4 ms·
U.S. Added 911,000 Fewer Jobs in the Year Ended in March
- gnabgib 1y agoOngoing discussion (177 points, 152 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45182111 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45182111
- punkbit 1y agoRecession! Ghost jobs, time wasters, unemployment, etc.
- supportengineer 1y agoThere must be a way to opt-out by constructing a sane, parallel world where things just work.
- eMPee584 1y agohow about drumming up some public support for an open access post-scarcity economy where we shift focus to quality instead of profit and use our resources for building resilient planetary infrastructure...
- gruez 1y ago>how about drumming up some public support for an open access post-scarcity economy where [...] Right... as if scarcity is some sort of social construct that can be abolished by "drumming up some public support"? Maybe we should start small and start with energy scarcity, by "drumming up" some support for cold fusion?
- darepublic 1y agoIts not abolishing it its about adapting to it
- gruez 1y agoHow should we "adapt" to the non-existence of fusion power?
- darepublic 1y agoMy mistake I interpreted post scarcity as post consumerist abundance
- gruez 1y agoJust like the global south "just" needs better governance to boost economic growth?
- more_corn 1y agoI wonder if it’s because increasing the cost of doing business with massive tariffs nobody asked for or needs is causing businesses to get nervous and stop hiring. Naww, must be someone else’s fault.
- QuizzicalCarbon 1y agoThis data is from the Biden administration, predating the current Trump policies.
- CaptWillard 1y agoWell, seeing as this is a record of jobs created last year ... yeah.
- amradio1989 1y agoNot to pile on, but there is a huge public misunderstanding when it comes to economic data. The data is lagging, usually by a full year. The policies that lead to that data are from the year before data collection, at a minimum, more likely two+ years. Economic policies generally take time to ripple through the economy. Generally. There are exceptions. Interest rates tend to affect things pretty quickly relative to other changes.
- spwa4 1y agoSo it was the effect Trump's first term then?
- amradio1989 1y agoThe period covers March24-March25. Two years prior to March24 is March22. It would have been the 2nd year of Bidens presidency.
- moc_was_wronged 1y ago[dead]
- Apes 1y agoPeople often get hyper-focused on a single cause, but there is a whole range of forces driving a sharp decline in jobs. All of this is visible, yet we are marching toward an economic crisis of our own making. I believe the best term for this is "gray rhino". * Tariffs and Trade Uncertainty – Elevated tariffs and rapidly shifting trade policies are raising costs for manufacturers and discouraging hiring and investment (Investopedia; Atlanta Fed survey; CBO analyses). * Automation and AI Displacement – Automation and AI, especially in low-skill occupations, are reducing new job creation and wages for some workers (academic studies in arXiv and PMC). * Restrictive Immigration Policies – Tightened immigration and visa processes are straining labor supply, particularly in sectors that rely on immigrant workers (Axios, 2025 labor coverage). * Small Business Strain from Economic Pressure – Tariff-related uncertainty is leading small businesses to slow hiring or lay off employees (Joint Economic Committee report, 2025). * Offshoring and Outsourcing Trends – Technological advances are enabling offshoring and automation, substituting domestic labor with remote or machine-based alternatives (academic research in World Development, 2024).
- gruez 1y agoIs this AI generated? Besides the em-dashes, I don't think anyone cites "Investopedia" as a source (not the specific entity, but in that format), or makes citations in (source, year) format.
- Apes 1y agoI created the list and had an LLM review it to ensure I wasn't just pulling stuff out of thin air. Looks like it switched my hyphens for em-dashes.
- kelipso 1y agoIsn’t it usually the opposite you are supposed to do? LLM output and make sure it is factual because LLMs cannot tell what is factual or not? I can’t even get myself to read what you “wrote” because of the LLM tinge though lol.
- mperham 1y agoI will point out that our labor data can no longer be trusted as the organization is no longer politically neutral. Pushing the jobs record down means more blame for Biden and a much lower bar for Trump to meet in order to "improve" future jobs numbers. > Trump ordered McEntarfer's removal on August 1 after data showed a surprise weakening in the U.S. labor market last month. The BLS employment report revealed meaningful revisions to job figures for the prior two months that raised investor worries that the Federal Reserve may need to play catch-up with interest rate cuts. https://www.reuters.com/business/inflation-data-draw-scrutiny-after-bls-firing-21-trillion-tips-market-risk-2025-08-11/ https://www.reuters.com/business/inflation-data-draw-scrutin...
- NotMichaelBay 1y agoAgreed, the Trump administration is _heavily_ leaning on this as evidence to support their argument that "Biden's economy" was a "disaster": > Today, the BLS released the largest downward revision on record proving that President Trump was right: Biden’s economy was a disaster and the BLS is broken. > The benchmark revisions make clear the economy President Trump inherited was even weaker than we thought. https://www.whitehouse.gov/articles/2025/09/bls-revisions-show-president-trump-was-right-again/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/articles/2025/09/bls-revisions-sh...
- amradio1989 1y agoThe economy is not great and has not been great for years. That has been the reality for almost all Americans. It’s very odd to make this about Trump vs Biden. This has been brewing for nearly two decades. Forever-QE made us forget about the real health of the economy.
- T-A 1y agoIt would be very odd if it didn't follow on the heels of this: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2025/sep/04/trump-bureau-labor-statistics-chief https://www.theguardian.com/business/2025/sep/04/trump-burea...
- 1y ago
- anon291 1y agoThird worldification of the United States.
- goku12 1y agoPlease remember that the 'Third World' doesn't refer to countries in squalor. It referred to the bloc of nations that were not aligned with either the Western bloc (First World) led by the US or the Eastern/Communist bloc (Second World) led by the USSR. Quoting directly from Wikipedia: > Strictly speaking, "Third World" was a political, rather than economic, grouping. > Since most Third World countries were economically poor and non-industrialized, it became a stereotype to refer to developing countries as "third-world countries". > Since the dissolution of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War, the term Third World has decreased in use. It is being replaced with terms such as developing countries, least developed countries or the Global South.
- akhosravian 1y agoThat’s a cool historical fact but the modern colloquial usage is synonymous with poor (financially) countries.
- goku12 1y agoA 'modern colloquial usage' that's mildly described as a 'stereotype' on Wikipedia. A more precise description is that it's a revisionist redefinition that represents the disdain towards countries that refused to sacrifice their sovereignty for money, after suffering extended periods of exploitation. And it predictably undermines the historical picture of the socioeconomic realities that existed during the cold war - a picture that doesn't resemble in any way what the US is inflicting upon itself now.
- pcurve 1y agoWith all the innovation in AI, you'd think there's more accurate way to track jobs data.
- morgoths_bane 1y agoit's almost like there actually isn't any innovation
- cwsx 1y agoit's almost like the administration doesn't care for accurate data
- bzmrgonz 1y agoI guess the whole labor department is gonna get fired by Trump.
- notepad0x90 1y agoTrump took office in January, so I'm guessing this has nothing to do with tariffs like people are implying? I didn't read the article (paywall), but if that is the case why was this misreported? couldn't he have just blamed biden or something? Either way, that sounds like a big number, is it interest rates that are causing this?