5 ms·
Are hotel room locks really that big a target? If you're in the room, set the deadbolt. When you leave, take your valuables. The easiest way into a hotel roo
by ams6110 14y ago
Are hotel room locks really that big a target? If you're in the room, set the deadbolt. When you leave, take your valuables.
The easiest way into a hotel room is social engineering via the housekeeping staff.
- daeken 14y agoThe deadbolt doesn't do anything with this, for what it's worth. The deadbolt on Onity locks is software-controlled; that is, there's a privacy switch that's triggered when you throw the deadbolt, and it checks the value of that when you put in a card. If you use a card with the 'privacy override' flag, or you use the Portable Programmer (or my opening device), the lock opens regardless of whether or not you use the deadbolt, as it's disengaged by the lock mechanism when you turn the handle.
- montecarl 14y agoI think he is referring to a manually operated dead bolt or those latches at the top of the door. The locks that can only be set and unset from inside of the room.
- daeken 14y agoLatches will work, but 99.9% of doors with Onity locks will only have the deadbolt inside the Onity lock, which is vulnerable to the problem I detailed above. Just something to keep in mind.
- jusben1369 14y agoNo no you're missing the point I think. Nearly every hotel room has a big old manual separate bolt set up higher and away from key based locking system. Slides open maybe 2 inches etc. Twice in my life the hotel person has given my room to someone else by mistake (I travel a lot for work). That is, I'll be in there, twice late at night, and someone else puts in a key and it works. After the first time I always set that manual bolt no matter what - just in case. Not that I think there's any real merit to the original point that kicked off this particular thread.
- nopassrecover 14y agoI think you're missing the point - Onity locks don't usually have this "big old manual separate bolt" as they're sold as "deadbolt inclusive".
- jusben1369 14y agoIt's pretty rare to not see them (can't remember when i haven't) due to the reason I list.
- mkjones 14y agoYou mean like one of these, right? http://cache4.asset-cache.net/xc/87800053-deadbolt-lock-and-chain-on-hotel-room-door-photos-com.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=910C62E22B9F47AA87CB891AEBAF7DB1159506FE70A4D5387863F5603F1371CFE30A760B0D811297 http://cache4.asset-cache.net/xc/87800053-deadbolt-lock-and-...
- nopassrecover 14y agoDoes anyone actually assume hotels are secure (in a sense other than good faith) though? There are so many points for allocation errors on the cards themselves, dozens of "all-access" cards available to both internal and contracted staff, and different people in every room most nights (e.g. no neighbour familiarity about an issue).
- daeken 14y agoFew people assume hotels are truly secure, but generally when something goes wrong, you have an accurate audit trail. That is, if someone breaks into room 413 using a legitimate card, I can go back and say "ok, Michael was the one who encoded this card for him, after the guest had already checked in". You can't do that with the opening device.
- nodata 14y ago> When you leave, take your valuables. So I'm in a foreign land, and I should carry around all my worldly possessions with me? How is that safer? (Why can't the hotel provide a lock that works?)
- lmm 14y agoLeave them in the hotel safe (many will give you one in your room) if you prefer. It just doesn't seem worth the hotel putting serious effort into the lock on the room door, because that's always going to be insecure, if only because the minimum-wage cleaning staff need access to all the rooms.
- nodata 14y agoI can't fit all of my valuables in a hotel safe. If the hotel wants to fit a lock that doesn't prevent easy access to my room, and my stuff gets stolen, they can meet my lawyer.
- dalke 14y agoWhat's the point of mentioning minimum-wage here? Would your logic change if the staff weren't paid minimum wage? If you are staying at a hotel were the staff was paid above minimum wage, would you feel more secure? The BLS says that the median wage for "Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners" is $9.32. Federal minimum wage is $7.25 per hour. Obviously then, most are not paid minimum wage. In any case, people also want a long-term job. An aspect of keycard entry is that you have a record of what people entered the room. If only one person entered when something was stolen, then that person is a definite suspect, and may be fired. But if it's possible to circumvent that security, then it's also possible to frame others.
- lmm 14y ago>If you are staying at a hotel were the staff was paid above minimum wage, would you feel more secure? Yes. Seriously, is that even a question? Wouldn't you? Higher wages mean two things: the staff have more to lose by being fired, and by implication the hotel puts more effort into its staff. Which means they're probably recruiting more carefully and putting more effort into staff loyalty once they're there.
- jbester 14y agoMost hotels have the a) long skinny security latches (i.e. http://www.shutterstock.com/pic.mhtml?id=16874026 http://www.shutterstock.com/pic.mhtml?id=16874026) - those are specifically used so they can be opened by hotel staff using a special tool (http://www.nathosp.com/product/sl2/hotel_room_door_locks_and_locksets http://www.nathosp.com/product/sl2/hotel_room_door_locks_and...) the deadbolt is typically controlled by the electronic lock and can be overridden.