree. The person I asked said "violence is never the answer" so I wanted to explore that.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- asmz4 1y ago[dead]
- cosmicgadget 1y ago> But I recognize that violence can sometimes become a necessity—which is why I say that people should forgo the use of violence unless all non-violent paths to resolve a conflict have either been exhausted or taken off the table. This is admirable and works in a lot of situations. But exhausting nonviolent options can foreclose success and be abused by an opponent.
- krapp 1y agoYes, this was a constant refrain by white moderates during the Civil Rights era, that black people should absolutely and under all circumstances refrain from violence and remain civil and respect the law.. all while they were being beaten, shot and lynched with regularity. MLK Jr. said such people were worse than the klan. The the feds shot him in the head. It is an understandable argument but like "think of the children" it can also be used to normalize the violence of the state and de-legitimize dissent. The entire country is flying flags flags at half staff in honor of Charlie Kirk. His murder is filling headlines across the country. It's being declared an act of domestic terrorism, and right-wingers are calling for civil war. Meanwhile the explicitly politically motivated murders of Melissa and Mark Holtman, the attacks on Nancy Pelosi and her husband, and the plot to kidnap Gretchen Whitmer go utterly unremarked upon. We notice when the rhetoric about nonviolence implies that only one side should stand down.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoA civil war? They run all three branches.
- krapp 1y agoWell, war against Democrats, leftists, liberals, gay and transgender people, black and brown people and everyone else they consider the perfidious enemies of God and who they've been threatening to put up against the wall for years now. I don't know if it technically counts as "civil war" if the government declares war on its own citizens, and one half of the population declares war against the other half. It's not as though "declaring war" actually means anything in the US. Maybe it's just sparkling fascism.
- taylodl 1y agoBlah blah blah blah blah blah blah. Let's not forget the liberals who've been murdered and attacked: - Gabrielle Giffords (2011) - shot in the head, survived. - Gretchen Whitmer (2020) - kidnapping plot foiled by the FBI. - Paul Pelosi (2022) - hammer blows to the head, survived. - Josh Shapiro (2024) - arson attacked family home while Josh Shapiro along with this wife and kids were residing at the time. - Melissa and John Hoffman (2025) - Murdered by a man posing as law enforcement. Now you want me to get concerned that MAGA might get upset with the murder of Charlie Kirk? I'm supposed to get concerned that MAGA is going to use this event as a rally cry - a rally cry for what, exactly? More violence? What does that say about them? That's just a threat they make to further their use of fear and intimidation to silence their critics. As I told my grown children time and time again while they were growing up: don't ever use the excuse that someone "made you" do something to rationalize your behavior. You chose your behavior, stop making excuses to justify it. Own it.
- mothballed 1y agoThe Whitmer plot is interesting because it was both 'foiled' by the FBI and the plot itself was something like half police informants or employees. If I recall several of the alleged plotters were found not guilty or hung jury because some of the jurors were having trouble with who even came up with and encouraged the plot.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoImagine that defense. "Well sure, if one person convinced you to kidnap a governor, that's on you. But in this case several people said it'd be a good idea to kidnap a governor so you're blameless!"
- mothballed 1y ago>Imagine that defense There is no need to "imagine" -- many of them were found not guilty, and their defenses are openly available. You can pull up the cases, and I think the situation was a little beyond a sort of one liner defense or anything like that. Brandon Caserta also was featured in several interviews and commented on it, for a briefer view of his situation. Either way I think we should be concerned that the government is generating violent conspiracies against the government while intentionally trying to drag 3rd parties along with it. I also just kind of object to calling something "foiled" when the entity foiling it appears to have likely been the one generating it in the first place.
- mothballed 1y agoWell it helped Charlie Kirk, in one aspect. I had no idea who he was, now I'm tempted to watch his videos and see what points he was making. I'm curious what he has to say that a crazy guy and loads of people on social media seemed to think was so dangerous he needed to die for it.
- techpineapple 1y agoYou're argument is that you think it's a good idea to base your intellectual curiosity on the <inverse> priorities of a raving madman? Do you think that insanity is precise enough to understand the truly valuable ideas of the world, it just heads in the opposite direction? Better apparently than other methods of discerning valuable information?
- mothballed 1y agoI have lots of inputs to my curiosity. A guy I've never heard of getting assassinated and it making to the top of news, while a bunch of other people cheer it on, is one input. If I just randomly hear some guy was shot by the local schizophrenic, no I probably won't look up their videos.
- CamperBob2 1y ago[flagged]
- mothballed 1y agoI don't really know much at all about the guy's political views, the bit about gang shootings is the only thing I've ever heard from his mouth. I am curious why the world is in a better place now that his wife and kids have to deal with the trauma and aftermath of picking up the pieces of their life and moving on. Sounds like he must have been a pretty bad guy.
- CamperBob2 1y agoSounds like he must have been a pretty bad guy. He was basically the founder and figurehead of the MAGA youth movement. So he is probably as responsible as anyone for the election of Trump and all that has happened as a result. In my book that indeed makes him a pretty bad guy. Essentially, if you want to resort to the usual Nazi cliches, what happened here was that MAGA lost their Goebbels rather than their Horst Wessel.
- jacquesm 1y agoI'm against murderers and I'm against agitators (which is just about synonymous with influencers in politics). Kirk did a lot of damage. And whoever did this did a lot of damage too. I'm not sure about where the balance between those two lies but it irks me that you're supposed to be either on the side of the murderer or on the side of Kirk with zero room for more complex viewpoints. What irks me even more is the cynical way in which the usual suspects have already decided this is what they needed to further their agenda.
- beAbU 1y ago[flagged]
- amradio1989 1y agoTo be clear, are we talking about agitators the likes of Martin Luther King? Or something else? Because I fail to see how anything in politics changes without agitators. Without agitators, we'd all still be living under monarchies, dictators, and who knows what else. I'm curious about what you mean. As for taking sides, I'm not sure why taking the side of a man who was wrongfully murdered irks you. Its basic ethics. You don't have to agree with him, or even support their views, to denounce his murder. Unless you have an issue with people like Kirk being allowed to live, I'm not sure where the conflict is.